Victorinox Spirit X or LM Charge TTi
-
The Charge is a good tool, the Spirit is an EXCELLENT tool!
The Charge does have it's place and there ARE scenarios where it would have the upper hand (diamond file, bit driver for non-standard drivers), but for everything else ... Spirit X, no contest!!!
-
let's continue to collect votes to see what your preferred taste is in this community.
meanwhile, i found out that on ebay (stuff-4-men) the Charge TTi costs 75$ plus 17$ shipping (it's not global FREE shipping as i had initially thought) plus 19% import taxes for my country. That's about 110$ grand total, or ~83.xx€. Far far away from the 65€ of the OP, and it would never come into my mind to spend that much money on a tool which i dont really need and just want to fiddle with.
and seeing that amazonDOTcom has discounted prices for all Leatherman products with FREE shipping to U.S. addresses i shouldnt buy any LM product from abroad. paying ~twice as much as a regular U.S. amazon shopper does totally spoils the fun and joy.
i've checked the price trend for the Spirit and Spirit X too. In the past years (e.g. 2010 and 2011) the price went up (as it does now!) during spring and summer and then all of a sudden dropped by >10€ in fall/autumn and stayed low until after Xmas. It will be my pleasure to pay 54€ for the Spirit X (should be easier to sharpen the main blade than the butter bread blade of the regular Spirit) in fall if i am still in the market for premium MT's.
SAK's (Tinker Deluxe, ..) offer much functionality for the money --i am impressed-- and are even handier for RL tasks so i will look into buying one too/instead. Personally i would assume that the Spirit provides much more joy .. and i do have joyous experience with 5$ MT's from the grocery discounter (LIDL, ALDI, Germany). If i really *needed *a multifunctional tool, especially for EDC, i wouldnt hesitate buying a SAK. Since my main motivation is not actual need but pure joy of ownership (fiddling, fondling, playing, caressing haha, admiring, showing off, .. you get the point ;=), i'll most likely stick with the idea of a MT, and no SAK.
EUR-prices of Leatherman's are not enjoyable so i would wait for a friend to bring a LM from his USA trip if, after the Spirit, i still want another MT (for the joy).
If you guys can remember what you had paid for your copy of the Spirit (Spirit X, ..) or Charge (TTi, Wave, ..), please share. Nutnfancy mentioned "55US$" for the Spirit at the end of his video review.. wow. That's a great price!!

-
If you do decide on the Spirit, you may as well contact Tim (Felinevet) here in the forums; he may be able to sort you out. You can also have a look at edcsource.com (I know there are at least two Spirits on there right now). You may also post a thread in the "tools needed" forum, but not many of us are willing to part with their Spirits... ;)
-
i found a few youtube videos which compare these MT's, which means that i am not the first in line who wondered about the superiority of one MT over the other. For serious MT use i would have to setup a list with priorities and most often used tasks. If OHO is on top of the features wishlist then the Spirit would lose from the very beginning and no further discussion possible hehe.
thanks Nikos for the links. i've created a WTB thread and the way i composed it i dont expect any Spirit owner to part.. ;)
-
If you're going to compare prices, the leatherman wave is probably a lot closer to the swisstool X than a charge TTI. To me it seems like the wave is 95% of the functionality of the charge, at 50% of cost.
If I wasn't able to find my charge for $50, I would've probably went with a wave, since the lowest price I've seen for the swisstool locally is $115.
-
@50ft-trad said:
The Charge is a good tool
(diamond file, bit driver for non-standard drivers),And...
Needle nose pliers, ruler in the handle, --> Pocket Clip <--, lanyard ring, Eyeglass screwdriver, serrated blade.Spirit X, no contest!!!
Charge scissors open wider

All fair comments, Paul
I should clarify:
Personal opinion based on my own general needs ... Spirit X, no contest!!! -
@sjian said:
If you're going to compare prices, the leatherman wave is probably a lot closer to the swisstool X than a charge TTI. To me it seems like the wave is 95% of the functionality of the charge, at 50% of cost.If I wasn't able to find my charge for $50, I would've probably went with a wave, since the lowest price I've seen for the swisstool locally is $115.
I agree, I think that's a much more realistic comparison. Still a tough contest of course.
Stay multi my friends
-
I own both tools, compare on price, Spirit X is more expensive than TTi in HK, USD$150 VS USD$121...
About which one is better, my answer is they are same, just depend on what you using for. I use Spirit X for scout training camp; TTi for pioreering camp and cycling.
For my Exp:
Knife, Serrated Knife, Screwdriver----> TTI is better
bottle/can openers, scissors----> Spirit X is better -
I had a Wave, and was pretty meh on it. OHO blades on most MTs don't work well for me, being a lefty. I got a Spirit X last week, and love it. It feels better in my hand, I like the scissors better, and the large flat driver works better for me as a prybar, which is a big use for me throughout the day. Same with the can opener, opening tint cans all day.
-
No Charge here but I do have three Spirits.

