Saw vs. Scissors
-
Going without scissors would be OK , if you had a 58mm , like a Rambler on your keyring .
Chris
-
-
Wenger Ranger 172- Huge scissors AND a huge saw.
Case closed
-
Scissors won with ease. Now, for those that wouldn't stay with a
let's go for the next one; Wood saw or Metal saw? Huntsman or Mountaineer? -
@kkokkolis said:
Scissors won with ease. Now, for those that wouldn't stay with a
let's go for the next one; Wood saw or Metal saw? Huntsman or Mountaineer?Start a poll about it then mate. I would but I don't want to steal your ideal :D
-
@papercut said:
Wenger Ranger 172- Huge scissors AND a huge saw.Case closed
Case reopened :P
Wenger Ranger 71 takes it to a higher class by adding a corkscrew
... but unfortunately has a CE blade :-\Wenger Ranger 14 keeps the corkscrew and reverts to plain edge blade
and doesn't have stupidly thick handle scales which should only be used on the slimmer models IMHO. Also, it doesn't have the cool "push the logo" lock release, but the slide release works well enough too -
Ahhh Ranger 14, isn't that thing a myth? How many made it to the wild?
Also, doesn't the 71 have a plain edge? It seems to be Euro only though, while the 172 is North America?
-
IMHO, The Climber is the essential SAK, so scissors for me. I use the scissors almost daily, whereas I use the other tools occasionally. I do have a Vic Ranger in my EDC rotation, and it's light compared to my Deluxe Climber despite being the same size, but the bare minimum for me is the Climber. I've tried to EDC a Compact, but I missed the small blade, the can opener/phillips, and the awl. I have a Harvester that I use for whittling, but could get by with the Climber for that in a pinch too.
-
@papercut said:
Ahhh Ranger 14, isn't that thing a myth? How many made it to the wild?Also, doesn't the 71 have a plain edge? It seems to be Euro only though, while the 172 is North America?
They're certainly real mate :D but I don't know how many made it out. Here's mine ;) ...

I'm a little unsure on the edges on the others. I based my comments on some googled pics before I commented, then say others after I'd posted which didn't correlate :-\ but there is a good chance I'd cocked up
-
Very nice 14, I think it was not released in NA very widely. I just found that the 71 is available locally which is fantastic! It runs about $60 though, so I need to consider if it is really THAT much better than the 172 I already own. It would be really awesome if a OH version had the scissors like a 78 plus scissors, but I don't think that will be happening with the demise of Wenger.
-
I like scissors better, I use them more than the knife. If I need a saw take a folding saw in my backpack.
-
Saw for me

I'm in pretty much the same boat as the OP - 3 layers is about my ideal thickness for every day basic carry. As I have posted before, the Hiker is so very close to being my ideal SAK (just need a marlin spike added and replace the small blade with something).
The saw (wood saw) is such a great tool. I've used it for trimming bits off gate posts, trimming wooden bed legs, cutting door threshold bars, cutting PVC plumbing pipes, cutting sticks for the dog when walking, the list could go on. It is so versatile. I really feel a bit "vulnerable" and "lost" when I carry an SAK without a saw.
I also believe a person's job and lifestyle affects their choice of either saw or scissors. An outdoors/manual worker might find more applications that suit the saw. In contrast, an office based individual may find more uses for the scissors in their average day.
It's possible that as I collect more, maybe get some mods done that I'll possibly change my views. But for the moment, the saw wins out by a country mile.
-
@Echo said:
I also believe a person's job and lifestyle affects their choice of either saw or scissors. An outdoors/manual worker might find more applications that suit the saw. In contrast, an office based individual may find more uses for the scissors in their average day.This is my usage situation exactly. For normal day to day use, scissors beat out a saw every day; a saw is barely more useful to me than a fish scaler on a day to day basis.
However, I do a fair amount of hiking, and do several camping and/or backpacking trips every year with my wife and kids, and/or extended family. In that situation, although I rarely use it, I always make sure I have a SAK with a saw blade in it. I've taken several outdoors-skills/survival classes and I can tell you from personal experience that making a hearthboard for a fire-bow or hand-drill is one heck of a lot easier if you've got a knife with a saw blade on you...

