SAKs vs Juices
-
I also think the idea of the Juice line is great, but I wish Leatherman had been a little more concerned with quality when they made them. For example, the scissors on my basically brand new CS4 have pivot play that you might expect from a 10 year old pair of cheap scissors. The fit and finish is just no wheres near what Vic puts out.
I would love to be able to love the Juice line as I think they are a great package on paper, and a great size for pocket carry. I think that if they were to have better QC, than they could have a tool that could/would be loved and carried by people that actually use their tools.
-
Interesting question, one that I have pondered before. It comes down to what I am doing on the day. At work I need pliers often (typically several times a day) and so a SAK on it's own just isn't going to do it for me I'm afraid. The Juice does have some limitations but I've carried my SC2 at work several times and I was generally very positive about it's performance.
Scissors, blade and saw all cut things, screwdrivers turn things and pliers grab things. ;)Now it's the weekend and I do have a SAK on me and nothing else, my use of pliers becomes very secondary while not at work and the little Vic ones are fine for what I am likely to be doing. I like the feel of a SAK a little more and it's a little less likely to take lumps out of my thumb for having the temerity of wanting to use a flat driver. ;)
So I say it's not really a question of which is better, just a question of which one suits what you are doing better. :)
-
But then Victorinox is capable to build a high quality Juice- like tool. I don't know what is the agreement between them and Tim Leatherman though. They might have some restriction. We know that they (V&W) always try to innovate with tools (Autotool, Cybertool, Office tool, Swisscard, Swissrachet etc), so we should expect one or more surprises.
-
I would be very surprised if there was any kind of agreement between Vic and LM in any way at all. I have always suspected that Vic have not gone down the Juice sized tool as it was never likely to make any real impact on their share of the market.
To put it another way (and ignoring other makers for the moment); once upon a time Vic had the 'pocket sized' tool market totally sewn up. LM come along and try to take a bite of that market, currently with the Skeletool, Freestyle and Juice tools.
Now how many of those LM's do we really think are sold compared to Vic SAKs? 1 in 100? 5 in 100? more? Perhaps, but I personally doubt it. So even if I am being generous I still suspect that in the 'pocket sized' category Vic still totally rule. So why on earth would they put lots of time and effort into making another product that couldn't actually gain them much of more of a market share than they already have?I will completely concede that there is a lot of guesswork in there, and I hope I'm wrong, I'd love to see Vic doing a compact pliers based tool as well.

-
The best thing about the juice is the size... other than that the tools are all inferior to SAK ones.
I want a juice size spirit so bad that I will end up making my own I think. Take Vic tools, make backsprings and my own plier head and assemble.

This idea would have worked, but it was thick with the dual SAK scales so I can make it thinner by making some Ti scales custom fit. I have all the parts right now to make one if I reuse the juice plier head, then if I like it I can make my own plier heads.
-
If your primary needs are only good pliers and drivers, go for the Juice. If other tools are priority (like knife, scissors, awl, etc) then get a SAK.
Or better yet: **Get a Juice and a pair it with Victorinox Compact. **
The Compact will make up for the Juice's shortcomings. The Compact has a better knife, a can/bottle opener that actually works, much better scissors, and the plus scales give you tweezers, toothpick, pen, eyeglass driver, and a pin.
-
I'd sell my Granny for a Juice sized Vic Spirit! >:D
-
One of my earlier posts not long after joining was a head-to-head between a Victorinox Deluxe Tinker and Leatherman Juice CS4 HERE and my views haven't changed much :) However, I often carry a SAK along with a pliers tool, and chose which to carry of each to compliment each other as well as possible
-
As far as I am concerned, I choosed a SAK years ago and from SAKs I choose the biggest with practical use Swisschamp, Swisschamp XLT and Minichamp. My first Leatherman will also be one of the biggest, the Surge.
Since I got the XLT I loved it but I couldn't help not noticing that it is a fat guy. I thought that it would fit better at hand if one could divide it in two. I opened an unpopular thread somewhere about such a theoretical plan, to divide the XLT or XAVT into two pieces, one with urban mentality and one for outdoors, or one with common and one with uncommon features.
I learned about Juices here, so that gave me the idea for a plier centered Swiss Army Knife.
The SAKs are built around the excellent springs and that means that the plier head should fit inside the main compartment. On the outside we would have slim tools, such as the corckscrew, awl, hook etc.
Then the long tools would be restricted to just four, if we would avoid our SAK to be very fat again. Most Multitools have just 4 long tools anyway, even without using floating springs.
Now I think of it, SAKs are perfect as such and the full size and heavy duty Multitools are better suited to serious work. So it is better to rely on a big Leatherman and your favorite SAK. The best of both worlds.
About the market share I agree, but that didn't stop Victorinox from experimenting with the Rachet and Autotool or Wenger with Officetool. And if I was T. Leatherman I wouldn't help the market giant to make competitive tools without some kind of written contract agreement. That seems suicidal. I wouldn't need an agreement in case I would sell the whole business to them but that didn't happen. He helped the best known factory to make tools that would cut his sales (most buyers get just one multitool, don't judge from us, sick multitool hoarders) and let them go at will? Then why didn't they make their own Wavelike tool? This is very attractive to buyers. 4 one hand opening and locking tools with a full plier is what V&W miss. They wouldn't have to produce expensive half solutions like the Swissgrip and Rangers with just one lockable or one hand opening blade as Wenger did, or limit themselves to Supertool reminiscent tools.
Just some thoughts of mine. -
Since both tools are light duty I dont consider this a SAK vs Juice issue. Choose your tool according to your needs. :)
-
I do that. But it multitools are our hobby also, so we like to talk, think and imagine about them. That's all. And by vs I don't mean war. Competition and exchange of ideas mostly.
-
@kkokkolis said:
I do that. But it multitools are our hobby also, so we like to talk, think and imagine about them. That's all. And by vs I don't mean war. Competition and exchange of ideas mostly.Well tool wise I do like the S2, but the steel is not anywhere near as good. If it was 440c instead of rust prone 420hc it might be higher on my like list.
-
reading kkokkolis's posts - have I missed something about Leatherman making Swisstools or what?
I'm confused

