SAKs vs Juices
-
@50ft-trad said:
One of my earlier posts not long after joining was a head-to-head between a Victorinox Deluxe Tinker and Leatherman Juice CS4 HERE and my views haven't changed much :) However, I often carry a SAK along with a pliers tool, and chose which to carry of each to compliment each other as well as possibleYep, remember that all too well. I had a Deluxe Tinker on the way within 48 hours of reading that..... :) I will have to say that I much prefer SAKs over the Juice line. I think the Juice is a great idea whose execution was sub-par. My S2 was underwhelming to me, and painful! Those damn stabby screwdrivers.... The S2 was rapidly replaced by the combination of my Octane and a SAK, which lately has been overtaken by the Balance and a SAK. I'm not adverse to pocket size tools, I just couldn't get along with the Juice.
-
Engineered by Vic. , the Juice could have been a world class catch all !
The concept has potential , the execution is not good .
Chris
-
I do that. But it multitools are our hobby also, so we like to talk, think and imagine about them. That's all. And by vs I don't mean war. Competition and exchange of ideas mostly.
Well tool wise I do like the S2, but the steel is not anywhere near as good. If it was 440c instead of rust prone 420hc it might be higher on my like list.
My biggest complaint about the Juice line has always been the crappy blades they have. Not only are they weirdly shaped to conform to the shape of the body of the tool, they're made of crappy steel with a crappy grind pattern IMHO. I won't use the blade in either my S2 or my CS4 unless I don't have anything else available. They won't hold and edge much at all, if you don't end up rolling the edge on it that is...

I agree about the quality of the other implements; not as good as a Vic or Wenger. The scissors on both my Juices work acceptably; not great, but they generally do what I put them to. In general, I don't need pliers on a day to day basis, so a SAK covers me for 95% of what I come across on a daily basis. Add the lighter weight, and overall quality, and I don't feel much a Juice offers me anything over a SAK. That said, I do carry my CX in my EDC bag, just in case.

-
You persuaded me, I'll stick with my SAKs and my Surge will help with the heavy duty stuff.
Cupboard, according to the Swiss Army Knife Owner's Manual, T. Leatherman was invited by C. Elsener to help th design and manufacture their Swisstools. -
Ah, never heard that before!
I'd thought the SwissTools came from Bear, but that's only based on the wiki.
-
@kkokkolis said:
But then, I don't see many Juices or Squirts around. The Leatherman shop in Greece (that sells Gerbers and Victorinox, we also have a SOG shop that sells Victorinox and dozens of shops that sell Victorinox alone) has all the big tools but neither Juice or Squirt.
Why is that?Easy answer, price... For example, Squirt PS4's local price is 10€ higher than Craftsman...

Vics are 10%-20% more expensive in Greece than their price in US, Leathermans are 100%-200% more expensive than their price in US. :o So, they are not really competitive in the local market.
-
Hmm... Not much love for the Juice line here. :P I've generally felt the Juice line was quite good, with a few nitpicks here and there. I think the drivers work well, especially the Phillips, the pliers are substantial, and the file and saw are great IMO. The knives are a bit unusual, but I've always gotten along just fine with them, though they of course aren't the thin slicers that you'd find on a SAK. All in all I think they are a great concept, done reasonably well.
My biggest gripe is the ubiquitous corkscrew.

I've also never fallen in love with the SAK line, as nice as they are, so I guess I'm just in the minority here.

-
NE I like the Juice line quite well. My personal preference is for the Juice over a SAK. There was a time I was not very fond of the Juice line but I have come to appreciate them especially the KF4. :D
-
I honestly never really liked the looks of the juices...
But then again, never handled one, so what do I know? Also, the fact that a S2 costs 90 EURO's around here
doesn't really help... Let alone the 140 euro's for a XE6... 
-
I bought a Juice thinknig it would be the last EDC tool I will every carry.
Aside from the pliers, I didnt really like the rest of the tools on it.I'll have to say that I think the idea of it is amazing, but as everyone on here has said, I also wish it had better quality tools. Mainly for the scissors and the blade.
Now I carry a Victorinox Compact and a Leatherman Mini-tool. Makes for a great EDC combo for what I need. I sometimes add the stanley 4-1 screwdriver pen, or the countycomm screwkeys.
-
I want to add a proviso to my comments above. I don't hate the Juices; I wouldn't have traded my CT34 to the Capt. for his CS4 if I didn't like them. I just find Vics to be a better fit for my general EDC needs.
That said, I find the best use for the Juices that I have to be with my camping and outdoor supplies. I keep my S2 with my day-hiking hydration pack that I also have set up as a PSK. I've recently changed out my modded 111mm Hunter for my PER RangerGrip 179 in that pack, and the S2 complements the 179 very well; almost no tool overlap, and the pliers are definitely handy for doing things like getting a needle through tough materials for wilderness repairs to packs, clothing, etc. I also like to keep my CS4 in my larger "Adventure Pack" that I use for camping, short backpacking trips, and the like, as a back-up to the 111mm SAK I keep in it.
I think Juices would be awesome tools if Leatherman took the time to redesign them so they weren't saddled with some poorly designed implements, and offered models with options like better blades, and so on.
-
Like others have already posted in some countries Juices are a lot more expensive than SAKs. On amazon.co.uk a Swiss Champ is £42.29; a Juice Xe6 is £114.95 :ahhh
I like the Juice range, especially when teamed with a bit adaptor, but over here Vic are better value, unless you need the bigger piers that is.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login