Skeletool VS Crusial
-
I would suggest the Skeletool over the Crucial, but the Crucial F.A.S.T. over the Skeletool. The Skeletool is a much better made tool than the Crucial (either model) but Gerber really stepped up their game for the F.A.S.T. version which includes an assisted opening blade that's fun to play with. Add in longer drivers and a smaller package than the Skeletool and the F.A.S.T. beats it out.
However, if you want the normal Crucial, I really wouldn't suggest it. The build quality and materials is really quite awful. In fact, a few years ago we had gotten a bunch of them from Gerber to give away, and embarrassingly enough, one of them was already broken while still in the package. The original Crucial was a good idea marred by very poor execution, which is part of why I was so pleased with the F.A.S.T. version. It fixed most of the mistakes of the original.
As for why I'd take the F.A.S.T. over the Skeletool, well, the Skele still has a better build quality but it's too bulky for what it is. It's a neat looking doodad for sure, but with the carabiner and screwdriver end it's a little long. Lop those off (as in the Freestyle) and you lose most of the functionality and are left with a blade and pliers in a package the same size as (you guessed it) the F.A.S.T., but the F.A.S.T. still has screwdivers, bottle opener etc too.
Def
-
Thanks Def.
I already have a Cruisial. (I have actually had 2. The first one broke after about a years use, and I just got a new one from Gerber) I must admit that I like the crusial, it has all the tools you normally need. it is however a bit heavy in the pocket so I don't think it will replace my Pioneer as a EDC tool. And I really dont need the pliers that often.
It was mostly curiosity that made ask if anyone owned both. They should be fierce competitors, but noone talks about the crusial, and everyone talk about the skeletool. I guess a bad quality reputation spreads like wildfire in this place, and that is probably the reason why it is "out of the game".The Cruisial Fast looks like a good option, but the springassisted blade will probably get me in trouble with the law.
Another question: hows the Octane compared to the Cruisial and the skeletool?
-
I thing Gerber made themselves a bad name with some of the cheaper models they produced for mass marketing- models like the Evo, ripstop, Suspension, Resolve etc had a really bad name. Also, they have a rep for being second best to Leatherman and in a lot of people's minds, "second best" is synonymous with "first loser." You see the same kind of thing with SAKs- Victorinox is the better one and people who have never even handled Wenger say they aren't any good.
As for the Octane, I think that it's the best of the bunch. I really like the Octane a lot, although the plier head does tend to slide out when pocket carried. Five minutes with a Dremel Tool will fix that mind you, but then the pliers won't flick out. I don't consider that a huge deal since I generally hold mine by the side (holding the locks in) and give it a shake and the plier head is out. I do that with all my sliding head tools.
To me the Octane, despite being made overseas, is a great successor to the MP600/MP400 series. It's just as bulletproof as the USA made ones but it is very slim (for a multitool) and pocketable with a decent OH blade. The blade is ok, but nothing special- some like it, some don't. I am one of the ones who likes the blade, but the locking bar is a bit flimsy looking. It's not actually flimsy, it just looks that way, but perception is everything, right?
So, in order, my choices would be:
1- Octane
2- Crucial F.A.S.T.
3- Skeletool15- Crucial
:D
Def
-
Another vote for the Octane here

For me the Octane beats everything in it's class, and I will freely admit I've not tried everything in it's class :D :D :D I have however tried the Sideclip, Toolclip, Skeletool, Li'l Guppie, Zillatool Jnr, Kick, played with the Wingman and Sidekick, avoided the Crucial in it's many guises as it's ergos look too much like the Skeletool ... and the Octane is the top of the tree for me.
I must say I really like the Toolclip and Li'l Guppie and I do use and carry them, but the Octane will find it's way into my pocket more often. I just wish the blade was plain edged and non-locking :-\
-
+1 on the Octane.
I was looking at the Skeletool vs. the Crucial vs. the Octane a while ago, and decided on the Skeletool. Big mistake IMO. It and I didn't get along at all. >:( A few weeks later at a local sproting goods store, I came across an Octane with no package for 50% off. I decided to give it a shot, and boy am I glad I did. For a light duty tool the Octane is hard to beat. The pliers and drivers are very good, the package opener is more useful than you'd think, and the blade is not as flimsy as some make it out to be. The only minor issue is the pliers deploying in your pocket, but like Def said that's a quick fix, I just haven't gotten around to it yet. When I'm off from work and just lounging around the house fiddling with things, the Octane is a regular. 
-
Thanks guys!
Looks like the Octane just made 1.place on my MT wish list.
-
Ive always compared the crucial to the skele and the octane to the wingman. I have all four and almost never carry/use the Gerbs. I find the skele's bit driver and blade leaps and bounds above what the crucial has going on. Considering how much love the wingman gets its pretty sad that I would choose it over the octane. I do appreciate what Gerber was trying to do with these tools I just can't deal with the fit and finish of them. This is all just my opinion and I did have high hopes for these tools before I actually used them. I have all four I can take some pics of them later if you'd like.
Keep calm and jeep on
-
Pics would be great. it would give me a good idea of their size compared to eachother.
-
Speaking of the wingman...
I actually bought my wingman as a replacement for the broken Cruisial. I EDC'd the Wingman for about a week and then discovered that I actually missed my Crusial. You will probably think I'm crazy when I say this, but I actually prefer the Crusial over the Wingman. The wingman is better built, but the Crusial is better designed. But thats just my opinion. -
I own all 4 and I would go with the wingman or up to a rebar or down to a mini. The crucial and octane will not stand up to use, not the ones I have. The octane liner lock bends each time I use it
-
@scrappy said:
I own all 4 and I would go with the wingman or up to a rebar or down to a mini. The crucial and octane will not stand up to use, not the ones I have. The octane liner lock bends each time I use itI'm wondering what job you are doing to apply the pressure on the lock? I only ask as most basic cutting tasks shouldn't be applying any. Just curious. :)
back to the OP. I have to say I wasn't very happy with the Crucial when I played with one but will also admit I didn't ever own one to give it a real workout. I did however own the Skele and, despite the excellent build quality, I just couldn't get alone with it. Grant pretty much sums up my opinion.
I do now like my Octane though I will say that I did have my issues with it to start with. See post here for my initial thoughts; /post/569779
-
I own all 4 and I would go with the wingman or up to a rebar or down to a mini. The crucial and octane will not stand up to use, not the ones I have. The octane liner lock bends each time I use it
I'm wondering what job you are doing to apply the pressure on the lock? I only ask as most basic cutting tasks shouldn't be applying any. Just curious. :)
:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh Scrappy, mate - woooaaaahhh!

