Toughest multitool out there?
-
I`m going with the Craftsman Professional. The Vise Grip 5WR Toolbox is up there also. :)
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I was just responding to a post in the MTO Facebook group about the SwissTool and I said that it was (in my mind at least) one of the toughest tools out there. To me, it's really only second to the Wenger SwissGrip (aka WengerGrip) in overall toughness. So, the question is, what do you think is the toughest tool (or tools) and what makes you say that?Def
That's pretty much my assessment to

-
I am going to propose the SOG Blacktip. They are the biggest plier based folding multitool out there and the compound leverage is fantastic. The plier jaws are long and there is carbide inserts for the cutters. But if you think the Swiss Tool is heavy this one is even heavier.
Bruce
-
What about Multitasker ? being CNC cut from a D2 steel billet they are tough as nails

-
@Bruce909 said:
I am going to propose the SOG Blacktip. They are the biggest plier based folding multitool out there and the compound leverage is fantastic. The plier jaws are long and there is carbide inserts for the cutters. But if you think the Swiss Tool is heavy this one is even heavier.Bruce
I had not thought about the sog blacktip. It is longer but I dont think it is thicker or wider in the plier head. Am I wrong?
I have never seen the carbide cutter version. I think it was sold in a very limited number. I know the west marine in utah never carried it. -
I am going to propose the SOG Blacktip. They are the biggest plier based folding multitool out there and the compound leverage is fantastic. The plier jaws are long and there is carbide inserts for the cutters. But if you think the Swiss Tool is heavy this one is even heavier.
Bruce
I had not thought about the sog blacktip. It is longer but I dont think it is thicker or wider in the plier head. Am I wrong?
I have never seen the carbide cutter version. I think it was sold in a very limited number. I know the west marine in utah never carried it.I don't think it is thicker but I do think is was slightly wider...if I get a chance I will get a Blacktip and Powerlock from the garage and compare.
The Blacktip is $ 14.00 off at West Marine right now...I'm waiting for $ 20 but when you are in there take a look at the back of the package...they did say carbide cutter the last time I bought one. I need to take a really close look to see if there are soldered inserts in the cutters. But you are correct the insert ones are super rare.
Bruce
-
Interesting that the Swisstool has so many recommendations going for it so far. I gave one a week's worth of work at my job (PC & networking installations, sometimes in crawlspaces, basements and attics) and went back to a Surge. The lateral flex in the tools; play in the plier jaws and knife blades; locks flexing under load; and slipperiness under tight grip just didn't inspire confidence. The feel of solidity just wasn't there compared to my Surge.
-
@Yalius said:
Interesting that the Swisstool has so many recommendations going for it so far. I gave one a week's worth of work at my job (PC & networking installations, sometimes in crawlspaces, basements and attics) and went back to a Surge. **The lateral flex in the tools; play in the plier jaws and knife blades; locks flexing under load; and slipperiness under tight grip just didn't inspire confidence. The feel of solidity just wasn't there ** compared to my Surge.That is close to my experience and opion of the SwissTool. :)
-
@Yalius said:
Interesting that the Swisstool has so many recommendations going for it so far. I gave one a week's worth of work at my job (PC & networking installations, sometimes in crawlspaces, basements and attics) and went back to a Surge. The lateral flex in the tools; play in the plier jaws and knife blades; locks flexing under load; and slipperiness under tight grip just didn't inspire confidence. The feel of solidity just wasn't there compared to my Surge.But, the Swisstool didn't actually break, did it?
-
@parnass said:
But, the Swisstool didn't actually break, did it?This is true, but when you're used to something that actually feels solid in your hand, the flex and the looseness of the joints in the Swisstool left me feeling less than confident in using it as hard as I sometimes need to. When I was using the file to clean up a channel in a baseboard, the tools were flexing enough around the pivot pin enough to make a clicking sound, and I could feel the file wobbling around the pin. Even using the prybar to pull staples made the handles feel like they were flexing under load. Yes, the shiny finish and clickiness of the locks is neat from an engineering point of view, but if I'm crawling under a house and I don't know what I'm going to run into, I'd rather bring with me a tool I feel confident isn't going to snap or come loose at an inopportune time. My Surge has that no-nonsense feel of being a work tool, and the Swisstool didn't. The added difficulty of sometimes finding and deploying the proper tool -- which you can do by feel on a Surge-- made it just not an ideal choice for the job. It just had this feeling of being a tool for someone who's more interested in the pleasure of using a tool than in getting something done as quickly and efficiently as possible.
-
@Ombudsman said:
What about Multitasker ? being CNC cut from a D2 steel billet they are tough as nails
I think the series 2X may be. Bigger head than the previous versions and as you mentioned, it is tool steel. I know it pretty strong from the three wire tests I did. I would cut three hard wires at a time. Sog, Swiss, Leatherman, and the 2X were all able to cut it.
The schrade cutter was too short to cut three at a time and the gerber tools I used hurt my hands too much. The evolve never cut it and the freehand eventualy did but my hand was in severe pain from putting 220 pounds on it and it just dug into my hand. -
My LM ST300 is my heavier use multitool, but the handles flex and twist a lot when you try to cut thick wire.
I think that for fold out multitools this is expected. A pop-out Gerber or SOG paratool has less flex. For cutting strength though, a standard SOG wins.
My swisstools are too prety :D for any actual use. -
Wow, this thread took a direction I didn't expect. While I like the swisstools a ton(don't get mad guys), I don't prefer them over Leatherman tools at all. I feel much more confident in my Wave when it comes to heavy stuff over my Spirit.
My only experience with a full Swisstool was brief, but it did indeed feel like a brick in hand, and I guess I believe fully that it can take some serious abuse.
-
I think my vote goes for Swisstool too. I've got a ST300 as well but I don't really like it, as said above its the flex in the handles that irritates me. The Swisstool feels much better IMO.
Regards, Jon.
-
What? You guys must have big brick laying hands. I crank on my st3 and it is my hands that give out miles before flex or tool become an issue. Even with the far more comfy handles on the surge the limitation is still me. There have been times where I've backed off with a tool, cutting, prying or twisting etc when it is the wrong tool for the job. User technique and experiance has to be considered. Having the toughest, best tool or looking good is one thing, using them and being able to get the job done is another.
-
+1 for the Swisstool.

The moment i used it, i have never regretted for buying it.
-
before I opened this thread only one word came to mind......SWISSTOOL.
its beefy...its a brick...its just tuff as sh!t.
-
I'm with Zoidberg, I have never been able to make the handles of the ST300 flex all that much, and I have a decent grip. BUT, the same can be said of the Swisstool, I couldn't hurt that one.
-
It's interesting- there seems to be a lot less choices than I thought there would be. The general consensus (with a few other thoughts) is that the SwissTool is pretty well the toughest. If I was half as cool as the Brits here I would have had the sense to start a poll on this one!

Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