I do have a Wave also so I'll use it as a proxy for the Charge. I would lean towards it if you do not carry a secondary knife and if you require OHO. I prefer the Spirit X in most other respects. I find it far easier to get to the interior tools on the Spirit X than the Wave.
-
3.0238.L, i ordered this article number from amazon eu (57€ shipped). i am guessing that the standard leather sheath without rotating clip is included. official Swiss list price is 159.00CHF (i called victorinox.ch hehe; local German retail price is 145.00€, which is about consistent with the exchange rate), amazon.com sells it for amazon.com sells it for rather low 108USD, i dont know how amazon is able to offer such low prices.
For our information, the official Swiss list price for the Vinox Minichamp ( i would be interested in it too because it complements the Spirit in some way ) is 37.00CHF. These CHF prices are also the ones adopted in their local factory shop and are called "UVP" (engl. MSRP).
within a few days of delivery i am gonna be a proud and joyful Spirit owner ( i dont mind the butter blade at this price point
), thanks to everyone -- this thread helped me a lot.besides nutnfancy's video review... archman's video was very influential to my purchase decision and helpful too. sorry for the many price quotes, just wanted to collect relevant info on pricing, comparison and what kind of strange deal i realized

will let you know if amazon sends me the right thing (the eu website is full of listing and database errors, wrong pictures etc. and flashaholics know about it).
-
I got a Swisstool from amazon Uk, same as amazon eu SARL a couple of years ago for not much. Then, a week after, the price went up by 50%, then down by 10% and so on. For some reason the prices fluctuate quite a lot, but when they are cheap they are really cheap. If you wait you can get most tools there for a low price, though the US is usually even cheaper so I buy most of my multitools from tthe US.
-
Here a self-updating price chart of the Spirit X in € (Germany):
i compared it with the xe.com chart of the EUR-CHF exchange rate and there doesnt seem any logical connection or coupling between the Spirit pricing and the exchange rate -- thanks god.
to me, the joy of a possession *is *coupled with its acquisition price. is silly but i do feel more joy with high value objects (say simple stuffz like books, CDs, flashlights, tools, ..) which would cost a lot and were acquired by me at low prices. optimal case: a high value gift!

-
Tough call
The bottom line is you need to try both, I know that doesn't help much but which ever one you go for you will always wonder what the other would have been like. Both are very good Multitools right at the top of the food chain so to speak.If you really push me for an answer I'd have to say Spirit

-
@Dunc said:
Tough call
The bottom line is you need to try both,in case i dont fall for the ordered Spirit, i will ask some local dealer to send over an (used/unused) review sample of the Leatherman charge (TTi/Al/..) as inspection copy. i dont think that any neighbor of mine or RL friend owns an original LM.
on the other hand, in case i fall in love with the ordered Spirit, my attitude will be not to look any further.
btw i think similarly about ladies and girl-friends (oops, that was uncalled for
haha) -
If the prices were the same as in your first post, I'd go for TTi, because depends on your local price, either TTi is a bargain or spirit is overpriced. But as you said later there is a 30 euro difference, then spirit no doubt. I have the "regular" version of leatherman, i.e. wave and surge, but never went for the TTi because I don't think the price premium is worth what you get in return.
-
Which of the 2 MT's generate more joy with you, personally?
Based on that I would say the Spirit
I've enjoyed using mine

-
--OT on--
@kreisler said:
For our information, the official Swiss list price for the Vinox Minichamp ( i would be interested in it too because it complements the Spirit in some way ) is 37.00CHF. These CHF prices are also the ones adopted in their local factory shopoops, i've also pulled the trigger for the Minichamp. found a website with 22.50€ regular price shipped, which is about the same as the 29.00$ on amazon.com. i didnt understand how the EDC source works (felinevet) and the shipping costs to **eu **would have been a deal breaker imho
--OT off--Looks like the majority in this thread has voted for the Spirit -- at least regarding my specific way of posing the question (joy, enjoyment, joyful, joyous, ..). Looking very forward to the Vinox shipment(s). For sure i will post my impressions and opinion in a strong clear way once i got to experience the tools.
Choosing a favorite/best flashlight was a bit harder .. I did that in fall/autumn 2011 and since then bought 13 lights. Crossing fingers that i wont buy more than i already ordered: the Spirit Plus (with butter blade), and the Minichamp.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
