Wire saws?
-
But in a survival situation would you rely on it? Everyone I have ever used has snapped. However I have had the same PCS for 4 years now and use it not only in fun. but use it in the yard thrown over tall branches using long ropes.
-
That PCS looks pretty impressive. :)
-
@hawkchucker said:
But in a survival situation would you rely on it? Everyone I have ever used has snapped. However I have had the same PCS for 4 years now and use it not only in fun. but use it in the yard thrown over tall branches using long ropes.In a survival situation, I'd rather not trust my life to one,but they can be made to work for light shelter building, but yeah hawks right they will break on you sooner or later :(, trust in you farmer or spirit though as they'll get the job done reliably :)
Here's a review of my saw...
-
WOW Very impressive review. I never saw that style before, but it is the same chain. I love mine and it sharpens up really nice with the Chainsaw file.
This is one piece of kit I do feel everyone should have in an outdoor kit. It will really cut way faster than a axx.
-
And quieter too :)
It's part of my regular bushcrafting kit, and really has been one of my better buys :)
-
I used to have a wire saw about 5 years ago. As long as you keep WD-40 on it in the bag it will work. But as Micky stated you have to give them time to cool down.. I think I will try one of those PCS' Hawk!
-
But would you trust it 100%?
Trust me Leatherman you will never go back to a wire saw after playing with this toy! -
I never use a wire saw to begin with! But, I will try one of those out, for sure!
-
@Leatherman123 said:
I never use a wire saw to begin with! But, I will try one of those out, for sure!You might want to edit your first post mate, as it sounds like you contradicting yourself in the second one :)
-
If I ever get a wild hair up my butt I may get one of the wire saws and try it out. I know the cheap ones are junk but supposedly this one is NATO approved so maybe it's better than most of the other ones. The pocket chainsaw looks good but I was kinda looking for something I could put in my wallet. Of course if I have my Farmer on me cutting through wood won't be too much of an issue.
-
I used to use them five years ago but not anymore!
-
@ducktapehero said:
If I ever get a wild hair up my butt I may get one of the wire saws and try it out. I know the cheap ones are junk but supposedly this one is NATO approved so maybe it's better than most of the other ones. The pocket chainsaw looks good but I was kinda looking for something I could put in my wallet. Of course if I have my Farmer on me cutting through wood won't be too much of an issue.There still a good back up plan, I've got one in my PSK, I just wouldn't have it as my only means of cutting wood :)
Great Idea about putting it in you wallet though mate
, I've got no money in mine, but plenty of room for a saw :D -
@micky d said:
If I ever get a wild hair up my butt I may get one of the wire saws and try it out. I know the cheap ones are junk but supposedly this one is NATO approved so maybe it's better than most of the other ones. The pocket chainsaw looks good but I was kinda looking for something I could put in my wallet. Of course if I have my Farmer on me cutting through wood won't be too much of an issue.
There still a good back up plan, I've got one in my PSK, I just wouldn't have it as my only means of cutting wood :)
Great Idea about putting it in you wallet though mate
, I've got no money in mine, but plenty of room for a saw :DMate, you could probably fit a full sized chain saw in yours with all that space! :D
-
I probably could :'( :'( :D
-
@ducktapehero said:
http://www.bestglide.com/Wire_Saw_Info.htmlI was watching Survivorman a couple of weeks ago and he tried one of these wire saws. His broke and he declared it pretty much useless. I was wondering if perhaps he had a cheap one and if the one that is in the link above would be better. I tried one years ago but I was underwhelmed by it but that was probably a cheap one too. Does anyone have any experience with the one linked above?
I have several of the NATO-type wire saws I got at a local military surplus shop and I carry one for emergencies.
Supposedly the NATO-type are a better grade of saw than the cheaper varieties available. The NATO-type are inexpensive enough and also compact and fairly lightweight.
I've practiced with this saw for shelter building, i.e. cutting small diameter trees to use for poles and stakes, then using them to set up a tarp with paracord.
I managed to break two while learning. One when I pulled hard on a saw to try to free it when it bound up halfway through a small tree. Another, learning to cut more slowly and to allow the saw time to cool down after finishing one job before starting another job. After the first two, I haven't broken any more.
The main thing is just to take your time and try to avoid binding and over-stressing the wire. If you practice with the saw to learn its quirks, and if you don't get in a hurry, then it should work OK.
My overall impression: if you practice beforehand to learn how to use the saw efficiently without breaking it, and limit your cutting to small - say up to 2 inch diameter - trees, then it should be OK for emergency shelter
building.It's definitely not a tool suitable for routine woodcrafting or routine cutting of wood for fires. Think emergency use only.
.
-
I read something ages ago from one of the guys who developed the current NATO wire saw. Apparantly it's main use is as an escape tool, and is not meant for general purpose use. It's expected to fail after cutting a certain number of wooden posts.
If I can find the site i'll post a link.Doug Ritter carries one in his mini survival kit.
http://www.equipped.org/drperskit.htm -
@appletree_man said:
I read something ages ago from one of the guys who developed the current NATO wire saw. Apparantly it's main use is as an escape tool, and is not meant for general purpose use. It's expected to fail after cutting a certain number of wooden posts.
If I can find the site i'll post a link.Doug Ritter carries one in his mini survival kit.
http://www.equipped.org/drperskit.htmI'd be interested in a read of that if you ever come across it mate :)
-
I'm pretty sure it's somewhere on the Bushcraft UK forum, but for some reason I can't open the site >:(
-
@appletree_man said:
I'm pretty sure it's somewhere on the Bushcraft UK forum, but for some reason I can't open the site >:(It never was the most reliable site ::), it'll probably be back online soon though :)
-
Here it is :)
http://www.bushcraftuk.com/forum/showpost.php?p=258883&postcount=13
And the entire thread is here,
http://www.bushcraftuk.com/forum/showthread.php?p=258883#post258883
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login