Soldier whinge
-
Why did they stop? Seems a vital function to suddenly leave out!
I bought an '08 Alox Soldier back in, well, '08 and it was the first SAK I'd bought since I was 10 (I'm 43 now) and I didn't weigh up all the possibilities. Lack of bail aside, it's an excellent knife, but it's so precious I don't want to lose it and I absolutley can't justify buying any more SAK's than I already have (7). I should have chosen more carefully, but you know what it's like when you get excited!
-
...c'mon, one more SAK won't hurt
>:D -
-
As mentioned, you may want to get a new Wenger Standard Issue (SI), a used old Vic Soldier with the hollow rivet or a new Vic Pioneer. All of which can still be found at low prices. Speaking of which there is also the choice of the colored Pioneers, most common in general being Black and next Red (in new, current, scales).
-
@Marius said:
As mentioned, you may want to get a new Wenger Standard Issue (SI), a used old Vic Soldier with the hollow rivet or a new Vic Pioneer. All of which can still be found at low prices. Speaking of which there is also the choice of the colored Pioneers, most common in general being Black and next Red (in new, current, scales).Granted I could get any of those, but I'm just having o moan about the one I've got really - I really cannot justify (however I try) buying any more SAK's! Just wish I'd been more careful before I bought this one.
-
If it bothers you that much get something with a lanyard ring or carry it in a sheath.
I think it may have something to do with leg length or body shape. I've never had a knife fall out of my pockets in over 20 years but a buddy of mine says they fall out all the time. I still keep a spare in the truck just in case I lose it when I am out of the house ;)
-
@APS said:
If it bothers you that much get something with a lanyard ring or carry it in a sheath.I think it may have something to do with leg length or body shape. I've never had a knife fall out of my pockets in over 20 years but a buddy of mine says they fall out all the time. I still keep a spare in the truck just in case I lose it when I am out of the house ;)
Like I said, I EDC my Huntsman. I have short legs and with about 50% of my trousers the Soldier will fall out. Usually I wear Craghoppers with the special zipped pockets (brilliant trousers!)
I do have a sheath I made for the Soldier, but the point is why produce such a good tool with (IMO) such a fundamental flaw in the design? I wonder if someone made a conscious decision to leave out the bail/split ring/hollow rivet and if so, what their thinking was.
-
A: Some of us actually prefer no smurfing keyring. (One of the best features of a Harvester over a Farmer is no keyring, IMHO.) :D
B: The bail was removed from the Vic Soldier when it was removed as part of the spec from the Swiss army. So, presumably simply a cost cutting measure, to avoid having to stock hollow rivets at all. (It was never for securing the knife, it was for using the knife as a plumb-bob for aiming a grenade thrower using a plumb-line.)
-
@Steinar said:
A: Some of us actually prefer no smurfing keyring. (One of the best features of a Harvester over a Farmer is no keyring, IMHO.) :DB: The bail was removed from the Vic Soldier when it was removed as part of the spec from the Swiss army. So, presumably simply a cost cutting measure, to avoid having to stock hollow rivets at all. (It was never for securing the knife, it was for using the knife as a plumb-bob for aiming a grenade thrower using a plumb-line.)
Well the up-shot of that costcutting decision is that now my grenade launcher is rendered un-aimable. What's a bombardier to do?
-
@Steinar said:
A: Some of us actually prefer no smurfing keyring. (One of the best features of a Harvester over a Farmer is no keyring, IMHO.) :D100% agree with Steinar here. Personally I prefer the 93mm alox without the ring and that is one reason I prefer the Harvester over the Farmer. No ring does not mean that is a design flaw, au contraire ::)
-
Fellow SAK lovers, I think we should have a poll here: Key ring or no key ring. I shall start this thread :) :sak:
-
B: The bail was removed from the Vic Soldier when it was removed as part of the spec from the Swiss army. ( [...], it was for using the knife as a plumb-bob for aiming a grenade thrower using a plumb-line.)
Well the up-shot of that costcutting decision is that now my grenade launcher is rendered un-aimable. What's a bombardier to do?
You must have one of the least sheeple-friendly EDCs I've ever heard of... :D
The easy answer would of course be to trade it with someone who's got a Wenger SI too much and a Vic Soldier tool little (Do such people exist?), but that would be too easy. My brother drilled holes or indents in the scales (not the rivets) of his Soldier, and then fitted a home made bail there. Not pretty, but it certainly seems to work. So it is not a hole all the way through, just indents deep enough to secure a bail properly.
On SOSAK a guy (perhaps he's reading that here now?) took some paracord and tightened it lengthwise around the knife in such a manner the cord rested against the closed tools, the backsprings and nestled in between the liners and rested against the tangs of the blade and the opposing awl. He used a sliding knot, so when he needed the knife, he simply loosened that knot and removed the lanyard altogether. (In other words, the cord in no place touched to outsides of the scales, just to try and make the idea as clear as possible.) It seemed a pretty good idea, I think.
-
That does sound like a good idea - Off to the bat cave to experiment!
Thanks for that

-
Sell one and then buy what you want.
Problem solved.Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
Break out the drill and make a hole.

-
Would have been a better demotivator if they didn't use a profession where 20 year old smurfs rake in the equivalent of the lifetime earnings of a common person each year. :)
-
I gave mine away in the end as I just didn't edc it because of it's lack of lanyard ring :(
Luckily I much prefer the Farmer anyway :)
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