-
@shamus said:
Or better yet: **Get a Juice and a pair it with Victorinox Compact. **The Compact will make up for the Juice's shortcomings. The Compact has a better knife, a can/bottle opener that actually works, much better scissors, and the plus scales give you tweezers, toothpick, pen, eyeglass driver, and a pin.
That is actually a damn good combo!
I'd like to play with an XE6 some time,but so far the only Juice I rate is the KF4,but with no scissors,you still need a SAK any way,even if it is just a Rambler!
-
@50ft-trad said:
One of my earlier posts not long after joining was a head-to-head between a Victorinox Deluxe Tinker and Leatherman Juice CS4 HERE and my views haven't changed much :) However, I often carry a SAK along with a pliers tool, and chose which to carry of each to compliment each other as well as possibleYep, remember that all too well. I had a Deluxe Tinker on the way within 48 hours of reading that..... :) I will have to say that I much prefer SAKs over the Juice line. I think the Juice is a great idea whose execution was sub-par. My S2 was underwhelming to me, and painful! Those damn stabby screwdrivers.... The S2 was rapidly replaced by the combination of my Octane and a SAK, which lately has been overtaken by the Balance and a SAK. I'm not adverse to pocket size tools, I just couldn't get along with the Juice.
-
Engineered by Vic. , the Juice could have been a world class catch all !
The concept has potential , the execution is not good .
Chris
-
I do that. But it multitools are our hobby also, so we like to talk, think and imagine about them. That's all. And by vs I don't mean war. Competition and exchange of ideas mostly.
Well tool wise I do like the S2, but the steel is not anywhere near as good. If it was 440c instead of rust prone 420hc it might be higher on my like list.
My biggest complaint about the Juice line has always been the crappy blades they have. Not only are they weirdly shaped to conform to the shape of the body of the tool, they're made of crappy steel with a crappy grind pattern IMHO. I won't use the blade in either my S2 or my CS4 unless I don't have anything else available. They won't hold and edge much at all, if you don't end up rolling the edge on it that is...

I agree about the quality of the other implements; not as good as a Vic or Wenger. The scissors on both my Juices work acceptably; not great, but they generally do what I put them to. In general, I don't need pliers on a day to day basis, so a SAK covers me for 95% of what I come across on a daily basis. Add the lighter weight, and overall quality, and I don't feel much a Juice offers me anything over a SAK. That said, I do carry my CX in my EDC bag, just in case.

-
You persuaded me, I'll stick with my SAKs and my Surge will help with the heavy duty stuff.
Cupboard, according to the Swiss Army Knife Owner's Manual, T. Leatherman was invited by C. Elsener to help th design and manufacture their Swisstools.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


