Best SAK Ever!!!
-
@micky d said:
Yep the inline is far better, until it closes on your fingers :oI've never had that happen, but I have had the backspring one close on me.
Have you tried the newer phillips that comes with the new design magnifier? The backspring engages a slot in the back of the driver, and works as a passive "lock" that keeps it snapped open pretty tightly.
-
@micky d said:
The saw on the Spirit does indeed lock open, but I've never had a Farmer saw blade fold on me, so I think it's a moot point, regarding the lock (or lack there off), the greater length of the Farmer however is hard to argue with :)
I'm not arguing with it.
Since you own both, perhaps you could enlighten me as to the difference in length?
Personally, I'd prefer to have a slightly shorter locking saw to a slightly longer saw that didn't lock.
.
There's not much in it, (just ran up stairs to check :D) maybe 5-6 mm, I've got to admit to being suprised at that as it feels longer

-
@micky d said:
Yep the inline is far better, until it closes on your fingers :o
I've never had that happen, but I have had the backspring one close on me.
Have you tried the newer phillips that comes with the new design magnifier? The backspring engages a slot in the back of the driver, and works as a passive "lock" that keeps it snapped open pretty tightly.
Nope, not tried the newer design yet :), good to see that Vic are still tweaking the design though :)
-
I agree, the inline one is far better. :) I just wish it didn't have to come on the same layer as a magnifyer. :(
...or that crappy LED.
I find uses for the magnifier, but most of the time I just put up with it as a consequence of needing the phillips. :)
Ever come across any mods that don't have either of these?
No, but it certainly would be worth looking into, wouldn't it? It might be difficult to find another tool that would fit in there due to the width of that layer. An electrician's blade (sheepsfoot) would be great, but it's too narrow and would have to be spaced out.
-
Where's Bill when you need him. :D A robertson would be cool.
-
@NutSAK said:
You should try a model with the in-line phillips driver if you haven't. It's the best of both worlds. It fits more heads, gets into tight areas, and has great reach.I've been tempted to try one, but they mostly come in the fatter SAKs that are too thick for EDC for me. Two layer SAKs are the limit for me for pocket carry, which is why I love the Tinker so much.
Plus, I've heard that the in-line Phillips doesn't grip screws even as well as the backspring Phillips, because the driver head is machined differently.
@NutSAK said:
I've buggered-up many more phillips screws with that over-polished backspring phillips than anything else. Out of the 60 SAKs I own, I now only have one that has the backspring phillips, and that's just because I can't find a SAK that has the same implements as a Deluxe Tinker w/a corkscrew instead of the phillips.I've had pretty good luck with the backspring Phillips over the many years I've carried a Tinker.
It's saved the day many times out in the field, allowing me to open cases to change out batteries, disassemble external pack frames, stoves, etc.
.
-
-
Where's Bill when you need him. :D A robertson would be cool.
That would be a great idea. It's a shame that robertson screws haven't reached the popularity in the US as they appear to have in the UK and Europe. Torx are quite common, but I rarely see robertson here.
They are not all that common here actually. I do have a few in my car though.
A T-20 torx would be great to have.
-
You should try a model with the in-line phillips driver if you haven't. It's the best of both worlds. It fits more heads, gets into tight areas, and has great reach.
I've been tempted to try one, but they mostly come in the fatter SAKs that are too thick for EDC for me. Two layer SAKs are the limit for me for pocket carry, which is why I love the Tinker so much.
Plus, I've heard that the in-line Phillips doesn't grip screws even as well as the backspring Phillips, because the driver head is machined differently.
That's a good point--the inline phillips will always add another layer, and thus more width to the knife.
My experience with the grip on screws is totally opposite to what you've heard. The in-line driver fits more sizes of screws and the grip is much better.
-
You should try a model with the in-line phillips driver if you haven't. It's the best of both worlds. It fits more heads, gets into tight areas, and has great reach.
I've been tempted to try one, but they mostly come in the fatter SAKs that are too thick for EDC for me. Two layer SAKs are the limit for me for pocket carry, which is why I love the Tinker so much.
Plus, I've heard that the in-line Phillips doesn't grip screws even as well as the backspring Phillips, because the driver head is machined differently.
That's a good point--the inline phillips will always add another layer, and thus more width to the knife.
My experience with the grip on screws is totally opposite to what you've heard. The in-line driver fits more sizes of screws and the grip is much better.
Well, maybe I should try one. I just recall people on various forums complaining that they don't grip that well.
Isn't there a two-layer SAK with an inline Phillips? Lumberjack maybe?
.
-
The Scientist is the only two-layer model I know of with the inline phillips. Sadly, it was discontinued years ago. Similarly, the Yeoman was the only three layer that I'm aware of, and it was discontinued.
You'd need to turn to Scibeer for something like that these days. Or, buy a four layer Explorer.
Hell, if the backspring phillips works that well for you, stick to it.
-
I've got an Explorer (thanks Calvin) and it's a great model, it's certainly doesn't feel too bulky for edc :)
-
@micky d said:
@micky d said:
The saw on the Spirit does indeed lock open, but I've never had a Farmer saw blade fold on me, so I think it's a moot point, regarding the lock (or lack there off), the greater length of the Farmer however is hard to argue with :)
I'm not arguing with it.
Since you own both, perhaps you could enlighten me as to the difference in length?
Personally, I'd prefer to have a slightly shorter locking saw to a slightly longer saw that didn't lock.
.
There's not much in it, (just ran up stairs to check :D) maybe 5-6 mm, I've got to admit to being suprised at that as it feels longer

I'd gladly give up 5mm = 0.2" of saw blade to gain a secure lock!
I've had saw blades fold on my hand on a few occasions and it's something I'd prefer to avoid in the future!
.
-
Yeah it would sting a bit :D
But it's honestly not a problem on the farmer as it has a very sturdy back spring :)
-
@micky d said:
Yeah it would sting a bit :DBut it's honestly not a problem on the farmer as it has a very sturdy back spring :)
I've nearly always had a SAK with a saw, starting with a Camper 25 years ago. I've used the saw hundreds of times, and I've never had it fold up. That Camper doesn't have near the backspring that a Farmer has either.
The saw on the 111mm models is really sweet. The angle of it makes it nearly impossible to fold up in use also.
-
@NutSAK said:
The Scientist is the only two-layer model I know of with the inline phillips. Sadly, it was discontinued years ago. Similarly, the Yeoman was the only three layer that I'm aware of, and it was discontinued.You'd need to turn to Scibeer for something like that these days. Or, buy a four layer Explorer.
Hell, if the backspring phillips works that well for you, stick to it.
I'm pretty happy with the Tinker after 25+ years of EDC.
Although I've experimented with other SAKs over the years, none of them ever replacded the Tinker as my EDC.
It'd have to be a custom model, but it's hard for me to visualize any two-layer SAK better than a Tinker.
Maybe a custom three-layer alox SAK, with:
-big blade and small blade
-can opener and bottle opener
-inline Phillips and awlIf a three-layer alox custom SAK was the same thickness as the two-layer Tinker, then maybe I'd be tempted to change my EDC.
.
-
The problem is though, the inline phillips comes on the magnifyer layer.
-
Due to the thickness of the phillips, I would think not. :-\
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login