Spyderco Manbug
-
If I'm not mistaken aren't those ladybugs and jesters?
-
First off, I prefer the manbug to the ladybug on the basis of the full flat grind. I personally do not like the ladybug's hollow grind. I know the zpd189 has a ffg but I do not like the green handle. I have heard rumors that the blade geometry is different as well, is this a non-issue?
Do you find the bug worth $10 (cheapest ebay price)? Especially considering that you have a ladybug salt. Would you ever opt to use it instead of you Lb? I figured that since they are both so small they both fit the niche of knives nonthreatening to knife haters. I would not keychain carry either btw. However it might be nice to have to try out ss handles, which must look and feel better than frn.
All thoughts appreciated!
-
@scorpion008 said:
First off, I prefer the manbug to the ladybug on the basis of the full flat grind. I personally do not like the ladybug's hollow grind. I know the zpd189 has a ffg but I do not like the green handle. I have heard rumors that the blade geometry is different as well, is this a non-issue?
All thoughts appreciated!Grind and geometry aren't really going to make much of a difference when we're talking about a knife the size of the Ladybug or Manbag. Besides, even though the Ladybug has a sabre grind (not hollow!) it uses thinner stock than the Manbug.
As for handle color, well, I guess that's highly personal. You can dye FRN scales black pretty easily, though.
-
You might also want to consider other SS options from the Bug series like the HoneyBee or GrassHopper. None of them are locking though.

-
The steel is substantially worse, though. I think a better cheaper option would be the Finch or Starling.
-
I was pretty much set on the frn manbug. Black, light, vg-10, locking, small, full flat grind. All I really wanted. The slipit line is only really tempting with the bug.
-
@scorpion008 said:
Do you find the bug worth $10 (cheapest ebay price)? Especially considering that you have a ladybug salt. Would you ever opt to use it instead of you Lb? I figured that since they are both so small they both fit the niche of knives nonthreatening to knife haters. I would not keychain carry either btw. However it might be nice to have to try out ss handles, which must look and feel better than frn.All thoughts appreciated!
I guess what I'm saying here is, if you already have a ladybug/manbug, would you spend $10 on a bug and feel that you really got your money's worth? Does it add $10 of value to your setup, pretending for a moment that you have no other knives except from saks and multis?
If I seem anxious over the sake of $10, perhaps this conveys the size of my budget quite clearly. :_c:
-
Depends on your use and intended carry. I have two, received as gifts and I don't carry neither as it doesn't fit into my setup at the moment, but that could change.
I know some members carry them every day. Some on a necklace, some in the wallet, some on the keychain, ... You have to decide that for yourself. -
I'm going to be honest in saying that for the size of the blade on a bug, and the weight (.6oz), I'd rather bump up to .72oz and carry a Vic Classic. Edit... The Vic Classic is VASTLY more useful, IMO.
I mean, I DO think the bug looks super cool. It just doesn't seem worth it.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I'm going to be honest in saying that for the size of the blade on a bug, and the weight (.6oz), I'd rather bump up to .72oz and carry a Vic Classic. Edit... The Vic Classic is VASTLY more useful, IMO.I mean, I DO think the bug looks super cool. It just doesn't seem worth it.

I gotta give that three thumbs up. I've been edc'ing a classic now for several years, and it's seen service from NYC to Naples Florida, and it's always been one of the handiest little items in my travel kit. Add either a Vic bantam for larger cutting jobs and screw driver, or put a P-38 in your wallet, and your about ready for anything. The Spyderco is a one dimensional tool with a single purpose, but the classic can handle small phillips and regular screws, scissor jobs, bottle opening if you don't know the house key or Bic lighter trick, plus tweezers that really work.
-
Last question. For those that have the Manbug, does the blade geometry (up swept tip) ever pose a problem, or ever cause inconvenience? I have heard several complaints, but I really like this knife and its ffg and hope that this isn't a big deal. If anyone thinks the swept up tip (compared to the ladybug) is an advantage, please tell me why, aside from the fact that it makes a better skinning knife.
-
I'd go for the ladybug zdp-189 ffg but if you perfer the manbug, go with the g10 version.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I'm going to be honest in saying that for the size of the blade on a bug, and the weight (.6oz), I'd rather bump up to .72oz and carry a Vic Classic. Edit... The Vic Classic is VASTLY more useful, IMO.I mean, I DO think the bug looks super cool. It just doesn't seem worth it.
This is exactly why I gave my Dragonfly 2 to my wife. For the kinds of small cutting jobs I encounter day to day, a small Vic like my Executive does the job just as well, and provides a lot more utility than a small dedicated folder.
I can see how there would be some situations where something like a Ladybug would be better, but I can't remember the last time my Exec or the small blade in my Squirt S4 was the only thing I had on hand and it wasn't sufficient.
That said, I like the blade profile of the Manbug more because of the extra belly it has, but in a knife that small, I doubt it's going to make a lot of difference. If I were to get another knife that small, I'd go for a Jester. I think the blade profile and the jimping it has for precision work is really well designed. The next time I have $60 - $70 to blow (yeah, riiiiiiight....) I'll think of picking one up!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


