Gerber Video
-
-
But if you watch the video it actually shows them stamping out blade blanks and the guy doesn't look Chinese lol even Victorinox doesn't use Swiss steel it's imported
-
@Gareth said:
Yeah, still stuff made in the US. However they gloss over the fact that plenty of their product are made overseas. That kind of misleading advertising never does a company much credit IMO. :-\You have obviously never seen a Taylor Brands catalogue then. Stars and stripes and eagles all over it, and nothing made anywhere near the US. It made me sick and I'm not even an American.
Def
-
I could be wrong, but of the bladesteels Ive worked with, including the chinese mystery steel, that's what it felt like to me. It would seem pretty odd then to buy the steel overseas and stamp it out in the US.. so it could jsut be a low grade standard steel. I havent worked with them all, just blade steels and 304/316 stainless.
Normally if they use a known north american standard steel, its listed as part of the tool specs. I work with 440c the most so I know how it feels (by feels I mean to machine it, grind it, sand it, polish it). When I try similar processes on known chinese mystery steel its a very different feel to work it.
Vic uses German steel as far as I remember? I remember looking at the closest north american standard steel to their spring steel and it was 440A. I went with 440C as the closest available, but slightly higher grade.
-
Well I was wrong then I think. Google tells me that the MP600 uses 420HC and ATS-34 steels.
-
I think they use a range of steels , according to the box my fixed blade Prodigy is sandvik 12c27
-
I work with steels from all over the world, and it's either decent stuff or it's not. I've experienced some horrendous steels from developing countries, but horrendous steel from first world countries too. I've also encountered very good consistent materials from across the globe too.
Steel is generally either made well, or made cheaply - geography may increase the odds of finding yourself at one end of the spectrum or the other, but isn't the be all and end all. Some of the worse steels have been from mills which are new to producing a particular alloy, and they just haven't got in tune with the nuances of that particular grade yet. Chemically it may be fine, and the test piece may have met all the mechanical values (though you never know how many retreatment cycles were needed to ensure that), but is it homogenous enough, without inclusions or other defects? All the test cert will tell you is what the ingredients are, what the initial (or final) treatment cycle was, and that a small piece they cut off a very large lump/batch had certain mechanical traits. Tha 12C27 is a good steel not just because Sandvik are a good conscientious supplier, but they've been producing the same grade for a long time and know how to make sure they get it right efficiently without rework and minimal rejection. Give them a new grade to produce, and they'll not be as good as someone whose been reeling it off for the last decade or so until they've had a good runs production runs
Don't ignore the importance of the subsequent heat treatment either - that can make a good steel great, or a great steel very poor indeed
-
@50ft-trad said:
Don't ignore the importance of the subsequent heat treatment either - that can make a good steel great, or a great steel very poor indeedIve heard that from a few bladesmiths. They were saying they make good blades out of 440c even though it has mostly been written off as out of fashion. But that the heat treating technologies, like cryo, allow for way better blades of the of same old steel then they were getting 20 yrs ago. Smaller crystal domains etc, which does make sense.
-
the lady at the beginning of the video looks oriental, so maybe there is a hint there..... :DThe only Chinese 440C I have is on some Navy knives and tools, but to me it feels the same as other 440C steels i.e. GEC, though not polished... Maybe if they were both polished they will feel different. All decent steels seem to be OK for my needs, anyway. As far as I know the Chinese versions are the same (if heat treated ok) as the branded ones, though they are more "equivalent" than identical.
50ft beat me to it....

-
I like the one with Trigger Cook the boat builder
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login