Survival Knives
-
I'd be interested in hearing what you think about the Golok mate, they certainly seem to be getting good reviews. :)
-
@Gareth said:
I'd be interested in hearing what you think about the Golok mate, they certainly seem to be getting good reviews. :)I'll keep you posted... It won't be here until next week, most likely, and we don't have another camping trip scheduled until July, when we're going to Sequoia / King's Canyon. Not sure about the trails there, but after my Tuolumne experience, I don't want to go without it!
I'll take it up into the open space preserved behind my house after I get it, and test it on some of the poison oak we have here... >:D
Edit: I have to admit I'm having second thoughts now, and thinking I should've gotten the Parang instead... each has features I like. The Golok's blade tapers from 1/4" thick at the handle, to 1/8" at the tip, so it should work well on brush, and its sheath doesn't require opening any snaps. The Parang, on the other hand, has a bit better reach and is more designed for brush and weeds than the Golok. However, it doesn't have the tapered blade, or the snap-less sheath, or the nice ball-end on the handle...
Agh! It never ends!
-
Just been comparing the specs on them and I can see your dilemma. :-\ On balance I think I would have chosen the Golok myself.
-
@Gareth said:
Just been comparing the specs on them and I can see your dilemma. :-\ On balance I think I would have chosen the Golok myself.Yeah, I think the Golok is the better of the two as an overall multipurpose utility tool... the blade should be better for wood processing than the Parang. The shorter length and the snap-less sheath are really what made me go for the Golok, as I think that'll make the Golok more pack-friendly. My hiking pack is a Mountainsmith Approach 3.0, which has side slots for cross country skis. There's a compression strap at the top of the slot, so I'm going to try running it through the belt loop of the sheath for carrying the Golok.
Our back yard is pretty overgrown right now, and my wife has been on me for a while about getting it dealt with... I can't rent a weed eater until Monday, but even so, there are some pretty nasty clumps of thistles out there that I'm going to save for testing the Golok. My wife said she'd even take pics for me to post here for a review of the tool. With any luck I'll get it early next week, and I'll be able to post a review a day or two after I get it. I'm really looking forward to getting this tool... partly because after enduring a week of poison oak rash on my side and face, I'm out for revenge!!! >:D
-
I keep thinking about a Woodsman's Pal myself
-
Kukris are cool, but I've never heard gurkhas mentioned as jungle special forces before. I didn't think there was a lot of jungle in Nepal, more, well, mountains?
Steinar, you are right. Gurkhas were not known for their Jungle warefare, it was in this part of the world South East Asia the Gurkhas was deployed as elite to fight jungle warefare against the Malayan communist party. That was why they were seens as elite of jungle warefare here, they were deploy in Borneo too: http://www.historicaleye.com/sukarno.html
There are probably better known Jungle warefare elite than the Gurkhas though :)
I hadnt had a Kukri for over 20 years untill picking these 2 up recently, they defiantly would make a grea jungle survival knife


-
I have been poking around the Yard and on Hikes with one of thse as an EDC survival knife of a light weight sort...my Rajah II in the Jack Pack and either my Spartan or Rajah III in my Pocket or Vice Versa depending on my Mood of course backed up by an SAK or Two...
http://www.coldsteel.com/rajahseries.htmlDtrain
PS...The Rajah II is awsome for cutting starps and such
-
The shipping on my Golok from Knifecenter is taking forever...
I ordered it a week ago today, and it won't be here for two more days yet... 
I am really looking forward to getting it. I'll check the edge and finish it up if necessary, then I'm going to put it through its paces...
-
I'm still a HUGE fan of the Puukko style for dealing with the vast majority of tasks, but many people expect something bigger for a "survival" knife. I've not got many, but the ones I have got are very dependable and very capable

I posted them in another thread recently, but they belong here too. From the top:
Chris Caine Survival Tool - a real brute of a tool, but capable of lighter work too
Scandi Puukko - not the best chopping knife but a very capable knife all the same
J Adams MOD Survival knife - British Army Issue sharpened prybar
Muela Jabali 17A - full tang bowie with stag and brass for surviving in style :D
Scorpion Knives Warthog - SUPERB knife and actually beats a Puukko for me. LOVE IT!!! -
The thing that bugs me about puukko style knives is they don't have any kind of finger groove, guard, choil, etc. to keep the hand from slipping down onto the blade.
I've been looking a lot at the Condor Tavian... looks like a great small utility knife.
-
I got this from Neil after the last meet-up.

TBH I've never had an issue with the lack of any kind of finger guard on this style of knife and I've got to say the grip in very comfortable.
-
@Gareth said:
I got this from Neil after the last meet-up.
TBH I've never had an issue with the lack of any kind of finger guard on this style of knife and I've got to say the grip in very comfortable.
Nice knife, Gareth! I'd say it's pretty :D
Thanks for the info. Nothing personal against the style, I've just always felt more secure when there's a guard or place for my fingers.
And the wait for my Golok is killing me!!!

