A little advice please.
-
-

@Cupboard said:
What about a Fenix? They've got a bit of a range of single AA lights, mine's an LD10 which replaced an LD10 that got nicked which replaced an LD01 that got nicked :DI did take a look at the E11 as an option but it's still a little long for my taste right now. The LD10 is a great light but I have a couple of lights about the same size already.

-
How about your original suggestion again, the D25A clicky, but in titanium.
Can't let Nuphoria have all the shiny things.

-
Thanks for all the input folks.
In the end I've gone for the D25A Clicky XP-G R4 anyway. :-[ I wanted to try a more neutral tinted light, hence the R4, but I also like a bit of throw, hence the XP-G.Really looking forward to this one; could this be my ultimate EDC light? 8)
-
@Gareth said:
Thanks for all the input folks.
In the end I've gone for the D25A Clicky XP-G R4 anyway. :-[ I wanted to try a more neutral tinted light, hence the R4, but I also like a bit of throw, hence the XP-G.Really looking forward to this one; could this be my ultimate EDC light? 8)
Naa, you're an addict just like me. You'll buy many other lights in the future, just to try them out. >:D
-
sadly you are probably right. :P
-
@Gareth said:
Thanks for all the input folks.
In the end I've gone for the D25A Clicky XP-G R4 anyway. :-[ I wanted to try a more neutral tinted light, hence the R4, but I also like a bit of throw, hence the XP-G.Really looking forward to this one; could this be my ultimate EDC light? 8)
It could be, but who are you trying to fool?

Even if you do end up carrying it every day, like you're going to stop buying new torches?

I think you'll find the neutral tint will grow on you... ever since I discovered neutrals and high CRI emitters, I can't stomach cool tints anymore. It's actually a good thing too, because it keeps my torch habit in check.
After a few years of this now, I've learned that tint and beam pattern trump pure output every day of the week. -
Oh I totally blame this tint thing on you mate.
To get the right combo of tint and emitter I wanted I had to order it in from the US, I couldn't find a UK supplier with just the right light. 
-
It's a bit of a rabbit hole for sure!
I do like neutral/white lights but it also depends on when and where I tend to use them.Hope you enjoy the new one Gareth - looking forward to seeing if I get with that UI too

-
OK, the tint thing might not be totally Heinz's fault. ;) I also found myself with an old incan torch that was given to my daughter and thinking "that really is a nice colour of light". Everything else was exactly what you'd expect, dull, ringy etc, but it was nice and "warm" to look at. :D
-
@Gareth said:
OK, the tint thing might not be totally Heinz's fault. ;) I also found myself with an old incan torch that was given to my daughter and thinking "that really is a nice colour of light". Everything else was exactly what you'd expect, dull, ringy etc, but it was nice and "warm" to look at. :DAnother convert! :D
The thing about warm tints is they tent to be strongest in the range of the spectrum our eyes are most sensitive to. The long wavelength (red) cones, and the medium wavelength (green) cones have a fair bit of overlap in the range of wavelengths they're sensitive to. The brain encodes brightness based on signal intensity, and as a result, when viewing two objectively equally intense narrow spectrum lights (measured in photons, candelas, whatever), one yellow and one blue, we will see the yellow one as brighter. That's simply because there are a lot more cones in the eye being stimulated and therefore producing a stronger signal sent to the brain.
Now it's true that a cool tint emitter will be objectively (and perceptually) brighter than a neutral or a warm tint emitter, but this is because of how tints are done on LEDs. They're coated with a phosphor layer that absorbs some portions of the spectrum, particularly the higher temperature wavelengths. So even though we're more sensitive to warmer temperatures, we still see a cool tint as brighter because it has a greater amount of total wavelengths in its power spectrum than a neutral or warm tint emitter produces.
The advantage of this, though, is that because of the medium and long cones are being stimulated more by a neutral or warm tint, it provides a stronger activation in what's called the parvocellular retinal ganglion system.
There are actually five major kinds of different neurons in the retina, with rods and cones being only one type, the photoreceptors. There are at least four different kinds of retinal ganglion cells, and there may be a new one that was just discovered in the last few years, but I'll have to check to be sure... Anyway, ganglion cells are the ones that get signals from the photoreceptors and then send that information to the brain. There are several sub-types, with the magnocellular and parvocellular being the two main types. It's the parvocellular ones that give us our detail, acuity, and color vision; the magno cells only encode motion and changes in brightness.
Anyway, to get back to the point, the extra activation of the parvocellular system gives us better depth perception with a neutral or warm tint. Shadows appear crisper and darker as a result, and it's those brightness differences that also affect the magno system, which increases our sense of depth with a neutral or warm tint as well.
The magno system does get input from the cones, but it's important to note that rods only send their input to magno cells. Thus, when you're fully dark adapted, what's called scotopic vision, only your rods are working as those levels of light are too dim to actually activate the cones. Rods are six to ten times more sensitive to light than cones are; it takes only a single photon of light to stimulate a rod to fire an action potential. A cone on the other hand, requires (you guessed it) six to ten photons of light to activate and produce an action potential. What's more, rods are maximally sensitive at a wavelength of about 505 nm, which is on the green/blue borderline of the visible spectrum, but yet that information isn't encoded by the brain, so we are literally color blind when in true scotopic vision. This results in a simple rule of thumb to know if you're truly in scotopic vision; if you can see the color of the light, it's too bright, and you're compromising your scotopic vision.
I guess I should just skip explaining the difference between dark adaptation and scotopic vision for now, since I've really gone off on a wild tangent here!

