Spotting Counterfeits
-
As I said before all pliers tools (and scissors etc) ~~are ~~
knockoffsderive from the original plier tool, which was probably invented a few thousand years ago..LM did not invent pliers and even folding pliers were in use earlier (I think Bob is the expert here..); people just generally improve an existing design making it better, cheaper, lighter, more usefull, nicer etc..
-
I always thought of a knock off as a cheaper version (or fake), of the original thing. If anything the swiss have a significant UPGRADE to to an MT concept, hardly a knockoff of it.
-
Has this topic gone off the rails slightly??
I assumed the original post was regarding branding knock-offs.
Not whether a company has copied a blade profile or used the concept of scissors!!Are we talking, for example the recent Gerber DET's that were to be found on ebay and even amazon. To me personally, I find that when they actually use a 'Brand' name in this instance Gerber, i.e copy not only the font used but also blatant lies to origin of manufacture - it's this that I find totally unacceptable.
If they want to copy the Multitools specific tool layout - well thats bad enough, but to then list it as a genuine item is quite frankly deplorable and should be stamped out.
-
I think "counterfeit" is a highly subjective term when it's not used specifically to refer to something produced with fraudulent intent to pass off as a product which is legally protected against being copied.
And when the Pawn Stars boys shoot a commercial implying that all the other similar shows are "knockoffs" they are overstating the original meaning of the term I think. Success is often imitated, after all.
-
@tosh said:
Has this topic gone off the rails slightly??I assumed the original post was regarding branding knock-offs.
Not whether a company has copied a blade profile or used the concept of scissors!!Are we talking, for example the recent Gerber DET's that were to be found on ebay and even amazon. To me personally, I find that when they actually use a 'Brand' name in this instance Gerber, i.e copy not only the font used but also blatant lies to origin of manufacture - it's this that I find totally unacceptable.
If they want to copy the Multitools specific tool layout - well thats bad enough, but to then list it as a genuine item is quite frankly deplorable and should be stamped out.
Ya counterfeits is what I thought this was about. I remember the Gerber DETs, and there are routinely fake SAKs that ebayers are trying to sell as real ones. I was just wondering if there are counterfeit leathermans or SOGs, as Ive never seen any.
-
@Syph007 said:
Ya counterfeits is what I thought this was about. I remember the Gerber DETs, and there are routinely fake SAKs that ebayers are trying to sell as real ones. I was just wondering if there are counterfeit leathermans or SOGs, as Ive never seen any.I guess it depends on your definition of counterfeit. Does this count, since it has the Leatherman name on it, but doesn't in any way resemble any Leatherman product ever made?
-
Would be good to see the more common and not-so-common counterfeit examples in one spot, then stickied. Probably would be need to be updated as well. That way when some of us that are not so adept on the subject would have a reference to go by.
Often tools are encountered online and on auctions. Even pictures of auctioned products are deceiving in what you see isn't what you get. Many eBay listing share the same graphic files and often have no enlarged photos. That should be a clue right there.
Products with unclear or horrible photos should be passed on. :ahhh
-
@Xelkos said:
Would be good to see the more common and not-so-common counterfeit examples in one spot, then stickied.That kinda WAS the intent here, but...
While I wield no authority, and I understand every thread wanders off topic, I was hoping this to be a 'I just saw X on ebay. How do I know I'm not buying a fake?' thread. Not a 'Leatherman Suxor/No Suxor!' thread.
And yes, tools that don't look anything LIKE a product from a company's product line, but branded with a company's name I would still consider a counterfeit.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Xelkos said:
Would be good to see the more common and not-so-common counterfeit examples in one spot, then stickied.
That kinda WAS the intent here, but...
While I wield no authority, and I understand every thread wanders off topic, I was hoping this to be a 'I just saw X on ebay. How do I know I'm not buying a fake?' thread. Not a 'Leatherman Suxor/No Suxor!' thread.
And yes, tools that don't look anything LIKE a product from a company's product line, but branded with a company's name I would still consider a counterfeit.
Exactly what I thought this was about. Counterfeit strongly carries the connotation of an attempt to defraud by misrepresentation. So basically if something claims to be something it's not. "Clones", "Copies", "Knockoff's" and "Inspired by" absolutely DON'T fall into that description, just so long as they don't claim to be something other than what they are.
-
Well defined Gareth

-
Ya counterfeits is what I thought this was about. I remember the Gerber DETs, and there are routinely fake SAKs that ebayers are trying to sell as real ones. I was just wondering if there are counterfeit leathermans or SOGs, as Ive never seen any.
