Pricey
-
So, you're happy...you had not invest on Victorinox SAKs? The Pioneer Damascus 2010 new retails for around $225 as limited edition, that's over $500 of profit! Has Wenger SAKs increased or kept their value over the past fews years? I'd be extremely happy if my collection were to increase in value, that makes as a smart investment!
I understand your points.
However, I never considered collecting SAK's an "investment" at all ..... the lower is the price the better for me, as I don't have plans to resell them.
Given also the fact that Wenger is way less popular and that there is much less interest by collectors comparing to Victorinox, I would not consider it a smart investment at all! ;)
My biggest purchase was for the Victorinox Battle Series Set, when I started collecting and before my "Wenger only" addiction.
Should I really need money... I will ask Reinier to sell my set! :D -
::)

So, you're happy...you had not invest on Victorinox SAKs? The Pioneer Damascus 2010 new retails for around $225 as limited edition, that's over $500 of profit! Has Wenger SAKs increased or kept their value over the past fews years? I'd be extremely happy if my collection were to increase in value, that makes as a smart investment!
I understand your points.
However, I never considered collecting SAK's an "investment" at all ..... the lower is the price the better for me, as I don't have plans to resell them.
Given also the fact that Wenger is way less popular and that there is much less interest by collectors comparing to Victorinox, I would not consider it a smart investment at all! ;)
My biggest purchase was for the Victorinox Battle Series Set, when I started collecting and before my "Wenger only" addiction.
Should I really need money... I will ask Reinier to sell my set! :DI'd not thought of resell or as an investment, but if a SAK increase his value over time by collecting, that's good thing too. Maybe that Pioneer Damascus could have got you couples of Wengers of your wanted list in some trades. Sometimes even if you're rich, you have the money for the stuffs you really want but I guess you can't have everything you want...
-
As far as the accumilation in value, that certainly says something for the brand

As for the going price of that damascus Pioneer, I <u>would not</u> pay that if I were a millionaire, just on principal. I'm perfectly happy with the black scale Pioneer and stainless steel blade :D
-
@sawman said:
As far as the accumilation in value, that certainly says something for the brand
As for the going price of that damascus Pioneer, I <u>would not</u> pay that if I were a millionaire, just on principal. I'm perfectly happy with the black scale Pioneer and stainless steel blade :D
This is the thing. 'Damascus' steel isn't real damascus of days of old, which people think it is. That was made with a special type of ore, which is no longer available. Current 'damascus' is pattern welding, where two metals with a different colour are folded repeatedly to get the classical look. But whereas if those metals are specifically chosen for their hardness and flexibility criteria, you would get a superior blade, I am sure for these types of knives, they are chosen for their look, and ease of manufacturing.
Moral of the story: current day damascus looks cool, but its fake. So pay what you would for a decorative item, but don't expect it to function like real damascus.
-
+1 Well said.
For performance the regular Vic steel is excellent.
-
I would expect the steel in the damascus Vics, which is Damasteel, to be superior to the wootz steel of old in pretty much every aspect. Metallurgy isn't magic. One of the better theories about wootz steel I've read, is an experiment where they discovered they could use the patterns to read the temperature of the blade when forging, thus getting extra control. (Don't remember who did the experiment, guy is an ABS master smith who's written a lot for Blade. He likes to make differentially hardened blades in 52100, often ram's horn in the handle. Anybody remember who I'm thinking of?) Temperature control which is a given in a competent industrial blade production line. So wootz would be a primitive carbon steel competently heat treated. Which would be pretty smurfing great in an era where temperature control boiled down to the experience of the smith.
Damasteel is actually a pretty nice stainless powder steel, PMC-27 and RWL-34. Damasteel is a trademark of the Swedish company which developed the product, not a generic shortcut for damascus pattern forged steel. (Esp. since it's not even forged. :) )
-
::)
-
English version of the text included with 2010 Damascus Pioneer reads:
There are only 2,010 of these special Damascus knives in the whole world. Congratulations, you now own one of them!
Damascus steel - the fine steel of the swordsmith
Damascus steel represents craftsmanship that goes back more than a thousand years. Even in antiquity, a few resourceful swordsmiths knew how to create blades of unusual toughness and hardness from different kinds of steel. The multiple folding and forge welding led to a homogenization of the material, and required a great deal of skill and dedication. Then as now, the crowning highlight in the production of a Damascus blade was the finish. Because only the grinding, polishing and etching reveals the characteristic pattern, and thereby provides a glimpse into the soul of the steel. (The blade of this knife is manufactured from stainless high quality Damascus steel, 60 HRc)http://swissbiancocanada.com/Newsletter/Articles/SwissBianco-Damascus-Pioneer.htm
-
And, that's typical marketroid speak, I agree. Doesn't change the fact the blade is Damasteel. The same page as you refered to confirms that as well.
http://damasteel.com/?page_id=194 has the data sheets, it's obviously martensitic Damasteel we're talking about.
If you want to discuss the matter instead of just rolling your eyes, please do.
-

http://www.edcsource.com/111688,auction_id,auction_details

Purchased in Mar 18 2012 $189.99, in Jan 29 2013 Buy Out for $79.99. Value dropped $110 for both New in Box clearly marked "ASTRONAUT".
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login