Okay, brain-dump over.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
OK, the tint thing might not be totally Heinz's fault. ;) I also found myself with an old incan torch that was given to my daughter and thinking "that really is a nice colour of light". Everything else was exactly what you'd expect, dull, ringy etc, but it was nice and "warm" to look at. :D
Another convert! :D
The thing about warm tints is they tent to be strongest in the range of the spectrum our eyes are most sensitive to. The long wavelength (red) cones, and the medium wavelength (green) cones have a fair bit of overlap in the range of wavelengths they're sensitive to. The brain encodes brightness based on signal intensity, and as a result, when viewing two objectively equally intense narrow spectrum lights (measured in photons, candelas, whatever), one yellow and one blue, we will see the yellow one as brighter. That's simply because there are a lot more cones in the eye being stimulated and therefore producing a stronger signal sent to the brain.
Now it's true that a cool tint emitter will be objectively (and perceptually) brighter than a neutral or a warm tint emitter, but this is because of how tints are done on LEDs. They're coated with a phosphor layer that absorbs some portions of the spectrum, particularly the higher temperature wavelengths. So even though we're more sensitive to warmer temperatures, we still see a cool tint as brighter because it has a greater amount of total wavelengths in its power spectrum than a neutral or warm tint emitter produces.
The advantage of this, though, is that because of the medium and long cones are being stimulated more by a neutral or warm tint, it provides a stronger activation in what's called the parvocellular retinal ganglion system.
There are actually five major kinds of different neurons in the retina, with rods and cones being only one type, the photoreceptors. There are at least four different kinds of retinal ganglion cells, and there may be a new one that was just discovered in the last few years, but I'll have to check to be sure... Anyway, ganglion cells are the ones that get signals from the photoreceptors and then send that information to the brain. There are several sub-types, with the magnocellular and parvocellular being the two main types. It's the parvocellular ones that give us our detail, acuity, and color vision; the magno cells only encode motion and changes in brightness.
Anyway, to get back to the point, the extra activation of the parvocellular system gives us better depth perception with a neutral or warm tint. Shadows appear crisper and darker as a result, and it's those brightness differences that also affect the magno system, which increases our sense of depth with a neutral or warm tint as well.
The magno system does get input from the cones, but it's important to note that rods only send their input to magno cells. Thus, when you're fully dark adapted, what's called scotopic vision, only your rods are working as those levels of light are too dim to actually activate the cones. Rods are six to ten times more sensitive to light than cones are; it takes only a single photon of light to stimulate a rod to fire an action potential. A cone on the other hand, requires (you guessed it) six to ten photons of light to activate and produce an action potential. What's more, rods are maximally sensitive at a wavelength of about 505 nm, which is on the green/blue borderline of the visible spectrum, but yet that information isn't encoded by the brain, so we are literally color blind when in true scotopic vision. This results in a simple rule of thumb to know if you're truly in scotopic vision; if you can see the color of the light, it's too bright, and you're compromising your scotopic vision.
I guess I should just skip explaining the difference between dark adaptation and scotopic vision for now, since I've really gone off on a wild tangent here!

