Silverline LM Crunch clone
-
Thanks for posting this! I'll be buying one. :)
I used to have a LM Crunch and sold as needed funds. A vice grip is nice to have though and I'll get one of these for sewing - I struggle to pull the needles through so use full sized vice grips which are a bit cumbersome.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
If anyone has a spare they wouldn't mind parting with, I wouldn't mind giving one of these a shot.Def
Grant, mine is up for grabs mate
I just got it to play with, and I'd decided within about 30 seconds that a Crunch (genuine or otherwise) is never going to be a user for me. -
Thanks for the heads-up. I have just bought 3 (1 for me, 2 for trades/loaners/gifts). Also freight was a bit much for just one (the perrenial addict's excuse).
They were less than GBP 10 when I got to check out (approx GBP 8.50).
-
@50ft-trad said:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
If anyone has a spare they wouldn't mind parting with, I wouldn't mind giving one of these a shot.
Def
Grant, mine is up for grabs mate
I just got it to play with, and I'd decided within about 30 seconds that a Crunch (genuine or otherwise) is never going to be a user for me.Thanks Al, yoodaman!
Def
-
I did exactly the same as 50ft - but bought 3.
One for each car and one for the house
.They were reduced to......£6/7 I think, and that's with postage and sheath thrown in too.
A few weeks later I managed to get the real deal off gumtree (£30 inc' postage).
TBH, as much as I'd love to knock it (yes, I am a tool snob :D). I couldn't really find any major, serious faults, one was a little stiff, but soon loosened up. I don't doubt for a second it's not the same quality as the Crunch. But cynical me does wonder how close it would be. But there's no way I'm gonna push my real Crunch to breaking point just to satisfy my own curiosity.
It's pretty alarming that Engineering machines, Presses, Dies and so forth can be machined and set up, wages paid, raw materials bought, sheath supplied, packaging too, amazons cut and postage thrown in, plus not forgetting a profit for the manufacturer and all for a measly £6/7, they do normally sell for under a tenner tho'!!
-
@tosh said:
It's pretty alarming that Engineering machines, Presses, Dies and so forth can be machined and set up, wages paid, raw materials bought, sheath supplied, packaging too, amazons cut and postage thrown in, plus not forgetting a profit for the manufacturer and all for a measly £6/7, they do normally sell for under a tenner tho'!!Still cheaper than actually investing in the time and creativity and endless prototypes that Leatherman had to do to actually develop this tool from scratch. While I appreciate a bargain too, it is a shame to me when one,s designs simply get copied. Had a company like Silverline taken the concept and changed it, added improvements and features and made it their own tool I'd say fair game.
Tony
-
It's pretty alarming that Engineering machines, Presses, Dies and so forth can be machined and set up, wages paid, raw materials bought, sheath supplied, packaging too, amazons cut and postage thrown in, plus not forgetting a profit for the manufacturer and all for a measly £6/7, they do normally sell for under a tenner tho'!!
Still cheaper than actually investing in the time and creativity and endless prototypes that Leatherman had to do to actually develop this tool from scratch. While I appreciate a bargain too, it is a shame to me when one,s designs simply get copied. Had a company like Silverline taken the concept and changed it, added improvements and features and made it their own tool I'd say fair game.
Tony
You are ofcourse quite right sir.
It is a blatant rip off - but isn't that what our far eastern friends specialize in?? -
It is the same, agreed.
However is Siverline or the company that ordered these or the company that sells them, amazon, Chinese owned too? Silverline seems to operate mainly in the Uk. I have bought some tools from them before.
It is easy to blame the Chinese, but who asked them to make it?
I suspect that being sold on Amazon uk they must have some sort of agreement with LM to make the product, or the patent is not valid in the UK, as direct copies like that are not often seen on mainstream online shops or regular shops. -
I'm just guessing that these must be the same tools that were being sold under the Jack Pyke name a few years ago. If so then I have to agree that the quality is really good given the low cost, not as good as a Crunch for sure, but still perfectly usable.
-
@Gareth said:
I'm just guessing that these must be the same tools that were being sold under the Jack Pyke name a few years ago. If so then I have to agree that the quality is really good given the low cost, not as good as a Crunch for sure, but still perfectly usable.I'm pretty sure you're right mate. I had seen your Jack Pyke one briefly at the first meet I went to, and decided to get this one as a try to give it a better evaluation. Like you say, there'll be compromises over the original but still worth a tenner - it's just the design does nothing for me at all, and I was pretty much instantly underwhelmed by it. I'm sure it would be a great tool for the right person though
-
I found a version of their Faux PST on their web site. Sells for $10 on Amazon

-
I would like to get my hands on one, but I can't figure out what the shipping to Denmark costs..

-
I would like to get my hands on one, but I can't figure out what the shipping to Denmark costs..

Also available from Amazon UK.
Congrats, Millhouse.
Welcome to the club. -
Thank you.
-
@trouthunter said:
I found a version of their Faux PST on their web site. Sells for $10 on Amazon
That doesn't look as much up to the job. I think most of us would never need a crunch EDC, but as a small set of grips for the tool bag or for most of us into MTs it's a way to try out a crunch cheaply :)
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
-
A few guys in my work have bought one and I ordered a spare one for the workshop...
Seems we started a bit of a rush on these.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
-
I would like to get my hands on one, but I can't figure out what the shipping to Denmark costs..

Also available from Amazon UK.
Thanks mate, but it was the Crunch clone I have to figure out the shipping for. :)
-
Should we move this thread in to the new Cheap tools section? :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login