Next flashlight purchase advice
-
Very interesting info guys. Keep it coming.

Also, I sent PP for a Zebralight SC51 this morning. It's has some scuff marks on the body but it's the inside beuty that counts, right? Damn peer pressure. If I don't like it it's all your fault. >:D
-
@enki_ck said:
Very interesting info guys. Keep it coming.
Also, I sent PP for a Zebralight SC51 this morning. It's has some scuff marks on the body but it's the inside beuty that counts, right? Damn peer pressure. If I don't like it it's all your fault. >:D
Not for me thanks; too big for the Leatherman side pouch, and too small not to lose it on my treks. I'll stick with my Maglite XL200.
-
I just got chastised over at CPF for admitting that I don't check the voltage of my protected AW cells after I take them out of the charger. Heck, I don't even own a multimeter...

But, that's the point of protected cells. Sure, even a protected cell has a chance of failing on you, but I figure it's a pretty astronomically low chance. I still take reasonable precautions with my cells; for my few lights that use multiple cells I keep those cells paired and matched in their rated mah capacity, always charge and use them together, and for all my cells I never let them sit longer on the charger than I have to, and so on. In two years of using AW's I've never had one so much as get warm on me. Heck, one of my old Jetbeams smooshed the top of one of my AW P2600 18650 flat-tops on me, but it hasn't compromised the safety or function of the cell at all. I just put a magnet on the positive terminal to make contact and it still works as well as the day it arrived in the mail.

Millions of people use devices with li-ion cells in them every single day, and I've never seen anyone burst into flames or get their head blown off because of a cell failure. In fact, the ONLY place I've ever heard (read) horror stories about li-ions going all IED is on CPF, and even then, it's always with cheap unprotected cells, and not the high end quality protected ones. Lots of people complain that AW's are overpriced, but I beg to differ. My experience with them so far has shown me that paying the extra for the highest quality protected cells is most certainly a worthwhile investment.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I just got chastised over at CPF for admitting that I don't check the voltage of my protected AW cells after I take them out of the charger.Must just be you, mate. I more or less said the same thing, and no one called me on it ;)
I always check the cells when they're new, to establish a pattern of behavior, but once I trust them, I only check them once in a blue moon.
-
Irrespective of that, get a cheap multimeter.
Unless you are really interested in measuring currents over 1A even the cheap ones from eBay are good and FUN :DI check by 18650 out of habit but I agree the stories on CPF and BLF are usually the extremes (overcharging, combining different cells etc).
Only one of my torches uses more than one 18650, normally, anyway. (I think)
-
I only ever buy lights that use ONE Li-Ion cell, this greatly reduces the chance of catastrophic failure. Besides, I don't like really big lights anyway,
-
@gregozedobe said:
I only ever buy lights that use ONE Li-Ion cell, this greatly reduces the chance of catastrophic failure. Besides, I don't like really big lights anyway,Why is that, if you don't mind me asking? I've heard of it happening, but it does seem extremely rare.
-
I only ever buy lights that use ONE Li-Ion cell, this greatly reduces the chance of catastrophic failure. Besides, I don't like really big lights anyway,
Why is that, if you don't mind me asking? I've heard of it happening, but it does seem extremely rare.
It's because using two cells can lead to charge imbalances between the cells, causing one cell to be pushed past its safety zone for depletion or draw, which can lead to a failure.
That's why I always use matched cells in my lights that use two cells. I match them in rated mah to minimize the chance of an imbalance, and charge them together, and rotate them in the bays of my charger, so I know that differences in the charging circuit between the two bays aren't creating an imbalance in their charge.
But, I only have two lights that use more than one li-ion cell, and that's primarily because they're lights I use in situations where I need the extended run time. In general, I stick with one cell lights simply because they're more convenient to carry and use. The added safety of not having to deal with a charge imbalance is nice, but is minor and not a major reason for me in my preference for single celled lights.
-
I also think that people worry that if one cell gets a lower voltage than the one it is connected to, because they have different capacities and drain at different rates, then the charge may be pushed in that cell the wrong way round and cause problems.
-
It's the multi-cell issue I have read about too - not heard anything about single cell lights blowing up!
Did see a pic of a guy who had his hand badly burnt up when a multi-cell light went bad :o
-
I may have ordered this one too.
Couldn't resist. A 60mm/20mm CR123/RCR123 flashlight with a 2/30/100% output. Sounded too interesting. :ahhhI'll report back when it arrives.

