Pocket friendly MT
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I think tool-for-tool, the closest comparable to the Juice S2 is the Victorinox Deluxe Tinker. They are virtually identical in weight.The victorinox scissors are better than the Juice scissors, but the S2's scissors are perfectly serviceable.
Can Opener on the victorinox is better. The Juice's is not great out of the box, but a little file work makes it work fine. I mentioned these two functions first because the Juice S2 can opener is in the way of the scissors, adding an extra step to getting to the scissors... something I found a constant annoyance.For screw drivers... the flatheads on both are good and useful.
The Phillips on the S2 is considerably better placed and more robust than the Victorinox. I nearly tore a Tinker apart overtoquing a phillips screw, and the amount of force it took was surprisingly little, whereas I had no problem removing a woodscrew from wood with the Leatherman. The S2 has 3 flatheads. The Vic has 2 if you count the one on the can opener.The flathead/cap lifter on the Vic makes a better pry tool than anything on the S2.
The blade on the S2 is fine. The Vic has 2 blades. So, if you like the idea of a back-up blade, that'd be the way to go.
Of course, the S2 has no answer to the Vic's awl. Or the parsel hook. Or the tweezers and toothpick.
Here's the real thing, though. The pliers. The pliers on the S2 are MILES better than those on the Vic. The REAL question is how much do you need pliers. If they're a high priority, then I'd say get the S2. If you can get by with lighter pliers, the Deluxe Tinker wins out clearly. In my opinion.
The truth of it for me is that I have only ever needed light pliers. I think a squirt PS4 can handle all my needs, and is more pocketable than a Victorinox Deluxe Tinker. But you may prefer the larger scissors, blade, etc, on the Tinker. So... I personally think it all comes down to how much you need pliers, and how heavy-duty those need to be. Then, how much capability you want in the other tools. If pliers are high priority, stick with the S2. If not, either drop to the Squirt size, or go with the Vic, for more capability.
I certainly don't think you'll be disappointed with a Juice S2 OR Deluxe Tinker.
Yup... what she said...

I'll only add that I personally don't think of the Vic pliers as "pliers" per se. Rather, I think of them as heavy duty forceps or hemostats... I bicycle a lot and have yet to find anything better than Vic pliers for digging stuff out of my tire treads when fixing a flat. I use them to make impromptu pokey/scrapey/hooky tools a lot out of paperclips and scrap pieces of wire, etc. As with digging stuff out of my bike tires, there's no better MT pliers for such work IMHO than the Vic pliers.
-
Yep,what they all said!
If your pliers are very important than the S2 will be hard to beat.I'd take a look at a Sideclip or a Gerber Octane as well,and stick a Vic Rambler or Manager on my keyring.
If the pliers arnt a deal breaker,Lynn is right,the Delux Tinker is an awesome SAK
-
I've got to say, the best pocket carry has got to be the Gerber Balance. If you haven't had one in your pocket, you are really missing out. It beats all the others for sliding in and out of a pocket or just carrying it all day.
Don't skip over it so easily...
Def
-
A quick check on weight looks like the Balance is 7.4 oz (210g)??? That might be an issue.
-
@kirk13 said:
I'd take a look at a Sideclip or a Gerber Octane as well,and stick a Vic Rambler or Manager on my keyring.That's what I tend to do, with an Executive replacing the Rambler or Manager.
I do have a Balance coming at some point, but it's on backorder. :( As for the Deluxe Tinker vs. Juice, 50ft-trad (Al) did an excellent comparison, which resulted in me getting my Deluxe.
Vic Deluxe Tinker vs LM Juice CS4
I originally posted this review on another forum a couple of months ago, but since joining I thought I'd offer it up to you guys for scrutiny/feedback too Vi...
