Multitool.org in 2013?
-
I think this place is fine just like it is. The only thing I would change is to have more Swiss MODS >:D
-
-
@50ft-trad said:
I've not really come up with any suggestions, because quite frankly I think you guys have all got it just about spot on. I don't really think there's anything "missing", nor is there anything particularly superfluous. OK, the main site and SAKnights might need a metaphorical flick over with a duster as mentioned before ... as could the Encyclopedia. In fact the Encyclopedia may benefit from emulating SAKWiki a little more ... it just doesn't feel as "accessible" as SAKwiki somehow
... but overall I think you've all got it right. Thanks once again for doing a great job guys 
@sawman said:
I think this place is fine just like it is. The only thing I would change is to have more Swiss MODS >:DWhat you guys are looking at is content and that's something I can help very little with. SAKnights aside (which is really beyond the scope of this thread- let's focus on MTO!) the Encyclopedia is user editable- if no users are editing and updating it then it doesn't get edited or updated. This site isn't The Def Show, it's a community. I imagine when Bob gets a few things off his plate he'll add to it, but there are several thousand other members here....

Ditto for SAK mods. I'm not much of a modder and so I really can't post a lot of mod stuff. You want more SAK mods, send a pile of parts to Syph007, Metro or one of the other guys and tell them to have at it!
Def
-
As I understand it (correct me if I'm wrong) the content is here for the main site, and bodies have been allocated to deal with the tweaks (on MTo and SAKnights) which will be done when real world permits ... I wasn't really nudging in that direction as I'm sure those things will happen in due course :)
As for my comment on the encyclopedia, it was more of a structure thing. Sakwiki has quite a user friendly format, moreso than the encyclopedia in my opinion which to me doesn't have as intuitive or appealing a structure ... and that is beyond the community. Just a hunch, but I'd imagine SAKwiki has significantly more traffic, and I'd like to think the Encyclopedia could mirror that. Yes, content is important but for "stray" visitors (i.e. not us members), that content has to be both accessible and ... well, fun to use. I don't think the format is at it's optimum is all.
Sorry if my earlier comments weren't clear :)
-
I hate to say it Al, but you are still wrong... at least in a way.
The Multitool Encyclopedia was built at the same time as SAKWiki from the same software and by the same guys. If SAKWiki is easier to handle it's because users made it that way. Anyone who wants can not only control content but also modify the way the Wiki works, making it easier for anyone else coming along afterwards.
There has also been some talk about merging the two.
Def
-
The only problem is I can't find the Register button on it. :)
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I hate to say it Al, but you are still wrong... at least in a way.The Multitool Encyclopedia was built at the same time as SAKWiki from the same software and by the same guys. If SAKWiki is easier to handle it's because users made it that way. Anyone who wants can not only control content but also modify the way the Wiki works, making it easier for anyone else coming along afterwards.
There has also been some talk about merging the two.
Def
I had no idea the wiki platforms are user formatable
Neither did I know that these opinions were capable of being right or wrong :P If you don't want the answer, don't ask the bloody question
:DI think there's easily enough info, and sufficiently diverse info to keep the two separate but that's funds and manpower resources .... which is entirely your call

As for the forum itself, like I said before - I think you've pretty much got it nailed

-
@enki_ck said:
The only problem is I can't find the Register button on it. :)I stand corrected... or I would if Al hadn't pointed out that there's no right or wrong here! :D Thanks Al, I owe you one!
The registration link was suspended for a while for a spam issue- I don't know if it was solved or not, but we'll have to look at having it reinstated. Meanwhile, anyone who wants access can send me, Bob or Whoey a PM and we'll set you up.
Also, basic users of the Wiki cannot edit the format or template of the Wiki, but we do give admin rights to anyone who asks for them so if you want to get in there and do some serious good, that can be easily arranged.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
The only problem is I can't find the Register button on it. :)
I stand corrected... or I would if Al hadn't pointed out that there's no right or wrong here! :D Thanks Al, I owe you one!
The registration link was suspended for a while for a spam issue- I don't know if it was solved or not, but we'll have to look at having it reinstated. Meanwhile, anyone who wants access can send me, Bob or Whoey a PM and we'll set you up.
Also, basic users of the Wiki cannot edit the format or template of the Wiki, but we do give admin rights to anyone who asks for them so if you want to get in there and do some serious good, that can be easily arranged.
Def
:D Anytime mate
:P -
I'm going to upgrade the wikis, they're both overdue, migrating from old LTS version to new LTS... hopefully not too much breaks as they have huge databases... and hope it has better spam signup prevention...
-
Something I've thought about is the inability to edit old posts, that's something I'm used to being able to do from other forums.
I can see why you'd want to keep the forums in a.. hmm.. constant state? And not having posts being edited years after they were first posted, but still.. I find it odd and a bit limiting when I notice a typo or something in one of my older posts. :P
-
...
so how about a spelling checker function?Is it possible?
-
@dks said:
...
so how about a spelling checker function?Is it possible?
Well that's built in in most modern browsers to be honest. :)
It's not just that though.. you might've posted something you end up regretting later on, personal information, drunk ramblings.. stuff like that. (Not that I'd ever post while drinking...
) -
@Northern Geek said:
Something I've thought about is the inability to edit old posts, that's something I'm used to being able to do from other forums.I can see why you'd want to keep the forums in a.. hmm.. constant state? And not having posts being edited years after they were first posted, but still.. I find it odd and a bit limiting when I notice a typo or something in one of my older posts. :P
This was to prevent malicious editing after posting... it happened, thus the lock down to maintain the knowledge base.
-
@Northern Geek said:
It's not just that though.. you might've posted something you end up regretting later on, personal information, drunk ramblings.. stuff like that. (Not that I'd ever post while drinking...
)If needed you can always contact a moderator to help out... we have had that scenario too...
-
@Northern Geek said:
Something I've thought about is the inability to edit old posts, that's something I'm used to being able to do from other forums.
I can see why you'd want to keep the forums in a.. hmm.. constant state? And not having posts being edited years after they were first posted, but still.. I find it odd and a bit limiting when I notice a typo or something in one of my older posts. :P
This was to prevent malicious editing after posting... it happened, thus the lock down to maintain the knowledge base.
Yeah.. I can see why you'd want to keep it this way.. I just prefer a more open system, but fair enough.

-
Yep, I've had to edit many posts within a few minutes because I am dyslexic and sometimes type utter nonsense. The old ones I didn't get to fast enough still stand! ::)
Over all this system works very well for a forum this size, and we are always happy to edit for you (then I can leave a bunch of misspelled rubbish in your posts too :D

-
I'm running Ubuntu, which has a built-in spell checker. The problem is, regardless of what I tell it, it believes I'm using British English, instead of American English. You brits sure do mangle MY language.

'Colour'
'Flavour'
'Parkour'...
As to the edit-old-post thing. I agree that things should be locked down after a very short time (to check for spelling/fact errors, and the like), as this board does.

-
I also hate not being able to edit my post. I've ask many times and always get told the same so I let it die. If I make a screw up as sometimes my fingers go fast then my brain or vise versa I just say oops and let it go. I've been a screw up a lot in life so why change now. :D BTW I will admit openly that my spelling sometimes sucks! I've been ask a lot "didn't you go to college" my reply is always the same "not for spelling or language".
Ash's mobile on the move.
-
Ash you can edit posts, but only for a short time. Gives you a chance to correct something if you check it quick enough.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login