Tool perception - have we got it wrong?
-
@50ft-trad said:
I find suspension clips safer as the tool is wholly within the pocket and the smaller clip draws less attentionI've read a few posts here recently extolling the virtues of the suspension clip and I'm definitely interested. In NYC any visibly clipped tool is likely to draw the attention of the NYPD, not sure if completely buried in the pocket makes any difference as opposed to sticking out slightly. But I do like to clip my Charge to my pocket when I'm in the office, on a job on private property or outside of the city, which constitutes a good deal of my time. I can see what you mean about the safety factor of the suspension clip but I would have to try one first to know about the comfort. The biggest drawback I can see with the suspension clip is that it makes removing and using the tool just a bit more fiddly.
@jerseydevil said:
My idea on tools seems to be if it looks neat, it's mine.Reminds me of a bumper sticker I just saw on a woman's car, "If the shoe fits ... I own it"
-
I had an "ah ha" moment like this not too long ago. I wouldn't call myself a "snob" toward any particular brand, but I am picky, I think. I was going through my stuff the other night, cleaning, sharpening, etc and realized that I'm a creature of habit and I just might be boring. :)
I realized that most of the stuff I have that I really like or really really LOVE are kind of standard look and fucntion. The reason I prefer the Pulse to the Wave is the way it looks and that phillips screwdriver. Now, on function and ease of use, if I'm outside working on something especially if I can only use one hand, then the Wave is the tool I want. But for everything else, I'd grab the Pulse. It's got a classic, no nonsense, no frill design in my opinion and that's what I like. Same thing with my SAK's. The only one in my collection that I'm not particularly fond of is the Cybertool 34...mainly because it's actually too fiddly for me. I also wasn't overly fond of the Helmsman until I realized just how useful that particular SAK is.
99% of the time I use a SAK. I love my case pocket knives and my spydies but really a SAK takes care of almost anything I get into on a day to day basis. And I've tried other multifunction pocket knives but they just don't "feel" right and don't look right. I guess I'm just a little biased on the looks and the feel of the tool. -
I had yet another perspective change last night, this time with SOG tools (or should I say parts). I've shot them down in the past for not being as good as other manufacturers, but I was sat down last night looking at a few tools I'd stripped right down and realised how the SOG tools are actually a really very viable alternative.
For example the file might not be diamond coated, but that screwdriver tip could make all the difference to configuring a versatile load out, as could the drivers on the can opener/cap lifter rather than the plain drivers on early LM's. Drivers tend to be my least used tools so carrying say a standard Kick which is just drivers, a knife (again I don't use MT blades much) and a can/bottle opener just seems silly for my needs. I still think the SOG saw is still ridiculously short though, just as the awl is still excellent. Again, that might not apply if I was doing different things everyday
I'm quite enjoying re-discovering all these tools with a more open mind. I'm not sure the CS4 will remain EDC at the end of this trial though (pity I can't swap that saw for a file as easily as on a full sized LM), but I really need to consider varying my tool choices and challenging my mindset more often anyway.
-
Thread necro :D
The CS4 was indeed carried for a month and I got by, but as soon as that month was up I started carrying something else and I don't think I ever carried it again. I ended up gifting it to my younger brother as I knew he'd get more use out of it and despite it's weaknesses and failings it was better than the really naff tools he had before.
He works in a care environment as a support worker, but often has to attend to a few maintenance tasks during a working day, and is also responsible for the electrical PAT testing at a couple of sites. He carries the CS4 everyday without fail, along with a Wenger Evo 14 which I also hated and gifted him.
I saw him last night and he said there's rarely a day goes by that he doesn't use one or both of them and he absolutely loves them. He started recalling times he's used them .... and he's getting some real milage out of both tools. He's won favour with the management at three residential sites in the city purely because he's not "just" a support worker in their eyes, and despite being in such a sensitive environment not one of the managers has flinched at his tool carry as they've all benefitted from it
I'm glad the tools found a new lease of life even though I couldn't abide them, and happier my kid brother is going round with legal tools in his pocket and the ability/mindset to use them safely
Bottom line, the tool which was a diabolical attempt riddled with annoyance for me is absolutely perfect pocket tool for him, and he's not got a single gripe about it
-
Funny reading this one as again things change over time, i for money issues had to sell a lot of my MT's last year and decided to have a non LM year plus try different makes and models, so far ive tried the paratool, for now and then use i found it ok but it bugged me while on my handyman job,way too fiddly but still a nice tool, i got to liking the changable and moddable tool loads,so now onto the PPP after a trade for the pt with Allan, so far this tool is more what im after in a MT good size smooth action,plenty of drivers (hence my lover for the days of my old wave lol) plus the little bitdriver that allan sent with it goes on the large flat head (io do love a bit holder :D ) i do agree that i look at MT's and SAK's in a much different way these days but im after the perfect MT and perfect SAK, it been a long road :D but fun ;)
Ive enjoyed all of this stuff,the ppp to find out .

