Key ring or NO key ring?
-
Keyring everytime. I hate to get a sak and it not have a keyring or a bail.

Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
The SAK Owner's Manual has opinions on this topic, as on many others:
"The Alinghi Yachtsman: Is there a lanyard ring on this working knife? Does a ship
have an anchor?"
"Because of a proven need for versatile, compact back-up equipment, the Victorinox
SAK is still issued to Star Truck astronauts -- with Velcro on one side to secure it in
weightless conditions. And of course ring for lanyard for EVA repairs." (When this was written in 2011 the USA still had a Space Shuttle program.)
"Pruning trees, a lanyard tied to the keyring and to yourself can save you
from climbing back down to get it, if nothing else. It is wise not to use tools
over somebody’s head, or to walk under a ladder - somebody is working with
tools up there. 'But I feel strongly both ways, and on the other hand the lanyard ring does get in the way in a pocket, and can annoy the hand during certain kinds of use...
All in all, I'll take a lanyard ring/keyring. Increases the SAK's versatility. -
@J Mackrel Jones said:
The SAK Owner's Manual has opinions on this topic, as on many others:"[...] And of course ring for lanyard for EVA repairs."
I would love if that usage consideration was personally relevant to me. :D
(When this was written in 2011 the USA still had a Space Shuttle program.)
Manned spaceflight? What a quaint idea, doing something with some vision that has no effect on the next quarter's earnings at Goldman Sachs. I'll shut up now, before I break the ban on talking politics. Let's just say this is something I feel strongly about...
-
Key ring or hollow rivet.
Yes! -
I usually carry my SAKs hanging in my pocket using a detachable keyring, so I voted for keyring.
-
"Even the lanyard rings, seemingly an add-on but in fact an
important feature, preventing dropping or loss as well as allowing connection
to keys or a mini-flash (and providing opportunities for improvisation),
differ between the two companies: Wenger’s are a simple, not-
quite-double ring with squared ends to the wire; Victorinox’s have a kink
in the angle-ended wire which forms into a flatter ring of two full circles."
SAKOM -
A keyring is a must for me, even on alox SAKs.
-
I don't always carry a SAK, but when I do, I prefer a keyring.
Stay Swiss my friends...
-
I carry both, but I voted no because I like not having a key ring a little better.

-
I voted no too. As far as full sized SAKs go, I prefer them without. Up to Executive size, it's ok, but anything larger than that is just unneeded. I'd prefer a hollow rivet on those or a lanyard hole over a keyring.
-
Too bad the 93 mm alox weren't all made with and without key rings, to please everybody.
Really... Why the Farmer must have the ring and the Harvester no?

(although this is nothing compared with other major Qs, like why not scissors on 93mm)
The old 108 mm line does it the best, IMO: all come with the hole (so one can attach a ring, shackle, lanyard, chain, etc) but no ring (so ones like me can pocket it like that).
-
The old 108 mm line does it the best, IMO: all come with the hole (so one can attach a ring, shackle, lanyard, chain, etc) but no ring (so ones like me can pocket it like that).
That sums it up! Best of all worlds and everybody's happy.
-
I gotta have the keyring point, if for no other reason than to attach a pull lanyard. I'll admit, putting a lanyard on a SAK can be a mixed blessing... they can get in the way when using tools that open to the same side as the keyring, and when you're trying to use a driver. But I still prefer them and would consider any SAK without one deformed.
Oddly, I find I am LESS likely to carry any of my smaller SAKs, like my Executive, on my keys... I just hate the way it beats the smurf out of them... I love my Exec, and bought two extra pairs of scales for it in fact, just to keep it nice looking. I guess it's because I carry it more often than any of my other SAKs; I consider it my 'gentleman's knife', so I want to keep it nice looking.
I have put my keys on my modded Outrider though, hard to mess up the nylon scales with keys.
-
I voted yes.
There are certain tools where the keyring becomes an annoyance. The short blade has already been pointed out. I haven't jumped into the SAK Whittling discussion, but have done some small wood carving, just to see if i cared for it (I ... don't), and very quickly realized how annoying the split ring was while using the short blade. But, I guess, if I were whittling more, I'd just slip the split ring off that particular knife.
So... I prefer the option of having the ring. I've used the key ring and a small binder clip to clip my Trekker to the inside of a pocket, keeping it upright for pocket carry.
I've never really needed a lanyard, but I do occasionally work on ladders, and like tools I don't have to chase.
-
I've always hated keyrings on tools/knives. For some reason, they make the tool/knife look cheap in my eyes, reminds me of sth cheap & Chinese.
-
Just kiddin'
Glad that we no ring fans are at least one of four. Almost.
to the ring fans -
@Lynn LeFey said:
Lynn, do you need ladders with those wings? :D
Unfortunately, they're vestigial. :D
My ability to fly has gone the way of the penguins.
Actually penguins do sort of fly, when they're in the water... if you've ever seen underwater footage of them, it definitely looks like they're flying, rather than swimming! :D
-
Sorry to bring this up again, but...the eyelet really hinders me, annoying, and on a modern Pioneer it's rather sharp too. These alox SAKs are supposed to do serious work. I understand why models like Electrician and Harvester come without. I guess with a splitring and lanyard attached it's more comfortable in hand, but still. Can't the factory make everybody happy and come up with something that's up to par? Or offer them with or without, like the Sportsman. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login