Which sharpenter system? lanky or Smith's
-
Hello to all,
I would like to get a sharpening system and I am considering the lansky and Smith's, any one have experince with them that could recomment me which one to buy, or which one is better..Lansky sharpening system...
Smith's Sharpening kit....
Thanks..
-
I have the Lansky deluxe and I am happy with it, though I may get some diamond stones for it for faster sharpening .
The Smiths seems to be a similar system with fewer stones but has the diamond ones included. I have not used it....
You may want to look at the Lansky with diamond stones too. The pice is not much more than the Smiths.
http://www.amazon.com/Lansky-Diamond-Deluxe-Sharpening-System/dp/B000B8L6LS/ref=pd_cp_hi_2/176-8008276-1241629 -
I have the Lansky kit with three stones (just got an extra coarse stone to go with it) and it works well for me,

I can't comment on the Smiths system -
I had a Smith's set and wasn't happy with it. It felt cheap, and one of the stones actually fell out of the plastic holder. It was just glued in there, poorly. I got myself the Lansky deluxe set about two months ago and think it's great.
-
I use the Lansky system, and am having trouble typing this on my iPhone due to the band-aid on my thumb after slicing the end off it while trying to feel for burrs. There were none...
-
Don't feel for burrs, look for reflection under light, more reliable, and safer.
-
I have the lansky diamond set. If you end up going this route, pick up a 'fine stone' hone and a 'super blue sapphire' one to really finish it well.
I DO however, like the Smith's honing solution, it's lighter than the Lansky oil.
-
I could see that all that reply my post has a lansky system with good comments and only one had the smith's before and wasn't happy with, so looks like the Lansky is the correct way.
Thanks to all... -
I like the lansky hones for reprofiling and love the 4 rod turnbox set for touch ups.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
My only experience with Lansky is their Turnbox, and it's fantastic. I use it along with my Spyderco Sharpmaker for really good PE blades.
The only smiths experience I have is the pocket diamond stone and the dual sided diamond stone. It works ok for rough stuff and reprofiling, but I use crocksticks for fine sharpening.
-
I had a Lansky , and it's great Grandpa , the loray - gave up on them , too fiddly . Went Spyderco Sharpmaker . Smith's stuff is lower end , if you want good diamond stuff ( stuff that wont shed their grit rapidly ) , go DMT .
Another option few think of , get an inexpensive , but good quality paring knife ie: Victorinox and leard freehand sharpening .
Chris
-
Between those two, Lansky for sure. Lansky is the original, the Smith's is the budget copy.
However...
I have the Lansky with diamond hones, (which last longer and retain their flatness better) and I prefer the Spyderco Sharpmaker to that. The theory of the Lansky is perfect: there is a jig to maintain the angles. In practice, it is less than perfect, as it doesn't clamp well to blades with a full flat grind. (ex. most multi-tool blades) It works better on bigger knives with a saber grind.
-
Also:
http://www.exduct.com/Special-Limited-Products/SP931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlsame idea, cheap, should be decent coming from Exduct, diamond stones, I do not know if anybody tried it.
-
@dks said:
Also:
http://www.exduct.com/Special-Limited-Products/SP931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlsame idea, cheap, should be decent coming from Exduct, diamond stones, I do not know if anybody tried it.
The hones themselves are awesome. Not sure of the exact grit but they made quick work of reprofiling blades however it's downfall is the rail system, made of plastic and would flex too much under use.
The Rods are attached directly via a thread on the back of the hones so they tend to get loose and they don't sit straight. Good for the price but not good in the long run.
-
Also:
http://www.exduct.com/Special-Limited-Products/SP931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlsame idea, cheap, should be decent coming from Exduct, diamond stones, I do not know if anybody tried it.
The hones themselves are awesome. Not sure of the exact grit but they made quick work of reprofiling blades however it's downfall is the rail system, made of plastic and would flex too much under use.
The Rods are attached directly via a thread on the back of the hones so they tend to get loose and they don't sit straight. Good for the price but not good in the long run.
From the last q&a on that page:
**
360grit,480grit, 600grit,800grit ** -
(Just putting this out there to confuse things) :whistle:
This one looked good to me but I don't know anyone who has one
-
I have the Smith's- don't buy. :)
-
i am hooked to this thread. a German academic who knows pretty much all better products and studied the sharpening of knives (he also owns a Swisstool Spirit X!!) is
Am glad that i know some German language.. ::)
He uses lots of Lansky and Spyderco sharpening products. -
Also:
http://www.exduct.com/Special-Limited-Products/SP931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlsame idea, cheap, should be decent coming from Exduct, diamond stones, I do not know if anybody tried it.
The hones themselves are awesome. Not sure of the exact grit but they made quick work of reprofiling blades however it's downfall is the rail system, made of plastic and would flex too much under use.
The Rods are attached directly via a thread on the back of the hones so they tend to get loose and they don't sit straight. Good for the price but not good in the long run.
From the last q&a on that page:
**
360grit,480grit, 600grit,800grit **Very good coments and options..Thanks,
This exduct system looks good, good price and its diamond stone, but fisrt time I hear about it, there is a good option to try but for know I believe I will go for the Lansky. -
oops, there is much more to sharpening (it's an art, it's science!) than simply buying a fool-proof Smith's, Lansky's or portable knife sharpener. without knowing what you're doing and why, you would could do more harm than good to the edge.
today in the afternoon i found a steel rod in a kitchen drawer and did some simple tests with it on old pocket knives and kitchen knives, and a Ganzo MT. The manufacturing quality of the Ganzo factory edge is a disaster and there was no way to get a perfect 50/50 edge along the blade. i managed to sharpen the knives with free-hand steeling (in a similar uneducated manner as most teenagers on youtube demonstrate their sharpening skills), so i am good. However, i dont really dare to touch up a Swiss made factory edge (which is very sharp already) of the Spirit without knowing anything about it. The above German link is quite helpful; it even points to literature (books on sharpening knives) and has lots of serious videos.A great series of serious videos on sharpening by a real pro is:
http://www.youtube.com/user/MrEZCooking/videosI guess that the subject of sharpening was already discussed at length on this forum and for sure on the many many knife forums on the WWW (i am not going there). Am just saying that restoring the super sharp Spirit edge is a challenge and not as simple as buying a 50$ Lansky kit and following generic instructions from the product manual.
Once one knows the fundamentals, has acquired the practical skills and got all sharpening tools (e.g. in a semi-professional set/kit), one could easily sharpen anything in the household: scythes, scissors, kitchen cutlery, lawn mower, pocket knifes, serrated blades, the special tools of a SAK and SwissTool, etc.
The most general sharpener seems to be the handheld rod and one would want/need different types and coarseness (steel, ceramic, diamond).Gosh.. restoring the Spirit factory edge (i.e. a precision 50/50 grind) with such quality tools could easily cost more than the cost of a new Spirit!
i think i will get just 1 fine "DMT Diafold Serrated Knife Sharpener"-type of rod or the Smith's PP1. Personally i have only very few blades to maintain (Spirit, Minichamp, old pocket knife).. so getting a Lansky or even the Spyderco system is outta line. Maybe i dont even need to resharpen these few blades. Wishful thinking.
Reminds me of flashlights and the topic of rechargeable batteries and their chargers, a wide topic and some users dedicate much much energy and money in it.
Is the Smith's PP1 more or less sufficient for MT's like the Swisstool or does it barely restore the Vic factory edge?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

- Mr. Whippy