-
I feel very fortunate in that I don't have to sell the tools that I try and set aside. Since the time of this original thread, I've decided that other than the Kf4, I don't really like the Juice series.
My wife, on the other hand EDC's an S2 everyday and uses the holy hell out of it.
I find myself tending to carry SAK's when we are out socially and save Leatherman's for heavy duty farm time.
With a cybertool 41 or S557, I'm pretty well covered for social events. Heck, we were out with my in-laws the other evening, and my mother in law had a few loose threads that were annoying her. My wife was about to go after them with a steak knife ::), when I said, "Wait, why don't you try this?" and handed her the Cybertimer 41 with scissors out. Right after that, we needed a way to keep track of appetiziers and sidedishes we were ordering, and voila! out came the little Vic pen. :D
-
I've had some amusement testing various bits on MTs. I don't think I have a bias, with one clear and notable exception. I have a positive bias toward the Crosscut from years of EDC. I understand that most of that is the 'it was the tool that was there when I needed it' thing, but there's no getting over that sometimes.
I always tie cost to the value of a tool, but try to realize a tool's potential even ignoring that. It doesn't always work. As Mr. Whippy just pointed out as well, a tool's perceived worth is also closely tied to the user's needs. The Juice might not do him any good, but his wife loves it for EDC.
I try not to have name-brand bias, either for or against, but I have to be honest in saying Gerber's stuff has consistently not thrilled me, and Victorinox has. There, I said it. The truth is that Gerber's stuff is consistently better than most knock-offs. And price seems to be about right to reflect that.
I've decided, since Vic's are all just combinations of a fairly small number of tools, they need to just make a set you can take apart and slap together in any combination you want, like the Quirky Switch. Bam... the perfect tool. :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've had some amusement testing various bits on MTs. I don't think I have a bias, with one clear and notable exception. I have a positive bias toward the Crosscut from years of EDC. I understand that most of that is the 'it was the tool that was there when I needed it' thing, but there's no getting over that sometimes.I always tie cost to the value of a tool, but try to realize a tool's potential even ignoring that. It doesn't always work. As Mr. Whippy just pointed out as well, a tool's perceived worth is also closely tied to the user's needs. The Juice might not do him any good, but his wife loves it for EDC.
I try not to have name-brand bias, either for or against, but I have to be honest in saying Gerber's stuff has consistently not thrilled me, and Victorinox has. There, I said it. The truth is that Gerber's stuff is consistently better than most knock-offs. And price seems to be about right to reflect that.
I've decided, since Vic's are all just combinations of a fairly small number of tools, they need to just make a set you can take apart and slap together in any combination you want, like the Quirky Switch. Bam... the perfect tool. :D
This is a reason im vering towards sogs lynn,although it would be interesting to see what combo's folk have in there PPP's as seems limited, i added 2 extra to the PT but the pliers stuck out a little bit,it bothered me ::) :D although i do like the ppp's tool load and i swapped out the blade for a wood saw, i might stick up a post to see if any folk have altered there ppp's

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've decided, since Vic's are all just combinations of a fairly small number of tools, they need to just make a set you can take apart and slap together in any combination you want, like the Quirky Switch. Bam... the perfect tool. :DWell... I suspect the current situation, where we buy the next one and next one and next one, because if just “that little thing” was different it would be “perfect” works out great for Vic. :D
And, frankly, knives and MTs is something where I happily have loads of prejudices. It is one of the parts of life where I can partake of that luxury of going for what I like, not only what is optimal price/performance and good enough.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've decided, since Vic's are all just combinations of a fairly small number of tools, they need to just make a set you can take apart and slap together in any combination you want, like the Quirky Switch. Bam... the perfect tool. :DNope, still wouldn't be perfect. Because the implements you need tomorrow could be different from the implements you need today. And if you add every implement you might need, you end up with a SwissChamp XL; you'll never find a perfect combination of size/weight vs. utility.