If any liner locks bend when you use it, you're either doing it wrong or you're using the wrong gear mate :-\ Personally if I can't do the job safely with a slip joint, I consider the job to be unsuitable for ANY folder and go for a fixed knife ... or chisel ... or whatever.
Sorry Scrappy, just my opinion - you do whatever works for you, they're your fingers

-
I've tried to like the Crucial FAST, but just can't. It's probably because I had a Skeletool CX first and really like it for light duty around the house.
The Octane is a different matter. I had a couple in the MTO Store and they sold quickly. I've wished a few times that I had purchased another for me. I could see the Octane filling the role that my Skeletool CX occupies.
-
@Travis Autry said:
I've tried to like the Crucial FAST, but just can't. It's probably because I had a Skeletool CX first and really like it for light duty around the house.The Octane is a different matter. I had a couple in the MTO Store and they sold quickly. I've wished a few times that I had purchased another for me. I could see the Octane filling the role that my Skeletool CX occupies.
I thought the same thing Travis yet my Octane still sits collecting dust.
Keep calm and jeep on
-
I had a Crucial for a while, but ended up giving it away. It was a little too chunky for my tastes. I had a Skele CX for about a year before it jumped out of my pocket one night while walking my wife's dog, and I miss it dearly. I'd still be carrying it regularly if I had it, but alas, I can't afford to replace it right now.
I agree about the Octane; much better than the Crucial. Longer blade with more PE but the same sheepsfoot-utility profile, better phillips driver, and easier to open. Also nice and slim in the pocket in comparison.
I still preferred my CX to the Octane though. Admittedly, the Octane is more comparable to the regular Skele, but I like the swappable bits on the Skele better, and the plier head feels better made IMO. On the other hand, I like the blade profile of the Octane better, but the OHO hole isn't as nice as the Skele's. The package opener on the Octane is useful, as it also works well as a gouge/scraper. For me, one place where the Octane really falls flat is the bottle opener; it's awkward to use, and takes some practice to learn to work it smoothly. The carabiner clip on the Skele is not only a great bottle opener, but is a great way to attach the tool to a pack.
-
I actually really like the cap lifter on the Octane, totally simple and no moving parts at all. I will be the first to agree though that the Skele has an excellent cap lifter too. :)
-
I own all 4 and I would go with the wingman or up to a rebar or down to a mini. The crucial and octane will not stand up to use, not the ones I have. The octane liner lock bends each time I use it
I'm wondering what job you are doing to apply the pressure on the lock? I only ask as most basic cutting tasks shouldn't be applying any. Just curious. :)
back to the OP. I have to say I wasn't very happy with the Crucial when I played with one but will also admit I didn't ever own one to give it a real workout. I did however own the Skele and, despite the excellent build quality, I just couldn't get alone with it. Grant pretty much sums up my opinion.
I do now like my Octane though I will say that I did have my issues with it to start with. See post here for my initial thoughts; /post/569779
When I say the "ones" i have, I mean the tools I have. The jobs are just normal use. Like cutting tape and rope. I often place my thumb on the spine of the blade. It doesn't bend drastically but it flexs and gives me the impression if I pushed hard it would bend.
-
Just got a Octane in the mail

I like it a lot. I especially like the blade and all locking tools. Im going to put it into my work EDC rotation and see how it performes over time.
-
I can't wait to hear your thoughts on it after you've put it to work. :D
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




