Multitool.org in 2013?
-
@Xelkos said:
Oh, no worries. Was a stupid idea in the whole.

Though there are lots of posts where I wished could give a kudo. You want to say "I agree" but don't want to post every where that you "agree" or like what was said. A kudo or a 'pat on the back' sometimes is a good thing.
Nobody said that, Xeikos. Maybe my idea is stupid instead. :D
You can allways PM someone if you want to tell them something without posting anyway.
Oh, when replying to AHB I told myself this was a stupid idea. Only one's intentions are perfect.
See many posts here that just want to agree with, but not post. But we don't want another facebook infestation. Was trying to be proactive. ;)
Am sticking to the tablet browser thing. Small set-sized graphical buttons would keep the text numbers from resizing. Can I go back and scribble out the kudos & bones suggestions?

-
That option is actually built into the forum software- it's called Karma and quite honestly when we tried it people took it far too seriously. People actually got upset when someone would give them a "smite" and want to track down who gave it to them and give one back. People also got very upset when a respected member like Bob (J-Sews) got a smite and all but formed a posse to hunt whoever it was down and defend Bob's honor, despite the fact that he had hundreds of positives.... whatever those were called.
It reminded me of eBay feedback. Everyone wants five stars and to maintain 99% and above feedback, and sellers feel awkward dealing with someone who only has 96% positive feedback. ::)
Soon the whole thing becomes about people trying to please people and not be themselves. That might work in other places, but not so much here.
Def
-
Thanks for the explanation. Can see your point all too well, reminds me of another place or three.
If I had the power, would of stricken my suggestions and commentary - or striked it through. :_c:No wonder this forum has lasted so long, has great leadership!

-
Thanks for the vote of confidence! :D
One thing I'd like to point out, and while your post is a perfect example, this is by no means directed at you or anyone else, just a general comment.
@Xelkos said:
If I had the power, would of stricken my suggestions and commentary - or striked it through. :_c:I don't believe in deleting (or editing) comments unless they are particularly offensive, and even then, only in really necessary cases. Yes, sometimes we all say things that were either misspelled, misconstrued or posted when under the influence of something or another. The fact is, these comments and thoughts are just as much who we are as the comments we make normally, and I for one welcome them, even though I've been known to post quite a few boners myself!
And this goes double when it comes to posting ideas- we aren't shooting down member ideas to sound important or make anyone feel dumb, embarrassed or otherwise. These ideas are all great, and if I didn't want people offering ideas I wouldn't ask for them- as I was reminded earlier, there's no right and wrong, and if folks feel strongly enough about trying something (like the Karma for example) I'm willing to give it a shot again. How many times have we tried the live chat option for example- three? Four times? Eventually we may try it again- you never know, the right chat solution at the right time could be a success, just like Karma.
The only caveat I have with the Karma points (if there was enough interest to try it again) is that folks would:
a) have to promise not to take it too seriously, and
b) if it fails, promise to harbor no grudges against anyone else.No idea is a bad idea, and no one should feel bad about mentioning ideas- after all, if it wasn't for some guys with stupid ideas we wouldn't have powered flight, be able to harness electricity or allow people to live long, healthy lives with the help of some pig organs. The world revolves on seemingly dumb ideas, and I for one will never penalize someone for sharing them. :D
After all, starting a forum to discuss plier tools was seen as pretty dumb before we started MTO... and we are still putting a lot of effort into attempting to prove them wrong! :D
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Sadly there is a reason for this- we've had issues before where members have gotten upset with the forum for some reason or another and gone back and removed information, photos etc from old posts. In my opinion this is an act of vandalism and hurts the entire community. We discuss tools here that are not represented anywhere else, so when that information is removed because someone has gotten into a hissy fit, well that is a slap in the face of everyone here and anyone who may someday come looking for that info. That's the reason we restrict the editing- to limit the damage any one member can do to the entire site.Besides, with so many members from around the world here I don't think spelling is all that important.
Def
Yeah, I really do understand.
It's probably just a feeling that it's too bad it's necessary because in an ideal world I'd prefer it if people were able to control their posts any way they want to.
But it seems to work pretty well this way as well so I guess it works.