Multitool.Org Forum (multitool.ninja)
If you decide to go the SAK route, I'd also say take a look at the Wenger Tradesman if you can find one. Same toolset as the Deluxe Tinker, but in the 85mm form. One of my absolute favorite SAKs..... Of course, another option is the time-honored MT.O way - Get them all and figure it out later! :D
-
I believe the best thing you could do would be to start by thinking about what tools you'll be using the most, and if "pocketable" means slim or light or both. If weight is not a primary concern (e.g., you'll be carrying the tool in a wallet or other), imho nothing beats the Spirit on the tools-for-size chart. It's a bit longer than other 4in tools, but it's among the slimmest you can get. On the tools front, I'm also all for pocketable and compact tools, but I use the pliers, blade, scissors, and phillips driver almost daily, so SAKs are out of the question. Moreover, unless you have legal issues with locking implements, I'd steer clear of the Juice line as well as I had implements fold down on me on several occasions.
-
Any of the Wenger SAKs with an "18" after its name(Evogrip 18, Evowood 18, etc.) can fill that void.

-
Apart from the S2, if you need good pliers see the wenger minigrip, maybe the PST, some of the CRKT offerings etc. It depends on what tools you want, though the S2 is in a leaque of its own..
-
If printing (the outline of the tool being visible through the fabric of your pants) is an issue then the Juice is very hard to beat. The oval shape minimizes printing more than any other pliers based MT I've tried.
I've been EDC'ing Juice models for more than 10 years. Every year or so I spend some time looking at all of the alternatives and I have yet to find another MT that is as pocket friendly as a Juice. The Gerber balance caught my eye, but it is longer, considerably heavier and has a more boxy profile compared to the S2.
-
/topic/25232
That was a good review. Thanks for all the replys. Just when I think I have my mind made up, someone gives me cause to think. If Victorinox made something like a mini X I would have no decision to make.
-
How about a good old PST or PST II? They are much slimmer than most modern MT's and drop in a pocket very well. :)
-
@Gareth said:
How about a good old PST or PST II? They are much slimmer than most modern MT's and drop in a pocket very well. :)True, but they're kinda long, and after carrying both (replaced my original Leatherman Tool with a PST-II) for ten years or so, the ends of them both caused significant wear in my jeans. As MeadMaker said, the Juice's oval shape is definitely more pocket-friendly, if you're not gonna clip it or carry in in a pocket sheath or the like.
(Semi-related tale: I had my original Leatherman Tool — they weren't even called PST then — in my pocket the second time my motorcycle and I went down. Lemme tell ya, that LM left a deep bruise in my thigh that took weeks to go away. :-[ )
-
How about a good old PST or PST II? They are much slimmer than most modern MT's and drop in a pocket very well. :)
True, but they're kinda long, and after carrying both (replaced my original Leatherman Tool with a PST-II) for ten years or so, the ends of them both caused significant wear in my jeans. As MeadMaker said, the Juice's oval shape is definitely more pocket-friendly, if you're not gonna clip it or carry in in a pocket sheath or the like.
(Semi-related tale: I had my original Leatherman Tool — they weren't even called PST then — in my pocket the second time my motorcycle and I went down.** Lemme tell ya, that LM left a deep bruise in my thigh that took weeks to go away.** :-[ )
Ouch! :-\
All fair points TBH, they are kinda long for some people's taste and do potentially add to pocket wear. I've just re-read this thread and noticed that no-one has mentioned either the LM Wingman or Sidekick. I cannot personally recommend them as I've not tried them, but they do have their fans (and quite a few detractors ;)).
-
@Gareth said:
I've just re-read this thread and noticed that no-one has mentioned either the LM Wingman or Sidekick. I cannot personally recommend them as I've not tried them, but they do have their fans (and quite a few detractors ;)).I actually like my Wingman (no really!). But I thought the OP was inquiring about carrying in a pocket, not clipping to a pocket. In the latter case, yeah, those two would be a good choice, carrying just as easily as a folding knife.
-
Thanks for all the replys. I messed around with a Juice S2 today and it was pretty sweet so I ended up ordering one. The fit and finish on it was very nice and it seemed well constructed. Not too big in my jeans pocket either.
-
Congratulations on the S2. If you want to make it even more comfortable in your pocket pick up a Tec P-7 suspension clip and use it to hang the S2 at the pack of your front pocket. You wont even know it is there.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login