Anyone edc a 108mm?
-
I'm looking forward to the results mate

-
And here it is. My battery died at the repeated GAK test but I gave up on it shortly after the battery died anyways. The 108mm saws were again the worst. Getting stuck, not clearing the sawdust and getting clogged up, ... the Mil Tec with pliers was even worse than my GAK, I can see now what troubles 50ft-trad had with that saw. I'll do the whole write-up later but for now, here's the video:
-
We can't watch it mate - it's set to private ;)
Also the struggles I had was with the Vic saw (Safari Trooper to be precise), I never tried the Mil-Tec

-
Uuups, how about now?
-
Great video, informative and interesting. Also, I'm not a tree hugger by any means but that poor tree :ahhh :D
-
@stealth007s said:
Great video, informative and interesting. Also, I'm not a tree hugger by any means but that poor tree :ahhh :DYea, but the crowd demanded it. It gave its life for "science"?!
It's a hazel tree and there grow fast and in abundance here. I used to make bows out of it when I was a kid 
-
So in short, if I'm going into the woods, I'm not taking a 108mm. At least not for the saw. It sucks to say the least. If you compare the cutting action of the other saws you can see them clearing sawdust from them, it flies around very visibly. The 108mm saws just clogged up. I had to dig out some of it out once i got home with an utility knife. The main difference between the 108 and all the other saws was its thickness and one directional teeth. The thickness is almost twice as wide as the other used saws, with the exception of the Spirit (and that one performed ok). I was very pleasantly surprised by the Leatherman Juice saw. Really a great cutter. The winners of this test?
I'd say the 111mm Outrider and the 91/93mm Ranger/Farmer. The 91/93mm use the same saw so the choice is weight vrs tool selection. And the added grip of the extra layers of the Ranger. I prefer the Ranger for the tool selection and doing great in both green and dry wood tests. All the other saws (with the exception of the 108mm) did good. Even the small 85mm Wenger did a lot better then some bigger fellows. You would be good taking any of them into the woods for simpler work. Just don't take the 108mm. :ahhh My forest setup still remains folding saw + Mora Clipper but the added features of the Vic Ranger make it a great tool to take into the woods. 
-
Cheers Nikola

That 108mm design really is bad ::) Looks like Victorinox managed to get it working better than Mil-Tec, but not by much. I'd certainly agree that pretty much any other Vic or Wenger would be a better choice as a wood saw
My favourite folding saws are the Bahco Laplander and Opinel 120, but I'd rather take any of my other SAK's or MT's into an outdoors environment than a 108mm VicI'm sure I'll be letting my Safari Trooper and Pathfinder go now as a result of this confirmation

-
Some great tests!
Looks like I need to update the wiki and try to link to this thread.

-
Those GAK saws really don't do very well do they. :-\ Cheers for taking the time mate.

-
Thanks for burning out your biceps for us mate

-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Thanks for burning out your biceps for us mate
No problem ;) I needed a work out anyways
And the surroundings was much better than the original tests on dry wood in the workshop in the middle of the summer.
It was nice to get some forest time finally. It's only a 10 minute walk from my house and I spent a lot of time in there as a child but it changed a lot in the last few years. Some of it is owned by the state but most is owned by locals and with the prices of heating going up as they are lately, people are going back to wood furnaces so quite a few trees that I used to use for orientation are no longer there. I went in pretty deep in cause I wanted to get away from the noise of a tractor mowing down the grass around the power lines but I think you still can hear some of it in the background. (I think that was the first time they did it in a decade, so I chose the "right" day to go out filming). Funny thing is the tree I was doing the test on had a long piece of wire wrapped around the bottom of it. I think someone had a trap set up there. :serverloft: poachers. 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login