Victorinox Spirit X or LM Charge TTi
-
I'd look at it this way.
If you're getting a tool for the experience of using a tool, go with the Spirit. There is a sort of satisfaction in using it that most other tools can't match. But, if you're going to get a tool for the purpose of getting some task done with as little trouble as possible, go with the Charge. It's like two different design philosophies, one for recreation and one for "let's get this done and go home."
-
For the sake of discussion, let's throw deluxe tinker in there too. It has a great load-out and it's a lot smaller than a wave/charge. Does it work as a substitute for most tasks? No need to go in depth, I would simply like to know if $40 can do pretty much as much as $90.
-
I can see your dilemma, tough choice.............
So, I'll make it easy for you
Audrey Hepburn (Breakfast at Tiffanys)
OR
Lady GaGaOne's the epitome of class, polished to perfection - the other is basically a buffer girl at heart in a fancy dress with a tongue that's wickedly sharp.
simple eh.. :D
hint...Lovely Audrey can be the Spirit

-
@scorpion008 said:
For the sake of discussion, let's throw deluxe tinker in there too. It has a great load-out and it's a lot smaller than a wave/charge. Does it work as a substitute for most tasks?It's a different class of tool. The backside phillips on a 91mm will tear the tool apart trying to remove a phillips wood screw. Ask me how I know. The phillips on the Spirit and Charge can handle that task no problem. The flathead/crate opener on the Spirit is MUCH more robust than the flathead on the 91mm or even the 93mm ALOX knives. Pliers are of a whole different class. When you ask 'does it work as a substitute for most Tasks', that really depends on how heavy duty most of your tasks are. The 91mm SAK is a great LIGHT DUTY tool. The Spirit and Charge are medium/heavy duty, depending on the task. This is a generalization, and some 91mm tools are just as good as what's on the Charge or Spirit, like the awl, can opener, etc. Just my view. YMMV
-
I asked because I was looking at the spirit, which lead me to looking at spydercos to fix the no real main blade problem. Then I started looking for multis cheaper than the spirit because the spydercos were >$40.
-
@scorpion008 said:
I asked because I was looking at the spirit, which lead me to looking at spydercos to fix the no real main blade problem. Then I started looking for multis cheaper than the spirit because the spydercos were >$40.Have a look at Byrd knives, they are Spyderco's budget brand and are good value for money. :)
-
I was actually looking at the bug (lol), ladybug, ambitious, dragonfly, and delica. Which ones are not made in china?
-
The Spirit is better built , has better implements/implement density . It's much nicer ergonomically . I guess it just depends on how much you care about OHO , and the Diamond file .
Don't get me wrong , they are the top two middleweight contenders . The Leatherman U.T.A. works well with the Spirit .
Chris
-
Do you think the Spyderco ladybug could cover my oho edc blade needs?
-
@scorpion008 said:
Do you think the Spyderco ladybug could cover my oho edc blade needs?It's a nice little blade for sure. That said, I think the Dragonfly (or its cousin, the Byrd Robin) is a better size.
-
The sprit x all the way! :sak:
-
@Styerman said:
The Spirit is better built , has better implements/implement density . It's much nicer ergonomically . I guess it just depends on how much you care about OHO , and the Diamond file .I agree with this statement. I think the Spirit is a bit more versatile due to some better implements/implement density. The OHO knives on the Charge are nice, but not a necessity, IMO anyway. I know it can be a deciding factor for many. I do like the diamond file, but I don't file much of anything, so it's not a deal breaker.
It's a tough call for sure ??? I own both though, and I love each of them. I don't think you can really go wrong with either

-
One bad thing about the Charge TTi, besides the price, as that annoying cap crimper. It really isn't worth having if you don't have need for one. As to why Leatherman insists on putting such a ridiculous feature on the pliers is beyond me. Not like they go out of their way to give the consumers what they really want.
The scales are awesome & comfortable. The file on the Charge & Wave are fantastic.
There is no awl (with or without a thread hole) but a redundant flathead. You'd think with a large bit driver Leatherman would realize that's just going to make someone use a redundant flathead for a pry bar. Leatherman must have a fetish for fleathead drivers.

Put something useful in there, like an awl. There's been countless mods to prove it can be done. And Dave C. just doesn't know Leatherman tools. He placed the awl on his customized Wave in the middle, with the lanyard on the outside then wondered why it would not close.
There are removable lanyard & pocket clips that fit as accessories. If you get tired of coaxing the under-the-scale lanyard attachment, clip that thing out and have use for an MTO Charge saw there while keeping the pocket clip on.
The small bit driver is okay, is good to have one on you. Have used mine twice. Guess it is better than yet another redundant bit driver.
Voted for the TTi, as I like mine despite the cap crimper. As for the Spirit, cannot say a thing, never owned one. They are too expensive (to me) for a curiosity.
-
@Xelkos said:
One bad thing about the Charge TTi, besides the price, as that annoying cap crimper. It really isn't worth having if you don't have need for one. As to why Leatherman insists on putting such a ridiculous feature on the pliers is beyond me. Not like they go out of their way to give the consumers what they really want.The scales are awesome & comfortable. The file on the Charge & Wave are fantastic.
There is no awl (with or without a thread hole) but a redundant flathead. You'd think with a large bit driver Leatherman would realize that's just going to make someone use a redundant flathead for a pry bar. Leatherman must have a fetish for fleathead drivers.

Put something useful in there, like an awl. There's been countless mods to prove it can be done. And Dave C. just doesn't know Leatherman tools. He placed the awl on his customized Wave in the middle, with the lanyard on the outside then wondered why it would not close.
There are removable lanyard & pocket clips that fit as accessories. If you get tired of coaxing the under-the-scale lanyard attachment, clip that thing out and have use for an MTO Charge saw there while keeping the pocket clip on.
The small bit driver is okay, is good to have one on you. Have used mine twice. Guess it is better than yet another redundant bit driver.
Voted for the TTi, as I like mine despite the cap crimper. As for the Spirit, cannot say a thing, never owned one. They are too expensive (to me) for a curiosity.
Yeah, I'm not a big fan of that crimper either. I really have no use for it, and it takes up valuable plier head surface space. Perhaps there are some other ways it can be useful, but I don't really know of any from my experience anyway.
I actually filed the redundant flathead down to an awl. Not the greatest awl, but still more useful than another flathead. I think you're onto something when you say they have a flathead fetish.

-
I've noticed that the "redundant" flat head isn't a standard size, it's too big to fit in most the screws that I've tried to use it for and it doesn't seem to match up in size with any of Leatherman's removable bits.
-
@sjian said:
I've noticed that the "redundant" flat head isn't a standard size, it's too big to fit in most the screws that I've tried to use it for and it doesn't seem to match up in size with any of Leatherman's removable bits.That's the one Leatherman removed because their customers used it as a by bar. They removed it and stuck in two more redundant flatheads. They sure have a fetish for them things...

-
@Xelkos said:
I've noticed that the "redundant" flat head isn't a standard size, it's too big to fit in most the screws that I've tried to use it for and it doesn't seem to match up in size with any of Leatherman's removable bits.
That's the one Leatherman removed because their customers used it as a by bar. They removed it and stuck in two more redundant flatheads. They sure have a fetish for them things...-- was referring to the Surge.The flathead on the Charge makes for a great spot for an awl.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login