One layer SAK
-
For me, it's the extra tools that a SAK provides that makes them stand out from other makes.
-
I do like bantams, but if i carry one, then I think, if only it had scissors... :D So I guess I could get buy on a few different configurations of 2 layers saks, but 1 layer itsnt enough for EDC for me.
Hmm a bantam with scissors does sound nice... :D
-
My sentiments are mirrored exactly by Syph above!
I'd love a Bantam with scissors :)
-
@magentus said:
For me, it's the extra tools that a SAK provides that makes them stand out from other makes.Couldn't agree more
I do like Wenger and Vic SAKs, but as versatile utility knives. I've never really had a yearning for bantam or pocket pal or solo. 84mm Golfer is the sparsest I own. I did get a gardener ages ago ... and I've never used it. The true value of SAK's for me is in the wealth and quality of the accompanying tools. For a less equipped pocket knife, I'd be more tempted to look elsewhere to be honest. -
Well sure, versatility is the main feature of the SAK.
I still hope to find someone here who would appreciate the one layer as well.
-
I have 2 one layer saks that I carry often.
A pioneer, large blade and pruner blade.
Pocket pal, small blade and an even smaller blade.
-
If I could get my hands on an Apprentice (or get the time to make one out of a Waiter and a donor backside philips), it would be a pretty good minimalist piece for my needs.
You mean a Voyageur- 84mm Golfer without the corkscrew. Although an alox Apprentice with scissors would rock my world, it would be as thick as a 1-layer cellidor
-
I have a wenger evo 63, it just lacks the utility function I expect from SAK so I never use it.
-
Its exactly what magentus said, its having the extra functions on the knife that makes it a SAK, if not then whats the point, id rather carry a Case with a nice wood handle and or a even one with lock back for a EDC pocket knife. Now, if it was just a two layer like a Cadet, then it would make sense.. JR
@magentus said:
For me, it's the extra tools that a SAK provides that makes them stand out from other makes. -
I had a Bantam, but gave it away. I'm a fan of the Cadet, not as thin but thin enough with much more versatility.
-
@ironraven said:
If I could get my hands on an Apprentice (or get the time to make one out of a Waiter and a donor backside philips), it would be a pretty good minimalist piece for my needs.I'd love a Bantam with scissors :)
You mean a Voyageur- 84mm Golfer without the corkscrew. Although an alox Apprentice with scissors would rock my world, it would be as thick as a 1-layer cellidor
Yes, a Voyageur - seen them around but way too pricy for me! Obviously very collectable too

-
@ironraven said:
If I could get my hands on an Apprentice (or get the time to make one out of a Waiter and a donor backside philips), it would be a pretty good minimalist piece for my needs.So is the Apprentice somewhat rare? I haven't seen one for sale here. The closest thing
to an Apprentice is a wenger evo junior 10, but the tip of the blade is rounded as it is a junior. -
Actually, I have a single Case, several GECs and several single layer SAKs. The Case and GECs are nice knives, but I usually prefer the single layer SAKs. Man-made materials that are easy to clean, the Swiss perfection in the mechanism and clean assembly, thin and pocketable. What some people like, is what other people view as flaws, and vice versa. Some days I want bone handles and natural variations, other times I want the advantages of alox handles and every single piece of steel being properly polished. Both the alox Solo, 108 mm Solo, Alpineer, Pioneer Settler and Pocket Pal have been regular EDCs for me. I have few other models, but they never reached EDC status.
So, yes, I do think the single layer SAKs are excellent pocket knives.
-

Bantam with scissors, 84mm of course (Golfer actually).
-
Amici,
I believe the one one layer SAK I have is one I picked up in the PX during basic many moons ago. It was a Vic, with two blades, a spear and a smaller one that's a standard on all their 91mm models. I don't recall the name of this particular model. Reminds me allot of a pen knife though..Cheers,
Serge -
@sergemaster said:
I believe the one one layer SAK I have is one I picked up in the PX during basic many moons ago. It was a Vic, with two blades, a spear and a smaller one that's a standard on all their 91mm models. I don't recall the name of this particular model. Reminds me allot of a pen knife though..Sounds like a Pioneer Settler, great knife.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login