-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I also believe a person's job and lifestyle affects their choice of either saw or scissors. An outdoors/manual worker might find more applications that suit the saw. In contrast, an office based individual may find more uses for the scissors in their average day.
This is my usage situation exactly. For normal day to day use, scissors beat out a saw every day; a saw is barely more useful to me than a fish scaler on a day to day basis.
However, I do a fair amount of hiking, and do several camping and/or backpacking trips every year with my wife and kids, and/or extended family. In that situation, although I rarely use it, I always make sure I have a SAK with a saw blade in it. I've taken several outdoors-skills/survival classes and I can tell you from personal experience that making a hearthboard for a fire-bow or hand-drill is one heck of a lot easier if you've got a knife with a saw blade on you...

Or for some of us that carry a pliers-based multitool we get a SAK that has the tool implements that compliment or replace the missing parts. Though my first SAK was influenced by this forum's poll. No regrets!
There isn't a SAK that has all I want on one tool. Same for my Leatherman. What to do?

-
@Xelkos said:
There isn't a SAK that has all I want on one tool. Same for my Leatherman. What to do?
I used to think this until I got a Work Champ. I could, literally, have it be my only EDC tool and still deal with 99% of the small tool related tasks I run up against on a day to day basis.
Then I saw the Wenger RangerGrip 90... Now if only I could get a Work Champ with a Ranger's pliers!
Wait... uh... oh. Never mind; you're right!
:D -
@Xelkos said:
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
I also believe a person's job and lifestyle affects their choice of either saw or scissors. An outdoors/manual worker might find more applications that suit the saw. In contrast, an office based individual may find more uses for the scissors in their average day.
This is my usage situation exactly. For normal day to day use, scissors beat out a saw every day; a saw is barely more useful to me than a fish scaler on a day to day basis.
However, I do a fair amount of hiking, and do several camping and/or backpacking trips every year with my wife and kids, and/or extended family. In that situation, although I rarely use it, I always make sure I have a SAK with a saw blade in it. I've taken several outdoors-skills/survival classes and I can tell you from personal experience that making a hearthboard for a fire-bow or hand-drill is one heck of a lot easier if you've got a knife with a saw blade on you...

Or for some of us that carry a pliers-based multitool we get a SAK that has the tool implements that compliment or replace the missing parts. Though my first SAK was influenced by this forum's poll. No regrets!
There isn't a SAK that has all I want on one tool. Same for my Leatherman. What to do?

This is my situation as well. I carry either the Rebar, Charge or Spirit and like to carry a SAK (or two :D) to compliment it. Most things are covered this way.

-
I just finished a month-long test of a $6 pocket knife, so for once I really had to pay attention to my tool usage. I found that even though I use the scissors more often, it's rarely for something really urgent. When I need the saw, however, I need it RIGHT NOW.
Take from that what you will.
-
@Xelkos said:
Or for some of us that carry a pliers-based multitool we get a SAK that has the tool implements that compliment or replace the missing parts. Though my first SAK was influenced by this forum's poll. No regrets!There isn't a SAK that has all I want on one tool. Same for my Leatherman. What to do?

It really is such a personal thing choosing an SAK with scissors or saw. I seem to have an "either/or" mentality when carrying a multitool. It's either an SAK or my Leatherman Charge. I don't have any need to carry both. I've tried and just find the weight and bulk of 2 MT's a bit of a pain. I'd rather just go to my travel tool box in the truck and get the right tools. The SAK or Leatherman (saw and scissors included) is a nice bonus to have on my person for those little jobs.
I can't believe my Charge AL doesn't have an awl - that is a real negative for me. I'm slowly learning more and more from this site and hopefully will be able to get some nice mods done and try to attain the "Perfect EDC SAK"

-
Yeah, you're not alone in wanting a good awl in a tool.
I tend to carry a 93mm Alox SAK for that reason, because I find it to be hugely useful on a regular basis :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login