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Thanks for the vote of confidence! :DAfter all, starting a forum to discuss plier tools was seen as pretty dumb before we started MTO... and we are still putting a lot of effort into attempting to prove them wrong! :D
I found this quite interesting, in fact. In my rather confusing conviction of getting my 1st SAK, was online about every night comparing and searching. Seemed about every page (or two) of searches I found this great discussion on the very same subject on Google! Guess where the referral link came from. :D
This site gets noticed!

-
When you are the authority, you are the authority and even Google has to recognize that! :D
Of course it's not hard to be the ultimate authority on a subject that the vast majority of people don't care about... do a search for "collectible toothbrushes" or "outhouse museums" if you don't believe me! >:D
Def
-
I can see the idea behind the karma thing, and I can also see how it could go wrong and become ... awkward. A like/dislike per post would be fairer than per member, but again I'd also hate to see this become a pseudo-facebook site ... it's so much better than that. If I post something that someone likes, dislikes, finds amusing, idiotic, naive or whatever, I'd prefer them to say something. A lot of interesting stuff (tool related and otherwise) comes out here because we actually talk to one another properly rather than just stick to regimented and pre-formatted discussions. It would be a shame if "liking" a post became more convenient and stopped people talking and expressing their thoughts. I suppose there is a kind of "like" function here already anyway ... just quote what was said and do this ....

-

Def
-
The only change request I have is the same from last year, and its not for MTO, but for EDCSource. Please make the thumbnail pics larger, they are too tiny to see what the tool is.
Example: I want to browse Tims awesome offerings. I click in his store to see the list. The thumbnail pics are too small for me to tell what the tool is, so I have to open each listing, defeating the point of having a 'summary' view to help me find what Im after.
It doesn't need to mirror exactly what ebay does, but when I do a search on ebay and get a summary list view, I can tell by the thumbnails what the item is.
That's my biggest gripe, other than that I love MTO!
Edit: Added comparison pic

-
I will talk to Micah and see what can be done about that.
Def
-
If we do edcs too I also have a suggestion/grudge: the search function seldom works for me. It often seems like its notion of similarity boils down to string matching.
-
I'd agree with you if I knew what that meant. I rarely have trouble with the search feature, but that doesn't mean it couldn't be improved.
The real big deal with EDCSource is that I have sunk a fair bit of money into it and it's not going anywhere. Because it's cost a fair bit of money, and because many of the fixes/upgrades we want to do are going to cost more money I'm leery about spending more money on it since the interest in it has been severely disappointing. Before we start looking at new/better components I think we need to see some potential there. I have a few things I am working on that should help but one man can only accomplish so much. If you really want to see EDCSource improved, start using it, start telling other people about it, start posting interesting things you see on Facebook, Google + and Twitter.
Def
-
First of all, I'm pretty convinced any "like button", karma points and so on and so forth always will evolve into metagames that take away energy and focus from the discussions. (Or they are ignored, and are thus wasted effort.) It is a good thing that saying anything takes a tiny amount of effort. Look at the way we handle number of postings as a game in itself already, the difference is that's not much of a problem, because it only makes us talk more. (And the occasional thread with one word, or letter, per post. :D ) To quote https://twitter.com/DEVOPS_BORAT , "Effect of observer in devops: once you are optimize metric, is lose relevance as metric.", that goes for pretty much any human activity where the metric isn't the goal itself.
Second, my request boils down to the forum software. I would like to be able to enter a forum, and then sort all threads with unread postings before those threads where I have already read all postings. Or is it already possible and I haven't noticed it?
Edit: s/involve/evolve/
-
Just a thought... Would it be difficult to make a little currency/unit converter thingy, like, below the 'community links' thingy at the right of the forum? Would be quite practical, I think, for us non-imperial system users :) (and us non-dollar-users)
-
Both Google and Yahoo! search does it as well. Just try "500 USD in EUR" or "60 yd in m". So if you read MT.o in a browser with a search box or something, you already have it integrated.
Ditto
;) -
Yeah, I know, I'm lazy....

-
xe is always about the most up to date one online.
Also, anyone running Win7 can add the desktop widget thing for currency very easily.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login