Which 84mm model to get?
-
Of those mentioned I'd track down an 84mm Golfer ... oh wait ... that wasn't mentioned
:DThe Tourist was my first SAK and it got me hooked. Personally I like to have scissors though, which puts the Golfer top of the running for me. Out of the current models I'd say Tourist or Sportsman depending on whether a second blade or a nail file is better for you.
If you like the smaller SAKs I'd also suggest having a look at the Executive. It is smaller still, and the blades are not as substantial, but you get a lot of versatility in a small package ... including scissors :D
-
That's a tough question. The Waiter was the SAK that got me hooked as an adult and it's a great minimalist tool. The Sportsman packs a whole lot of features in a very small package. Given that you already have and like the two layer Recruit I'm going to say Sportsman. No, Waiter. No, Sportsman.... :ahhh
Waiter. Maybe.

-
Both JerseyDevil and 50ft Trad kinda beat me to the punch here.84Mil golfers are good,if slightly tricky to find,and Wengers?85mil verses 84mil,with tons of tool options.Thier combo tool is better than the Vic,as are the scissors
-
I'll second Kirk and say take a look at the similar sized Wengers. Another suggestion would be to check with Felinevet, who often has a wide selection of decent used knives at very reasonable prices. Pick up two or three different used ones to play around with.
http://www.edcsource.com/FELINEVET-SWISS-ARMY-KNIFE-STORE,name,100015,user_id,shop
-
I have both a Waiter and a Sportsman, plus a very small assortment of 85mm Wengers; of the options, I'd go for the Sportsman - I love a nail file and the opener layer of the Sportsman, combined with the T+T and corkscrew. If I'm not carrying my Explorer, Compact, or a thicker SAK, I'm often carrying my Sportsman. :)
If you need scissors, throw an Executive or Ambassador on your keys. ;)
-
I was going to keep my suggestion to one of the models mentioned in the original post, but now that Wenger has been mentioned..... ;) Some people don't like Wengers for whatever reason. I was one of them for a while. All my SAKs were Vics and that was that as far as I was concerned. But now...If you asked me right now what my favorite SAK is, I'd answer the Evo16. I like the 85mm size, I love the scissors and the locking driver, and today I did a little mod to the nail file like ICanFixThat mentioned, giving it an SD tip. Perfect! If 84mm is the size you're looking for, for 1mm more Wenger offers a lot more tool combinations without having to try and locate a discontinued model.

-
I'd agree with JD ... to a point. Wenger's classic line were very good alternatives, but I'm not enamoured with their move to evo scales nor to locking blades. Their locking drivers are very good, as are their other implements, but it appears they have a desire to not step on their sister company's toes and their designs are on the whole moving away from what I personally want in a SAK. Each to their own though, I know the blade locks and evo scales do have their fans - I just wish the classic scaled non-lockers were still as freely available as well. I have wondered if this is why Victorinox has held off expanding the 84mm line, to maintain separation and clear distinction in identity between the two company's product lines
-
I think I will go with the Sportsman then. It does seem to be the most complete package. I do not use scissors often and when I do, the Classic or Swisscard are capable enough. Thanks for all the replies.
-
I was thinking...why buy a new SAK? why not buy a vintage SAK?
You get better quality, something special, for less money if you shop around on flebay.
Just an example:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/230808454085?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649 J -
My favourite is the lumberjack. I have a couple of economy line models and an alox.
The economy line versions live in my gun safe with my other discontinued SAKs. And the alox lives in my pocket.
And despite my paying more than three times as much for the alox than I did for the other two put together, they I still consider treasure and the alox is just my pocket knife.

-
You left out the Cadet, which might not be a bad choice as it is the slimmest of all all the 84mm two-layers, but y ou don't get the glasses screwdriver and it's holder.
Of the unavailable, the 84mm Golfer is a shorter Compact, so if the Compact feels funny, it might be worth trying to track one down.
-
Thanks for suggesting the Cadet and the Golfer. However, the Cadet has no backside tools, which I really like to have. Furthermore, I would rather not get a discontinued model for two reasons. Firstly, they are more expensive than current models. Secondly and more importantly, older models are very likely in used condition. I want to be the one who puts the knife in used condition.
Still, the Sportsman seems to be the most complete package to me, so I will probably get that model.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