-
'Pretty' is probably not all that unfair. :D It's a J.Marttiini (a Finnish knife brand) and has "Joulumaa, Santa Claus Land" stamped on the sheath.
A nice knife anyway and seems to have taken a good edge. Not actually done much of anything with it yet, other than sharpen it, so I can't say how good it is but I can't see any issues ATM. -
@Gareth said:
'Pretty' is probably not all that unfair. :D It's a J.Marttiini (a Finnish knife brand) and has "Joulumaa, Santa Claus Land" stamped on the sheath.
A nice knife anyway and seems to have taken a good edge. Not actually done much of anything with it yet, other than sharpen it, so I can't say how good it is but I can't see any issues ATM.Either way, it's a beauty, for sure. :) Have fun!
Tell you what, you post more pics of your new Martini, and I'll post some pics of my Golok when it comes... if it ever does...

-
Thread necro!
This was a fun thread and I thought I'd bring it back up to see if anyone has anything to add. If not, it's a good read at least!
Def
-
I enjoy these sorts of threads because of the diversity of discussion they generate.
I also don't think there is any 'one' ideal survival knife. The reality is--as others already stated in this thread--the best survival knife is the one you have with you when the Smurf's hit the Mosh Pit. And different circumstances will suggest different survival 'knives'. A good machete will be the tool of choice in tropical environments, a good axe in more boreal climates.
As a basic survival tool, I think it's hard to beat a Vic Farmer or Leatherman Wave. The "Survivorman" series highlights how different tools can all serve a survival role.
I've been run through a few military survival courses and have come to the conclusion that one's mentality is more significant than one's tool set. Still, it's always nice to be equipped with a handy tools set.
I usually deployed with a Vic Farmer and a multitool, Wave or Charge. In addition, I carried a fixed blade. Initially I carried a Camilus USAF Pilot's knife, but then I got Scott Gossman to make me the knife pictured below. I asked him to make me a 5.5" knife I could use to cut my way out of a downed helicopter. Here's what he came up with:

Off the leash:

I absolutely love this knife, simple as it is. And yet, I almost never carry it now. When I go off on an adventure or road trip, this isn't the knife I carry.
Why?
Because this knife is now special to me and I don't want to risk it being damaged or lost. How is that for backward, smurfed thinking?
But, also, I'm not sure that any old knife won't also serve as a 'survival knife' in a crisis. How often will you really need anything more than a Vic Farmer in a tight spot?
-
@Nix said:
I enjoy these sorts of threads because of the diversity of discussion they generate.I also don't think there is any 'one' ideal survival knife. The reality is--as others already stated in this thread--the best survival knife is the one you have with you when the Smurf's hit the Mosh Pit. And different circumstances will suggest different survival 'knives'. A good machete will be the tool of choice in tropical environments, a good axe in more boreal climates.
As a basic survival tool, I think it's hard to beat a Vic Farmer or Leatherman Wave. The "Survivorman" series highlights how different tools can all serve a survival role.
I've been run through a few military survival courses and have come to the conclusion that one's mentality is more significant than one's tool set. Still, it's always nice to be equipped with a handy tools set.
I usually deployed with a Vic Farmer and a multitool, Wave or Charge. In addition, I carried a fixed blade. Initially I carried a Camilus USAF Pilot's knife, but then I got Scott Gossman to make me the knife pictured below. I asked him to make me a 5.5" knife I could use to cut my way out of a downed helicopter. Here's what he came up with:

Off the leash:

I absolutely love this knife, simple as it is. And yet, I almost never carry it now. When I go off on an adventure or road trip, this isn't the knife I carry.
Why?
Because this knife is now special to me and I don't want to risk it being damaged or lost. How is that for backward, smurfed thinking?
But, also, I'm not sure that any old knife won't also serve as a 'survival knife' in a crisis. How often will you really need anything more than a Vic Farmer in a tight spot?
That's one beautiful knife you have there mate
.I wouldn't use it either, but then again, I only really use stuff that I own doubles from (or triples ::)).
-
Thanks, 24.
I feel badly about not using this knife more, but, then, how often do you need to cut your way out of a helicopter? Scott makes a great knife, and if this one had a more conventional sheath, I'd probably carry it more regularly.

-
reminds me a bit of a smaller Tusker that Gossman makes
-
That is a beautiful knife.

If you want a good knife that can cut you out of a helicopter (and clean fish, strip bark or pretty well anything else you want to do) plus has a normal looking traditional leather sheath, check out Grohmann knives. Specifically the #1 which was issued to the Canadian Paratrooper Corps (the Red Arrows) in the late 60's or my latest go to knife, the #4 if you want something bigger. They are both a lot more knife than folks give them credit for. :D
I recently picked up a book in a discount store called The Ultimate Survival Manual- Canadian Edition. It features 333 Survival Skills, and I'm not sure how I managed to live on this planet for 43 years (so far) without the knowledge contained within. It has interesting articles like "How to survive a lion attack" which doesn't strike me as an overly common issue in Canada that I need to prepare for, you know, as we don't have lions in Canada.
Yes, some of you will point out that we have mountain lions, but the article is about African Lions, which are very differently behaved than our mountain lions, rendering the article useless..
There's another section on how to deal with a broken bone. At one point it says don't try to reset the bone if it is protruding the skin, just splint it as is. Then nothing. So, I guess once you splint it, it'll be ok, and you can just leave it that way?

It does say in the beginning though, that survival is more of a mindset than any gear, which I think is something we all can agree on.
Def

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





