Multi blade
-
You'll have to forgive me if I ask silly, unambiguous or allready answered questions, because I'm new here. Lets start with these:
- When should one choose a serrated blade over a straight blade? I know I use it for bread, but let's think about an utility knife. If you have both into your SAK or Multitool, when you choose one over the other?
- Which SAK ever built has the more blades? I mean real knife cutting blades
- Whould it be possible to combine 6 or more full length blades in a Swiss Army Knife? I have no mod talent or tools, but I would like to have a 110-120mm knife with:
- A normal drop point blade (might be full or half serrated)
- A piercing and filleting clip point blade (as in Mauser, or Opinel knives)
- A spey point blade for general use (as in Douk Douk knives)
- A sheepsfoot blade for using as an X-Acto knife (might be serrated as in Mike Horn's knife)
- A Wharncliffe or prunning blade
- A long awl like the one the 93mm Vics Use
I wouldn't put screwdrivers and such on a knife like this, but a metal and a wood saw are desirable.
Is there allready such a (usable) knife? I found many "American Old Style" folding knifes with four blades and some modern knifes with interchangeble blades but I would like a Swiss Army quality and style knife with these features.
- Has anybody thought of an X-Acto, Stanley or Olfa holder built in a Swiss Army knife? You could have some fresh blades somewhere into the scales and no need to sharpen.
-
@kkokkolis said:
You'll have to forgive me if I ask silly, unambiguous or allready answered questions, because I'm new here. Lets start with these:- When should one choose a serrated blade over a straight blade? I know I use it for bread, but let's think about an utility knife. If you have both into your SAK or Multitool, when you choose one over the other?
- Which SAK ever built has the more blades? I mean real knife cutting blades
- Whould it be possible to combine 6 or more full length blades in a Swiss Army Knife? I have no mod talent or tools, but I would like to have a 110-120mm knife with:
- A normal drop point blade (might be full or half serrated)
- A piercing and filleting clip point blade (as in Mauser, or Opinel knives)
- A spey point blade for general use (as in Douk Douk knives)
- A sheepsfoot blade for using as an X-Acto knife (might be serrated as in Mike Horn's knife)
- A Wharncliffe or prunning blade
- A long awl like the one the 93mm Vics Use
I wouldn't put screwdrivers and such on a knife like this, but a metal and a wood saw are desirable.
Is there allready such a (usable) knife? I found many "American Old Style" folding knifes with four blades and some modern knifes with interchangeble blades but I would like a Swiss Army quality and style knife with these features.
- Has anybody thought of an X-Acto, Stanley or Olfa holder built in a Swiss Army knife? You could have some fresh blades somewhere into the scales and no need to sharpen.
-
Serrated blades are best for fibrous materials such as cord, rope, cloth, canvas, and cardboard. They also work well on bread, yes, but also on other, softer things like tomatoes. Plain edge blades are best for most all other general cutting tasks.
-
The Vic Work Champ XL.
-
Yes, we have some talented modders here who do great work. To get such a beast, you'd have quite a layout in donor tools to get some of the necessary blades. The Work Champ XL has the regular large drop point blade, but it also has a clip point blade, and a long and curved 'rescue' serrated blade that's used on both the Rescue Tool and the Fireman. The pruning blade can be had from other SAK models, but I don't know if the one from the Alox models would fit into a 111 mm frame. The other blades I'm not so sure about though, you'd probably have to have them custom made for such a tool.
-
Thank you. I considered the Workchamp but it is huge and heavy. I would throw away the equestrian tool, scissors, pliers, corkscrew, openers and screwdrivers etc (I allready have those on my EDCs Swisschamp and XLT) and I would keep the blades, awls and Marlin Spike (I sense it could be useful for sewing things on canvas and leather).
On the other hand, I see many people on EDC forums carry a separate folding knife (like a SOG, Buck, Gerber etc) together with the SAK or Multitool. I do the same thing now, I carry a Spearpoint ballisong (I think it is not vey legal though) or a traditional Clip-point with wooden handle (that also looks like a weapon). I would like to exchange them with something that looks more like a tool, as SAKs do. The only other well known knife that passes for a tool and has a clip-point (some models are also half serrated) is the Opinel knife. That might suit as an additional utility blade besides my Swisschamp, without the hassle of an overweight second SAK to carry. I need to learn a lot about modifications before I try to build my own.
But a Multiblade from Victorinox or Wenger would be a great hit. After all it is a knife centered tool, isn't it? -
Yes, a SAK is definitely a knife based tool. I have a number of nice folding knives, but I don't find I have a need to EDC any of them. When I do, it's typically my Endura 4. I've also had a number of smaller folders as well, including some very nice ones, like my Dragonfly 2. But, I found that for my needs, a SAK handles 99% of the cutting chores I come across on a day to day basis, and also gives me a lot more functionality in the same package. So, the only time I carry a dedicated folder anymore is when I think I'm going to need one, and that's usually only when I go hiking, camping, etc. Most of my dedicated folders live permanently in various bags and packs that I use, so they're always there when I need them for a certain activity.
As for the Work Champ, the XL is a beast... much to large for EDC IMHO. I have a regular Work Champ though, and it's my favorite SAK, even though I don't use it as often as other SAKs I have. Still, I carry it in my EDC bag, because I feel that it's the most capable and useful SAK I have. I also carry my Compact in a holster on the strap of my bag, for easy access, so the Work Champ comes out only when the Compact won't meet the need at hand. The only other SAK I've got that I think is as good as my Work Champ for the 'who knows what I might need' role is my CyberTool 41.
One thing you might consider is talking to one of our modders here about what you want. I've had TattooSteve do a couple for me so far, and they've been great; he really does fantastic work. You could get a Work Champ XL and have him pare it down so it would only have the tools you really want in it. That way you could get the three different full size blades it has, and any of the other tools it has that you'd want to keep. It'd be smaller and lighter that way, and be designed specifically for your needs. You'd also have a bunch of left over parts so you could have another SAK made to fill some kind of specialized role or need.
-
I'll think about it and try to learn more before I do anything. For the time beeing I got an Opinel Outdoor that suits me and it is very lightweigt for EDC. With this I get a locking clip-point and serrations to save my XLTs blade from dirty work. I also got a shackle key and a whistle other Vics have. Nothing is duplicated (as is the case with 111mm and 91mm SAKs) and it costs 22 euros. If it brakes I'll get another one.
I'll try to make up my mind about the needed blades, learn to disassemble and reassemble a Victorinox (I might use my older Swisschamp for this) and then find some spare parts.
But I insist, Victorinox or Wenger should offer that. It is simple and it would sell a lot. One could have such a folder to complement his Multitool, his outdoor dedicated gear or as a standalone knife. -
If you pair a Swisstool with a Solo, Settler or Mauser for instance, you got plenty of blades to choose from.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login