Can Opener Test
-
Ashley? -
Heh, I have a few MT's I can try, but consider I eat maybe one canned food every month or so, it'll take a long time. :P
-
jzmtl: That's why I thought it might be useful to get more folks involved. Not many people open tons of cans in a day, or maybe even a week. Heck, it took me 2 weeks before I opened enough cans to give each opener I had a shot to open one, let alone doing enough to get 'good' with any of them.
Also, I just had a test with a P-51 on a can of coffee (which i think is a #10 size). It was 70 seconds. I've never opened a can this size with a P-51 before. I had a couple slips where the tool hopped the rim, so lost a bit of time. Speed was good. Comfort at the end was not. I wouldn't want to do more than one #10 can with one at a single sitting. However, this is also only one of a handful of cans I've ever opened with a P-51. I'm sure a bit of practice would increase the speed. I don't think I'd do as fast with a vic with equal practice.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
jzmtl: That's why I thought it might be useful to get more folks involved. Not many people open tons of cans in a day, or maybe even a week. Heck, it took me 2 weeks before I opened enough cans to give each opener I had a shot to open one, let alone doing enough to get 'good' with any of them.Also, I just had a test with a P-51 on a #10 can of coffee. It was 70 seconds. I've never opened a can this size with a P-51 before. I had a couple slips where the tool hopped the rim, so lost a bit of time. Speed was good. Comfort at the end was not. I wouldn't want to do more than one #10 can with one at a single sitting. However, this is also only one of a handful of cans I've ever opened with a P-51. I'm sure a bit of practice would increase the speed. I don't think I'd do as fast with a vic with equal practice.
Hate to say this but...
The thickness of steel in a large can of coffee isn't even close to the steel in the green bean cans. jzmtl can comment on how tough the green bean cans are. He had a chance to test MT openers at last years NAMU.
-
Forgot to mention, when I tried to open a green bean can with my P-51, it folded the point over on the 3rd plunge.
-

Not even gonna bother.
-
Putting this all into perspective:
Today is Thursday. Usually, I am alloted a burger on Thursdays. It's an understanding that my mostly-vegetarian husband and I have. I eat very inexpensive meat (usually chicken) when I eat it at all at home, and once a week I get a burger.
I told him today that I was apparently going to have to use my burger fund to instead get #10 cans of food, to get more info on the 'great raging can opener debate of 2012'.
His Response: 'No, you're getting a burger.'
He has reached the end of his desire to put up with my crazy. Further testing postponed. Sorry, I was having fun with my crazy, too....
-
Lynn,
If you still have the coffee can lid, PM me an address and I'll send a SASE. Send me the coffee lid. I'll mic it and a green bean lid.
-
Meh. Just wait a while. #10 can can't be more than a few dollars. I'll swing one some time soon.
And, just to be clear, if I got (for instance) fruit, because I think there's a chance of actually finishing a can of peaches, is that going to be up to your standards, or do they use thicker metal on boiled vegetables compared to fruit in syrup.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Meh. Just wait a while. #10 can can't be more than a few dollars. I'll swing one some time soon.And, just to be clear, if I got (for instance) fruit, because I think there's a chance of actually finishing a can of peaches, is that going to be up to your standards, or do they use thicker metal on boiled vegetables compared to fruit in syrup.
Nope. Canned fruit, vegetables and potatoes are all in the same kind of can.
-
One more question, not directly related, but might be important for prepper folk. Are the #10 cans used by the LDS canneries going to be the same as the fruit/veggie cans? This isn't important to me, but MAY be important to people who stockpile food in 25-year shelf-life #10s.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
One more question, not directly related, but might be important for prepper folk. Are the #10 cans used by the LDS canneries going to be the same as the fruit/veggie cans? This isn't important to me, but MAY be important to people who stockpile food in 25-year shelf-life #10s.The real answer is: I don't know.
But the cans I open have a coating inside, that prevents the contents from directly contacting the metal (I assume to prevent corrosion).
-
MAJOR UPDATE....
Today, the EZ DUZ IT can opener arrived (from Amazon.com). I had forgotten to get one, but when my wife said the OXO can opener couldn't open #10 cans anymore, I remembered this thread and quickly ordered.
Tonight, it was put to the test. The BossLady says it is the BEST can opener she has ever used. Extremely heavy duty. Here are some photos:
OXO and EZ DUZ IT



So Lynn: I officially concede.
:) -
Ummm... wow...
Well, crap. What do I argue about NOW? :D
I got one some time back as well, a few months ago. I only replaced my old Swing-A-Way, due to 'crud' on the cutting wheel.
I hope the EZ-DUZ-IT gives you years of long life. And yeah, they're built like frickin' tanks. I'm going to have to pass the torch on to you, Mr. Whippy, on reporting back about the long-term durability of the EZ-DUZ-IT versus #10 cans. I just don't open enough (or, really any, ever) to give it the workout it deserves.
If you'd like, just for fun, do a time trial on it on a #10.
In the event that this is the last of the can opener discussion, I'm putting in links to the other 2 related threads I did, time trials on 15oz and #10 cans.
15oz can time trials...
/post/595477#10 cans time trials...
/post/596469 -
Hope Lynn LeFey doesn't mind me posted here on her thread. Was after another can of peaches, for an afternoon snack, when I decided to compare the Charge TTi & Climber can openers again, and post the pictorial results.
Maybe Leatherman might be interested in the results as well, since their product left metal splinters on the outer edge!

Test subject: A delicious can of Freestone Peaches.


Contenders: Leatherman Charge TTi, Victorinox Climber, US Speaker P-38



Pictorial results will show the outer edge of the cut, over-view looking down with the lid, and inside the can views.
Outer Edge of Can
Leatherman Charge TTi

Victorinox Climber

US Speaker P-38

Can Edge & Lid View
Leatherman Charge TTi ~ Note: Left behind many metal splinters.

Victorinox Climber

US Speaker P-38

Inside The Can View
Leatherman Charge TTi

Victorinox Climber

US Speaker P-38

Conclusion: All had cut the same can open and without much effort.
• Leatherman can opener left behind unsafe metal splinters.
• Victorinox' Swiss can opener takes a bit to get used to, yet does seem to open slightly faster & easier, and leaves a safer working surface.
• US Speaker also excelled in performance, though still on a keyring it was a lot slower. However it did not create metallic splinters or a rough edge. The lid could double as a formed-serrated steak knife too. ;) -
A closer look at the edges of the Leatherman Charge TTi & Victorinox Climber surface:
Leatherman Charge TTi - Splintered outer edge, safer inside edge

Victorinox Climber - Smooth outer edge, fairly safe inside edge

-
I dont mind inthe least that others post their can opener stuff here. It keeps it all in fewer threads and makes it easier to find.
I dont recall any problems with metal splinters from any of my openers, although a number of them did chew rims up. Something to keep in mind.
Also, we.re under a tornado watch, and I,m on my Kindle ATM, so expect bad punctuation. :D
-
I've had Leatherman opener result in a few metal slivers, in my finger, too. Pretty annoying.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login