I guess it depends on your definition of counterfeit. Does this count, since it has the Leatherman name on it, but doesn't in any way resemble any Leatherman product ever made?
Only if Leatherman didn't endorse this product, which seems likely in this case. But good luck suing China.
-
This type of threads in all forums are problematic.
I am not happy with someone trying to sell a product branded as e.g. Wenger when it is not.
This tricks people and makes them get a product that is not what they were expecting.However I and several others here may/or may not have bought products we knew were like that just to see how good they were.
Then comes the judgement by people that feel they should preach morality telling everybody that what they are doing, buying products that are not "original" is wrong.
Then some proceed further to tell people not to buy tools that are similar or inspired according to them by other makers, forgetting that the original product may have also been inspired by others. What level of similarity is allowed, even on products not claiming to be the “original product” depends on each individual.Have a look at BF to see people claiming that nearly every knife is a copy of their favourite brand, whatever it is. (Sebenza Vs SRM710 [and other knives] was a very popular topic a couple of years ago, though most people have now realised that they are two different knives, each with its own niche. Also {insert country } vs the rest used to come up often in the past)
I have said it before but the fact that this forum is owned and run by a wealthy Canadian businessman helps people from all over the world to express their opinion freely, as Canada does not have any huge multitool companies that he may feel need to be supported by the forum.
So the idea of posting pictures/links of counterfeits may be good but the discussion that usually follows is not so good. Generally here people tend to judge a multitool on its overall performance, for the price rather than its morality.
-
And I thought I was bad for moralizing...
-
I was just talking/typing in general concerning this type of threads.
This forum is the least affected by what I described..
-
Has this topic gone off the rails slightly??
I assumed the original post was regarding branding knock-offs.
Not whether a company has copied a blade profile or used the concept of scissors!!Are we talking, for example the recent Gerber DET's that were to be found on ebay and even amazon. To me personally, I find that when they actually use a 'Brand' name in this instance Gerber, i.e copy not only the font used but also blatant lies to origin of manufacture - it's this that I find totally unacceptable.
If they want to copy the Multitools specific tool layout - well thats bad enough, but to then list it as a genuine item is quite frankly deplorable and should be stamped out.
Ya counterfeits is what I thought this was about. I remember the Gerber DETs, and there are routinely fake SAKs that ebayers are trying to sell as real ones. I was just wondering if there are counterfeit leathermans or SOGs, as Ive never seen any.
remember the ''MAMUT" with "dental approved pliers" or something i'll edit in the link
</post/611717> -
@multi jack said:
Has this topic gone off the rails slightly??
I assumed the original post was regarding branding knock-offs.
Not whether a company has copied a blade profile or used the concept of scissors!!Are we talking, for example the recent Gerber DET's that were to be found on ebay and even amazon. To me personally, I find that when they actually use a 'Brand' name in this instance Gerber, i.e copy not only the font used but also blatant lies to origin of manufacture - it's this that I find totally unacceptable.
If they want to copy the Multitools specific tool layout - well thats bad enough, but to then list it as a genuine item is quite frankly deplorable and should be stamped out.
Ya counterfeits is what I thought this was about. I remember the Gerber DETs, and there are routinely fake SAKs that ebayers are trying to sell as real ones. I was just wondering if there are counterfeit leathermans or SOGs, as Ive never seen any.
remember the ''MAMUT" with "dental approved pliers" or something i'll edit in the link
</post/611717>Ah, but I would argue that that isn't a counterfeit Leatherman. After-all the name Leatherman doesn't appear anywhere on it. It's no doubt a "copy" of an original Wave, but it also doesn't claim to be anything else.
HOWEVER I do strongly suspect the use of the name Mammut is likely counterfeit, Mammut are an excellent (and pricey) maker of outdoor gear; clothing, sleeping bags, boots etc and I very much doubt that they had anything to do with this thing.

-
DKS... i want you to understand EXACTLY what I'm talking about when I started this thread. My intent is exactly this: that people know that they are getting what they asked for.
I am neither making nor claiming ANYTHING about the quality of a tool, or it's design lineage, how 'borrowed' any design concept is, etc.
I intended this, and ONLY this... if you buy a something described as a Victorinox Rescue Tool on ebay, how do you know you're getting an ACTUAL Victorinox Rescue Tool. That kind of thing.
-
LYNN LEFEY, no need to shout :D
I know why you started the thread, no need to explain yourself.
I was posting based on my experience, not on the reasoning for the thread..
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
