Anyone edc a 108mm?
-
@qwotchi said:
I also have to recommend the bottle opening prowess of the combi opener, a while back I tested it along with the 91mm and 93mm openers and the 108mm was most effective, I tested it quite a few times, just to be sure.
It also looks like a mad camel with a stretchy neck, so bonus points.
Exactly!
The bottle cap opener on this nasty looking (but so cool, IMHO) combo tool to me is the best one by far compared with all other cap opener SAK tools that I had the chance to try, on Vic's 111, 93, 91, 84 and (as the least effective, for emergencies only) 58 mm as well as Wenger's 130 and 85 mm. Or at least this was my limited experience. And I am happy that I am not alone here.:D
-
@enki_ck said:
Comparison of Swiss Army Knife sawsSaws used: Wenger Master, Victorinox Ranger (both 5 layered with saw in the middle layer), Farmer, GAK, Outrider, Spirit X and LM Wave.
The multitool saws did the worst. The GAK saw on dry wood confirmed what Al said, which surprised me as I always had good results with it as far as I can remember. But I did always use it in the woods on green wood so the jury is out on that one. The can opener part did annoy me, it kept getting stuck. ::) The 93mm Farmer and the 111mm Outrider didn't do bad but to my surprise the shorter 85mm Wenger and the 91mm Vic (same saw as the Farmer though) did the best. I contribute this to the fact that they were both the widest handled tools used and provided better grip. So the length of the blade was less important than the good grip these two provided.

Conclusion, if you're going to the woods or camping take a folding saw. They are lightweight, strong and much more useful. (I can't believe I'm recommending a dedicated tool :ahhh but at least it's folding, right? )
Excellent Tests. Thank you for doing these. I guess I'll keep the folding saw handy, but I don't get out much any more where I need them.
I'm very surprised on the 111mm performance.
I can't wait for the next round.
-
@enki_ck said:
The bad results of the 108mm and the not as good as expected results of the 111mm are still bugging me. I'll redo the test on dry wood tomorrow and try to go to the woods in the afternoon for some green wood tests.Due to a freaky thumb twisting I'm a bit late with the tests. It's still not healed properly but I did redo the dry wood tests on 108mm and 111mm. Both did better (may have been the heath during the first try getting to me) but the 108mm still doesn't get good grades, to much sticking and a very rough finish. You can compare the cuts and see the differences. I used the same wood used in the initial test. I still feel the thicker handled 91mm and 85mm saws did the best.
-
Wow I didnt realize the 108 was so bad, but I guess it does have a fairly short cut length. For any sawing around the house I use a japanese (silky something) tree pruning saw and it cuts through branches like a light sabre through a jawa. So I never really use the SAK ones much. I think I used a farmer saw once but thats about it, Im not a big saw user on a pocket knife.
-
Of course


-
Pwetty!

-
Lovely job there mate :)
-
I did a (subjective) saw test myself, with the knives I have.
And no users - only those with fresh saw blades (except for the Spirit and Elinox).
All sawing was done on the same broomstick, clamped in a vice.Here are the votes of the dutch jury:
At first place:
- Victorinox Rucksack (111mm, ironwood, 3 layers)
Second place:
- Victorinox Spirit (stainless, multitool)
Third place:
- Victorinox Officier (91mm, blue cellidor, 5 layers)
Fourth place:
- Victorinox Farmer (93mm, blue alox, 3 layers)
Fifth place:
- Victorinox Lumberjack (84mm, blue nylon, 2 layers)
Sixth place:
- Elinox Lumberjack (84mm, red cellidor, 2 layers)
Seventh place:
- Victorinox Lumberjack (84mm, plain alox, 2 layers)
Eight place:
- Victorinox Trooper (108mm, bocote, 2 layers)
(top to bottom in pic)
I will tell you my findings later on.

-
It's a funny thing, but I find the 111 and 91 SAK saws really good (can't comment on GAK's as I've never tried one). Couldn't get on with the LM Juice saw but like my Blast saw??
Great thread!
Atb, Jon.
-
Oh nice another Saw test. What/Whom comprised the Dutch Jury? Is it time for you to give us your official verdict?
Was there really any difference between the lumberjacks?
-
I edc'ed a Gak for a while and really liked it , i got it after the gak passaround that was done here on MTO, i liked it but ended up going on the hunt for all the different makes and it started to get expensive so i sold them all, stupid really as i should of kept atleast one of them, well got another on the way so ill give it more of a chance as a nice knife,