Okay, brain-dump over.
Ahhhhhhhhhh
my brain hurts.
great post Heinz
Stay Warm
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
OK, the tint thing might not be totally Heinz's fault. ;) I also found myself with an old incan torch that was given to my daughter and thinking "that really is a nice colour of light". Everything else was exactly what you'd expect, dull, ringy etc, but it was nice and "warm" to look at. :D
Another convert! :D
The thing about warm tints is they tent to be strongest in the range of the spectrum our eyes are most sensitive to. The long wavelength (red) cones, and the medium wavelength (green) cones have a fair bit of overlap in the range of wavelengths they're sensitive to. The brain encodes brightness based on signal intensity, and as a result, when viewing two objectively equally intense narrow spectrum lights (measured in photons, candelas, whatever), one yellow and one blue, we will see the yellow one as brighter. That's simply because there are a lot more cones in the eye being stimulated and therefore producing a stronger signal sent to the brain.
Now it's true that a cool tint emitter will be objectively (and perceptually) brighter than a neutral or a warm tint emitter, but this is because of how tints are done on LEDs. They're coated with a phosphor layer that absorbs some portions of the spectrum, particularly the higher temperature wavelengths. So even though we're more sensitive to warmer temperatures, we still see a cool tint as brighter because it has a greater amount of total wavelengths in its power spectrum than a neutral or warm tint emitter produces.
The advantage of this, though, is that because of the medium and long cones are being stimulated more by a neutral or warm tint, it provides a stronger activation in what's called the parvocellular retinal ganglion system.
There are actually five major kinds of different neurons in the retina, with rods and cones being only one type, the photoreceptors. There are at least four different kinds of retinal ganglion cells, and there may be a new one that was just discovered in the last few years, but I'll have to check to be sure... Anyway, ganglion cells are the ones that get signals from the photoreceptors and then send that information to the brain. There are several sub-types, with the magnocellular and parvocellular being the two main types. It's the parvocellular ones that give us our detail, acuity, and color vision; the magno cells only encode motion and changes in brightness.
Anyway, to get back to the point, the extra activation of the parvocellular system gives us better depth perception with a neutral or warm tint. Shadows appear crisper and darker as a result, and it's those brightness differences that also affect the magno system, which increases our sense of depth with a neutral or warm tint as well.
The magno system does get input from the cones, but it's important to note that rods only send their input to magno cells. Thus, when you're fully dark adapted, what's called scotopic vision, only your rods are working as those levels of light are too dim to actually activate the cones. Rods are six to ten times more sensitive to light than cones are; it takes only a single photon of light to stimulate a rod to fire an action potential. A cone on the other hand, requires (you guessed it) six to ten photons of light to activate and produce an action potential. What's more, rods are maximally sensitive at a wavelength of about 505 nm, which is on the green/blue borderline of the visible spectrum, but yet that information isn't encoded by the brain, so we are literally color blind when in true scotopic vision. This results in a simple rule of thumb to know if you're truly in scotopic vision; if you can see the color of the light, it's too bright, and you're compromising your scotopic vision.
I guess I should just skip explaining the difference between dark adaptation and scotopic vision for now, since I've really gone off on a wild tangent here!

Okay, brain-dump over.
Ahhhhhhhhhh
my brain hurts.
great post Heinz
Stay Warm
Hope it helps!

And don't worry about your brain... I'm sure it's fine. I've spent, literally, a third of my life studying and teaching this stuff, so I know a lot about it. I've even worked as a neurophysiology researcher studying the visual systems and functions of the brain using rhesus monkeys. No more stabbing monkey brains for me though... in-vivo neurophysiology research is definitely fascinating, but just not my particular bag. If you had weirdos like me sticking needles in your brains that are hooked up to oscilloscopes, potentiometers, and other things like that, then you'd have to worry about your brain! :o
-
Just arrived today and I've had a couple of minutes to play with it. Initial impressions are very good.

-
-
Yeah, five days from time of order, bought from Illumination Gear. I've not used them before but I will certainly consider using them again.

BTW, the "cost" of the light dropped to $15 on the declaration form. Top chaps.

-
:D
Very nice of them.

-
Yeah, they're good like that ;)
-
OK. Second impressions are still good. It's about as compact as I expected and I think just about small enough to be carried on my keys. I'm very happy with the LED I picked, nice warm tint and good hot-spot. Very well made light and good clip IMO.
The not-so-hot; the reverse clicky is a little hard to get to with my thumb, and it's not like I have fat fingers. The D25A Clicky does not have mode memory in the 'group 1' setting (i.e with the bezel loosened), my understanding is that the larger lights in the family do. :-\ Shame, as I rather like the medium level and I have to click through to get to it.
There is nothing however that I truly dislike on this light and it nicely falls into my "small enough, bright enough, versatile enough" wish list of features.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
