Anyone edc a 108mm?
-
@Steinar said:
Well... tested as in "follows the specification", no doubt, tested as in "check if it's any good", I have no idea. Some military equipment works great, some of it requires language not suited to a family friendly forum.
I agree that meeting order specification does not mean it is going to work. Just because somebody gets what they asked for, doesn't mean they necessarily got what they need
-
@Steinar said:
Depressing example: The Norwegian army boot used to be a great hiking boot. Simple, strong, well-made and comfortable, a lot of people leaving the service "lost" their pair to use for hiking, and many civilians wanting a cheap, good pair of boots bought the model. Then, a couple of years ago some economy smurfs figured out the boots really didn't need to last for years when typical service time is shorter, so the army actually requested lower quality from the factory to get a cheaper boot. And, yes, the new boots don't last, as requested...
Ouch! So I guess the Norwegian army did not choose these boots for actual combat, real war (knock on wood) conditions. Me thinks that one may do well there without a pocket knife in the winter, not so much without good boots.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Well... tested as in "follows the specification", no doubt, tested as in "check if it's any good", I have no idea. Some military equipment works great, some of it requires language not suited to a family friendly forum.

I agree that meeting order specification does not mean it is going to work. Just because somebody gets what they asked for, doesn't mean they necessarily got what they need
I agree with this in general but in this particular case why did Victorinox not only accept (ok, this maybe was for revenue) to manufacture these GAKs, but also build their own variations and keep them for such a long time if the combo tool was a failure? Do you doubt that Vic at the time would see the difference between their own built saw variations? Could be, but I tend to not believe it.
Would be interesting to hear from folks who were actually issued these GAKs and what their thoughts were about it in general and in particular the nasty saw.
SakWiki has good words to say about it:
http://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Saw-wood
"The 108mm Wood saw not only has the reputation as being one of the best for cutting wood, it also contain a unique Combo Tool integrated into its tip. The tool that can be used as a Bottle Opener, Can Opener or Screwdriver. A later version of the tool appeared on the knife commonly referred to as the GAK-2, which added a ))Nail-File((/))Match-Strike(( tool to the side of the blade. This easily makes the 108mm wood saw the most versatile version of the wood saw. The 108mm saw often has a removable blade-guard. This is a very good feature for this model, since the combo tool on the tip would in theory be used more frequently and the guard makes the tool much safer in this usage. In earlier Catalogs this tool is referred to as the Utility Tool."
I completely agree the wood saw on 93/91 mm and 111 mm are more efficient and more easy to be used with good results, at least on the dry wood. But I suspect the 108 mm saw has its strong points as well, like mentioned in the review and maybe more. Certainly it appears less friendly to casual users like me, but I still like it.
What I do personally really like on the combo tool is the bottle cap opener. IMHO that is the best bottle cap opener that I tried on a SAK. And there is a screwdriver and a can opener too.

-
Hey, I'm just giving feedback based on my (albeit limited) experience, and ability to use a measuring implement. If other people have had different experiences that's fine by me, and I'd love to hear it

As for the other variations, I'd suggest they had tooling and the opportunity to use it for revenue in market opportunity beyond the primary supply contract. Let's not go down the road of assuming a company (any company) is perfect and never puts commercial decisions first, or never gets anything wrong - ever ::)
-
Completely agree

This is an interesting topic for me because I personally like the 108 mm SAKs (including the GAK) but at the same time to be sincere I encountered myself frustration in using that saw. I wish it is just me not knowing yet how to use it to get the best out of it but


-
These 108's are made for modding

-
@Waterlander said:
These 108's are made for modding
Yes and no. There are very few parts for these series. For example, if anybody else noticed this, there are just two backspring models for the entire 108 mm line. One is used for the layers with a tool on the back (awl or corkscrew, just two) and the other is used for the layers without back tool.
The tools themselves are very few: the main blade, the combo tool (with and without that nailfile), the "gutting" blade (with or without serrations) and the clip point blade (available only on the Mauser, Walther and the +B 3 blade special that I so much like and cannot find).
-
Hmm, you got a point. But there are a lot old GAK's around for donor. And perhaps 93mm tools can be used? I really don't know, not my department.
I do feel these 108's have potential. -
-
This is turning into a great thread guys

-
I think I'm gonna do a 85/91/93/108/111mm feld test myself in the next few days cause of this thread. Not that I don't trust you Al. I just got interested.

-
Go for it mate
Based on the dressing down I got earlier, you had better do dry wood and greenwood though

Another thing that might have made a difference to my results is I was cutting small pieces off a stick, rather than a thin branch off a tree. I reckon if the tree had effectively got hold of one end of the stick, that aggressive (albeit short and fat) tooth form may have worked better. I do need to try it out at pruning tasks to see what the difference is
-
@enki_ck said:
I think I'm gonna do a 85/91/93/108/111mm feld test myself in the next few days cause of this thread. Not that I don't trust you Al. I just got interested.
I'd be interested in the results of that too mate

-
I have a used Victorinox 108mm GAK, which i bought from a german military surplus some time ago. I take it often with me and it is great. especially in woods settings. :tool:
-
Well I've ordered a Victorinox Safari Trooper with red scales for my son to give to me on my birthday later this month, and I'll keep it on wood's duties

-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
@enki_ck said:
I think I'm gonna do a 85/91/93/108/111mm feld test myself in the next few days cause of this thread. Not that I don't trust you Al. I just got interested.

I'd be interested in the results of that too mate

Videos uploading. It's boiling hot here again so I decided to postpone the trip to the woods for the fresh green wood test and went with a 3,5cm thick dried acacia tree. Not so smart in a furnace of a workshop :ahhh
Results were .... wait and see

-
Comparison of Swiss Army Knife saws
Saws used: Wenger Master, Victorinox Ranger (both 5 layered with saw in the middle layer), Farmer, GAK, Outrider, Spirit X and LM Wave.
The multitool saws did the worst. The GAK saw on dry wood confirmed what Al said, which surprised me as I always had good results with it as far as I can remember. But I did always use it in the woods on green wood so the jury is out on that one. The can opener part did annoy me, it kept getting stuck. ::) The 93mm Farmer and the 111mm Outrider didn't do bad but to my surprise the shorter 85mm Wenger and the 91mm Vic (same saw as the Farmer though) did the best. I contribute this to the fact that they were both the widest handled tools used and provided better grip. So the length of the blade was less important than the good grip these two provided.

Conclusion, if you're going to the woods or camping take a folding saw. They are lightweight, strong and much more useful. (I can't believe I'm recommending a dedicated tool :ahhh but at least it's folding, right? )
-
-
Cracking test there mate, thanks!

-
Good show Nikola

I'm glad I wasn't the only one who struggled so much on dry wood with the GAK blade. So frustrating :ahhh and it was very interesting to see how difficult that was in comparison with everything else. At least I now know it wasn't me being useless

My conclusion was the same (use a folding saw) when I did a test on a CS4, Swisstool and Swissgrip (I think it was mky CS4 vs Deluxe Tinker thread). I was surprised to see the Outrider didn't do better with the longer saw blade. I have high hopes for my Rangergrip 90 when it lands for that reason, but I do accept it's still going to struggle against my Bahco Laplander - superb bit of kit
Top job mate

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login