-
@ICanFixThat said:
Oh nice another Saw test. What/Whom comprised the Dutch Jury? Is it time for you to give us your official verdict?Was there really any difference between the lumberjacks?
Yes major difference! Please hold on a little longer. Just got home from work
and I need a beer first!
-
Here are some of my thoughts.
First of all let me say that I'm a cabinet maker by profession, so I know how to handle a woodsaw. Twenty years of woodworking and doing rockclimbing as a hobby, has given me strong hands. So it's fair to say I don't get fatigue quickly. This is importent, because it effects the test results. Ofcourse the saw blade itself also plays a major role how it performs. But the handle is just as important. In general I found that a boxier shape works best. It lets you grip the knife secure with thumb on top. This will help greatly keeping the saw blade straight all the way through the cut, effortless. It is far less effective, far harder to control and far more fatigue holding the handle in a pinch grip between thumb and indexfinger. When doing cross cutting, you get the straightest cut without binding if the blade is rigid. If it's too flexible for sure you have to watch this. On the other hand you want a nice thin blade, so this is a trade of. A dedicate hand saw for precise cross cutting solves this by putting a rigid piece on the spine of a thin saw blade (hand saw in the picture with orange handle). Let's just forget the shape of the teeth for a moment (all Vics are the same except for the 108 and Elinox). I like to mention that SAK's need relative large teeth to be effective because only short strokes can be made.Now, for the test... (back after the coffee)
-
Cutting medium is a long broom stick, clamped in a vice, 10 slices with each saw blade.
Reference I used a Bahco Laplander and Opinel Folding Saw. :DAt first place:
- Victorinox Rucksack (111mm, ironwood, 3 layers)
This SAK has been fitted by me with desert ironwood scales, mildly contour shaped to my liking.
The handle shape and lenght is the best of the bunch. 3 layers on the 111mm frame are excellent for comfort and grip. I must add that wooden scales are my prefered handle material. But the standard nylon scales are great, better then cellidor on a worker. The keyring eyelt (at the back end) has no sharp edges and doesn't hinder at all, nor do the backtools. The saw blade is the longest and thus fastest cutting with the least effort. It's also a little thicker and substantial stronger than on the 91/93mm. Prefered to take into the woods.
Second place:
- Victorinox Spirit (stainless, multitool)
We all agree how nice the curved handles on the Spirit are if you open them up for the pliers.
Handles closed with the saw out and the feel is fantastic too. Unfortunately rather slippery as well. But the rigid saw blade, the easy of keeping it straight, the speed of cutting without much effort, the weight of the multitool helping, makes it functions very well. Build like a tank and it locks too, that's a bonus. Prefered to carry every day.
Third place:
- Victorinox Officier (91mm, blue cellidor, 5 layers)
The reason why I've put this SAK on third place over the Farmer, is because I find the extra layers helping (saw blades are exactly the same). My hand gets tired sooner with less layers. You need to make more small corrections with your hand muscles and you need to grip it tighter. My 5 layer works easy, fast and well, considering it's blade lenght. It is a mod, and the back is rather flush without backtools getting in the way. The keyring-eyelet is grinded off as well. If you go 3 layers, you will find the corkscrew and keyring under your thumb which doesn't help.
Fourth place:
- Victorinox Farmer (93mm, blue alox, 3 layers)
It's a close fourth. The flush backsprings and the textured alox scales clearly win over cellidor. The Farmer does everything well, and nothing poor. I have a 2 layer alox Woodsman as well, but the boxier shape of the Farmer works better for sawing. Easier to keep a loose grip and let the saw do the work. I do have one big issue with the Farmer, and that is the sharp eyelet at the backend cutting in my handpalm. This clearly has it effects on prolonged sawing.
I probably forgot a bunch to say, and please do chime in, but next up the Lumberjacks...
- Victorinox Rucksack (111mm, ironwood, 3 layers)
-
Lumberjacks:
All of them have nice and flush backsprings. On all of them the lanyard attachment sits at the tang of the saw blade. At least the vintage Elinox has a bail that folds away unlike the other two modern versions with sharp ring. The saw blade on the Elinox differs as well, it only cuts on a backwards stroke. Not bad, but it ends at sixth place overall.
The boxy blue nylon Lumberjack performs not bad for such a small package. The alox scaled Lumberjack on the other end is much too thin to handle well. You get fatigued quickest and sawing is ackward to keep it straight upright and smooth going, compared to the other contenders in this test. The alox Lumberjack is often used in a PSK, and it does its job in a pinch. But I feel in a survival situation when your hands are cold, frozen etc. I would rather have the big 108 GAK in my pocket, although it ended at last place. The aggressive saw blade on the GAK binds halfway through the cut, almost impossible to do. You have to turn the wood and cut from several sides to make it work.
That said, if you take it into the woods and use it in a more aggressive manner on green woods it performs better. Like cutting a branch halfway and hit it on a rock to split along the grain. Or make a quick forcefull cut and snap the rest off.JMHO

-
Thanks for the rundown
Very insightful 
Interesting to see the slightly shorter Spirit edge out the longer 91/93mm saws. Interesting also to see the 108 as the choice for a survival kit over all the other options
Is that due to taking other things into account such as weight etc? -
@50ft-trad said:
Thanks for the rundown
Very insightful 
Interesting to see the slightly shorter Spirit edge out the longer 91/93mm saws. Interesting also to see the 108 as the choice for a survival kit over all the other options
Is that due to taking other things into account such as weight etc?Spririt blade is just a hinge shorter, that doesn't effect much.
Sorry, but I did NOT say my prefered choice for a survival kit is the GAK 108mm.
I said that in a survival situation I rather have the GAK in my pocket then the alox Lumberjack. -
Thanks for the clarification ;)
-
no worries :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login