Again, that's what keeps Vic/Wenger churning out SAKs by the tractor-trailer-full!
:tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool:
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've had some amusement testing various bits on MTs. I don't think I have a bias, with one clear and notable exception. I have a positive bias toward the Crosscut from years of EDC. I understand that most of that is the 'it was the tool that was there when I needed it' thing, but there's no getting over that sometimes.I always tie cost to the value of a tool, but try to realize a tool's potential even ignoring that. It doesn't always work. As Mr. Whippy just pointed out as well, a tool's perceived worth is also closely tied to the user's needs. The Juice might not do him any good, but his wife loves it for EDC.
+1

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've decided, since Vic's are all just combinations of a fairly small number of tools, they need to just make a set you can take apart and slap together in any combination you want, like the Quirky Switch. Bam... the perfect tool. :D
Nope, still wouldn't be perfect. Because the implements you need tomorrow could be different from the implements you need today. And if you add every implement you might need, you end up with a SwissChamp XL; you'll never find a perfect combination of size/weight vs. utility.

Again, that's what keeps Vic/Wenger churning out SAKs by the tractor-trailer-full!
:tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool: :tool:
This is why we keep buying new tools, and keep rotating them. I'll have days where I only want to EDC my sideclip because I just don't want the extra weight, but by the end of the day I miss the utility of my full sized tools and I slap on back on my belt. Then I have the problem of deciding which tool to pick, do I want OHO or not? Do I want replaceable cutters? What about the bit kit? Sliding pliers sure sound cool, what SAK should I pair with that Gerber?
So basically :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
@Mercury said:
So basically :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhhBTDTGTS. I've trimmed my flashlight/knife/tool rotations down a LOT, for that reason. I've tried to limit my choices to two or three favorites, plus whatever is new and shiny and in need of testing. And defined a few "use cases" with favorite go-to load-outs, so I don't have to think about it much.
-
I still remember the days when 1 MT was enough and i was happy with it :D iam trying to get back to that as i like to bond with a tool and hard if too many choices, my tinker and opinel #5-6 i have this kind of feeling for, oddly ive had the ppp in my shorts pocket this afternoon and havnt really noticed it there, a good sighn ;)
-
@Zed said:
I still remember the days when 1 MT was enough and i was happy with it :DI know whatcha mean! I bought the original Leatherman shortly after it came out (wasn't even called the PST yet), and it was the only tool I owned for almost ten years. I only bought my second, the PST-II, because Ol' No. 1 took a swim in Great Egg Harbor one afternoon. The PST-II was my one-and-only for another four years or so, until I fell for the siren charms of the old-school Wave. Then, several years later, a Squirt... and then... let's just say things got more complicated.
Same with knives. I carried a Schrade LB-7 on my belt from age 18 until I bought that first Leatherman. The only other knife I owned was an old Vic Super Tinker, which I carried when the Schrade was a bit much. Then a buddy turned me onto this cool knife called a Delica...

-
I still remember the days when 1 MT was enough and i was happy with it :D
I know whatcha mean! I bought the original Leatherman shortly after it came out (wasn't even called the PST yet), and it was the only tool I owned for almost ten years. I only bought my second, the PST-II, because Ol' No. 1 took a swim in Great Egg Harbor one afternoon. The PST-II was my one-and-only for another four years or so, until I fell for the siren charms of the old-school Wave. Then, several years later, a Squirt... and then... let's just say things got more complicated.
Same with knives. I carried a Schrade LB-7 on my belt from age 18 until I bought that first Leatherman. The only other knife I owned was an old Vic Super Tinker, which I carried when the Schrade was a bit much. Then a buddy turned me onto this cool knife called a Delica...

yep i was the same, my dad got me a wave for my birthday in 98 i carried it untill 09 the rest is MTO history :D
-
I hear you. My first multi-tool was an American Camper that my father and I bought to aid us out on the 3D range in the mid 90s. After that, he bought a Schrade tough tool and a Leatherman Pulse. I thought I had to have something fancier, and because I couldn't afford a more expensive tool, found a Coleman Pro-Lock at one of the local big box store. It looked somewhat like the Schrade ST1 which at the time, I thought was way cool. I was happy with that.
Then my father passed away a few years ago. While cleaning his room out, i found I had a nice collection of 20 odd multitools if I included my 2 into that equation. Seeing that an MT was a big part of his life as a tradesman, I got into collecting them in his memory. Well everyone here knows how crazy that got.
Even with the many multi-tools I do have, I still only carry the one most of the times due to work restrictions. Mind you, I am the only person at work that wears one. I had to explain myself a few times when I first started to wear it. Now it is not uncommon for other people to ask me for my multi-tool to aid in a job. Regardless, I do try out many multi-tools on weekends, and holidays. I still gravitate to the Knifeless Fuse as it does everything I need in a nice package and weight. I guess I am still that one multi-tool sort of guy...but I do have one heck of a choice list when I need it.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login