-
Personally, I think Lithium Ion batteries are a mismatch with an LED flashlight. They tend to discharge themselves over time (some, not all) as well as loss of capacity (10-20% per year in some cases). Most LED flashlights have run-times of over several hours, which is sufficient for most applications.
There is also a minor but significant fire risk, using Lithium cells, especially in harsh environments.
An alkaline cell seems much more suitable, as they tend to hold their power over longer periods of time, and have a longer shelf life, up to 10 years in some cases. Also, an alkaline cell is much more available when you need one, unlike a way to charge a rechargeable light when you really need it.
Re-edit: I meant to refer only to <u>rechargeable</u> Lithium Ion, batteries, not the Lithium cells which substitute for alkaline cells. I based my opinions on personal experience and research.
-
Sorry, but most of what you just said isn't true. More the opposite. And you're mixing up Lithium primaries and Lithium rechargeables. As a rule Lithium primaries are SAFER than any alkaline for flashlight use. They have a much longer shelf life, +15 years, and they don't leak. As for Lithium rechargeables, there's no danger in using them in single battery flashlights, the dangers you speak of are only if you use mismatched (maybe even unprotected) Lithium rechargeables with different power levels, when instaid of powering the flashlight, the the stronger battery starts charging the weaker and BOOM. And those cases are due to user error, not the batteries themselves. As for loss of capacity, good quality protected rechargeables like the AW ones have a very low self discharge rate, almost negligible.
-
Here's a table from a 6 month test of rechargeable Lithium ions. It's from the 3 month stage. And quality RCR123A only lost less than 0,5% or their initial charge in 3 months.

-
Also alkalines tend to leak when left for a long time. They are ok if they will be used quickly but not designed to be left for years in a device.(nicknamed alkaleaks..) :D
Eneloops are popular because they keep their charge for long, similar to rechergeable LiIons, do not leak and can provide quite high currents, which are usefull in powerfull LED torches.
Regular NiMh batteries lose their charge quickly; may be usefull after a month, tops.
LiIon primaries last for years, have minimal loss of charge and do not leak, but they are expensive.By the way, most phones, laptops etc use rechargeable LiIons.
I advice people interested in batteries to have a read through the** batteryuniversity ** site. It is probably the best resource for information on batteries on the internet.
Also BLF and CPF have lots of information. -
Yes, I was going to suggest that site dks

Alkalines are dirty little beasts :ahhh
-
yes, I though I posted a link to it but it was in the phone charging thread :D
-
For those of us living in places where we have winter, a pretty important aspect of preferring Lithium batteries is as simple as... getting any power at all. Lithium batteries are some of the least bad when it gets cold.
-
@Steinar said:
For those of us living in places where we have winter, a pretty important aspect of preferring Lithium batteries is as simple as... getting any power at all. Lithium batteries are some of the least bad when it gets cold.True, also Eneloops work good in cold temperatures, down to -20°C as per manufacturer. Anything below that, only Lithiums. :tu: I used to exchange Eneloops for Energizer Lithium primaries each winter before I found that out. Now I do it only if it gets REALLY cold.
-
I guess I should have clarified that my gripe was against rechargeable lithium batteries in an EDC LED light, and I still feel that way. I'm sure that there exists a superbly designed, rechargeable Li-on compact LED flashlight, that will perform dependably for years, but I haven't seen it so far.
I do use the lithium dry cells (such as the Energizer Ultimate Lithium) for long life and cold weather performance in my flashlights.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login