Must have?
-
@Farmman said:
I think Al just died of shock. Yes it is me voting for a vic! I have carried one for the past year. It has everything I need and nothing I don't need ( well ok still don't use the hook). Best of all it is uk legal.Not at all mate, I knew you were starting to see the light :P :D :D
@Gareth said:
OK, lots of SAKs appearing, and I have no issue with that, but are we really done with pliers based MTs?Not until we get the Bucktools in there at least :D
- Vic Spirit.
- Leatherman Wave or Charge
- Leatherman Micra
- Leatherman Crunch
- SOG Powerlock
- Gerber MP series, Diesel or Flik
- Leatherman Knifeless Fuse
- Leatherman PST
- Their Own Mod
- Leatherman Juice
- Victorinox Swisschamp
- Leatherman Pulse
- Leatherman Mini
- Leatherman Sideclip
- Leatherman Skeletool
- Leatherman Surge
- SOG Toolclip
- Victorinox Huntsman
- Vic tinker
- Leatherman Squirt
- Vic Farmer
- Vic Classic
- Vic Soldier or Wenger Standard Issue
- A unique Wenger
- Super tinker
- Bucktools
-
- Vic Spirit.
- Leatherman Wave or Charge
- Leatherman Micra
- Leatherman Crunch
- SOG Powerlock
- Gerber MP series, Diesel or Flik
- Leatherman Knifeless Fuse
- Leatherman PST
- Their Own Mod
- Leatherman Juice
- Victorinox Swisschamp
- Leatherman Pulse
- Leatherman Mini
- Leatherman Sideclip
- Leatherman Skeletool
- Leatherman Surge
- SOG Toolclip
- Victorinox Huntsman
- Vic tinker
- Leatherman Squirt
- Vic Farmer
- Vic Classic
- Vic Soldier or Wenger Standard Issue
- A unique Wenger
- Super tinker
- Bucktools
- Vic Swisstool
I think the Spirit's big brother needs to be here too, for when the going gets really tough.
-
Our "must have" list is getting close to thirty tools :ahhh
Can we get it down to one essential classic model per manufacturer?
My votes would go to:
Vic Spartan
LM WaveJust because to me those are the instantly recognisable tools from those companies. I don't know enough about SOG or Gerber or other companies to list a definitive must-have from them.
-
I can't give an exact model for this, as there are a number of candidates, but a SAK or something similiar, with basic set of tools, that is on the slim side (if a Vic, 3 layers max) and not super long and has dressy scales. They can be anything from scrimshaw to wood to a semi-precious stone that is kind of stunning, like turquoise or tiger eye or snowflake obsidian. File work is a plus.
So why- you need to dress up sometimes. It might be a job interview, a wedding or a funeral, but you need to not have this... bulge, not in your pants. The class of the knife means if you need it, it doesn't look tactical or cheap (lets face it, red celidor does look kind of cheap). But you need to have a gentleman's knife, just like you need to have a good pen and a decent watch.
For pliers based tools, that kind of limits you to someone with outer scales like a Juice. Take them off, make new ones and put it back together again, and they aren't very big so long as you limit yourself to like the C2 or S2.
Basically, anything Sidhartha does. :)
-
@user24 said:
Our "must have" list is getting close to thirty tools :ahhhCan we get it down to one essential classic model per manufacturer?
...
My wife has been asking me that same question over and over again for the last couple of years ...
(no, just kidding, she's cool 8))But I know what you mean, a "must have list" of 30 tools might just be a bit over the top ... ;)
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
My wife has been asking me that same question over and over again for the last couple of years ... -
Our "must have" list is getting close to thirty tools :ahhh
Can we get it down to one essential classic model per manufacturer?
...
My wife has been asking me that same question over and over again for the last couple of years ...
(no, just kidding, she's cool 8))But I know what you mean, a "must have list" of 30 tools might just be a bit over the top ... ;)
In fairness, Gareth's OP said must have or must try, and to be honest I feel there's some must trys in there which aren't necessarily must haves
For me, the top 5 must have's are: Vic Spirit, Wave/Charge, SOG Compound leverage, Gerber slidey pliers, and SAK of choice. The rest is a good guide for interesting tools to try out, and some may actually suit some folk better than my top 5
-
Yeah, must try is also the point. Best done with friends at a meet-up IMO but even a quick play in a shop is better than nothing.
-
@50ft-trad said:
For me, the top 5 must have's are: Vic Spirit, Wave/Charge, SOG Compound leverage, Gerber slidey pliers, and SAK of choice. The rest is a good guide for interesting tools to try out, and some may actually suit some folk better than my top 5I agree wholeheartedly, both with your list, and your reasoning. The list is getting waaaay outta control.
We could put the list up to a vote, to pick the Top Five. But I'm not sure that would really work; it would just turn into a popularity contest, rather than an overview of the state-of-the-multitool.
-
@50ft-trad said:
For me, the top 5 must have's are: Vic Spirit, Wave/Charge, SOG Compound leverage, Gerber slidey pliers, and SAK of choice. The rest is a good guide for interesting tools to try out, and some may actually suit some folk better than my top 5
I agree wholeheartedly, both with your list, and your reasoning. The list is getting waaaay outta control.
We could put the list up to a vote, to pick the Top Five. But I'm not sure that would really work; it would just turn into a popularity contest, rather than an overview of the state-of-the-multitool.
Agreed

@Gareth said:
Yeah, must try is also the point. Best done with friends at a meet-up IMO but even a quick play in a shop is better than nothing.The problem with trying them in a shop is they don't like you getting
lighting fires and throwing axes and shovels around.
The company is not normally as good either -
A poll sounds like an excellent idea.
My thought is also to split out the pliers based tools from the SAKs, not because I think people shouldn't own both, but I do think SAKs might deserve a poll all of their own. :DI'll give folks a little time to add any last minute thoughts and get something together later tonight. :)
-
I agree with Gryffin, it's tricky not to turn it into a popularity contest. Wording is important. Eg if asked which SAK I think everyone should own, I'd say either a Farmer or a Huntsman, but if asked which SAK is the quintessential SAK, I'd say the Soldier or the Spartan. Depends what we want to find out really :D
-
Not sure about the various SAKs, but I totally agree with the plierbased suggestions (the REAL multitools).. ;)

-
the poll is now open; /topic/38028
-
@user24 said:
I agree with Gryffin, it's tricky not to turn it into a popularity contest. Wording is important. Eg if asked which SAK I think everyone should own, I'd say either a Farmer or a Huntsman, but if asked which SAK is the quintessential SAK, I'd say the Soldier or the Spartan. Depends what we want to find out really :DI have to say I think the climber is the Quintessential SAK. I also think everyone should own a climber, or my favorite, the Supertinker.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login