SAK Phillips Functionality
-
@NutSAK said:
I like your test. I would be willing to send you a Victorinox SAK with an inline phillips driver for temporary use in testing.If you do that, I would like to suggest that you add #1 phillips screws to the test.
Thanks for the kind offer NutSAK, but I'm not sure it'd be worth the effort to send a SAK back and forth for this purpose. Besides if I do damage or break a SAK while testing, then I'd rather it be one of my own. Eventually I'll probably be getting a Wenger S557 and then I'll be able try out its inline driver.
I did do a little testing on some No. 1 Phillips woodscrews out on the deck. Results:
-The can opener drivers couldn't break any of the No. 1 screws loose, but did bugger up a few while trying. (All of those No. 1 screws were put in using an electric drill, so it's really no surprise they won't loosen up with just a can opener driver.)
-The T-style drivers could loosen roughly half of the No. 1, and didn't bugger up any.
-The Buck X-Tract driver could loosen all of the No. 1 that I tried, and didn't bugger up any.
I also tried a few No. 3 woodscrews. As expected, none of the SAKs nor the Buck X-Tract could even begin to break them loose. (I put those big No. 3 screws in using an electric drill that really tightened them down.)
.
-
Good thorough test mate, thanks :)
-
Thanks for posting the test results I ahve nothing to comment on except that my swisschamp phillips saw a recent work out while decorating the bathroom and I had no problems shifting some screws that haven't moved since flares were in style
I will now have to get another new SAK just to compare it with.Cheers Mate you gave me a great excuse /reason to buy another SAK -
Nice write up, I like hearing tests like this. SAK's really are pretty darn handy and pretty durable.
Many years ago I used nothing but a Tinker to take down and dismantle some cabinets in a lab I worked in. One of the doctors asked why I didn't just go find the department toolbox. I said if anyone knew where the darn thing was, I would have. ::) The Tinker got the job done no problem. The screws I couldn't reach with the T-style Phillips were taken care of with the can opener Phillips.
Mike
-
@jock1 said:
Thanks for posting the test results I ahve nothing to comment on except that my swisschamp phillips saw a recent work out while decorating the bathroom and I had no problems shifting some screws that haven't moved since flares were in style
I will now have to get another new SAK just to compare it with.Cheers Mate you gave me a great excuse /reason to buy another SAKYeah, you obviously need to get a SAK with one of the T-style drivers just for comparison.
Seriously though - a T-style driver will probably let you apply a tad more torque to the screw than you'll get with an inline driver.
.
-
@mike said:
Many years ago I used nothing but a Tinker to take down and dismantle some cabinets in a lab I worked in. One of the doctors asked why I didn't just go find the department toolbox. I said if anyone knew where the darn thing was, I would have. ::) The Tinker got the job done no problem. The screws I couldn't reach with the T-style Phillips were taken care of with the can opener Phillips.Mike
The Tinker does have amazing capability for a smaller, two-layer SAK!
My EDC Tinker has saved the day many times over the years, and I've usually been quite happy with the performance of its T-style Phillips driver. Occasionally I encounter a Phillips that its T-style driver won't reach, but that's fairly rare.
These days it seems I encounter far more recessed Phillips in plastic cases for which the Tinker T-style works great.
.
-
Ringzero, do you have a Swisstool Spirit?
The phillips driver on the Spirit is machined exactly the same as the inline phillips found on SAKs. You could substitute that driver in your test.
-
The S557 is also a great choice to test on, as you will also get to see Wenger's patented pressure lock in action as well. When you put pressure on the screw, the driver slides "into" the knife handle, locking it open. You didn't mention experiencing any of the other types folding on your fingers, but trust me, that is a very unpleasant experience.
When selecting a SAK knowing I will likely encounter stubborn screws, I always reach for a Wenger model (or locking multi) for this reason.
Def
-
@NutSAK said:
Ringzero, do you have a Swisstool Spirit?The phillips driver on the Spirit is machined exactly the same as the inline phillips found on SAKs. You could substitute that driver in your test.
No, unfortunately I don't have a Spirit. For a long time I couldn't decide between a Spirit or a Swisstool.
Then I got a SOG Powerlock, so I figure I'm set for heavy duty multis and should get a smaller, medium duty multi.
So, a Spirit is probably next on my list of multitool aquisitions.
.
-
@Defender said:
The S557 is also a great choice to test on, as you will also get to see Wenger's patented pressure lock in action as well. When you put pressure on the screw, the driver slides "into" the knife handle, locking it open. You didn't mention experiencing any of the other types folding on your fingers, but trust me, that is a very unpleasant experience.When selecting a SAK knowing I will likely encounter stubborn screws, I always reach for a Wenger model (or locking multi) for this reason.
Def
Yeah. Since I got the Wenger Taskmate, I've come to appreciate several of the Wenger features.
Taskmate has a locking slothead driver, which is a great feature indeed!
Also, I have come to appreciate its old-school, razor-sharp can opener for slicing open blister packs, cardboard packages, etc. Works great for slicing packaging where over-penetration and possible damage to contents is a concern. Also great for those "nasty" cutting jobs where you want to spare the main blade to avoid damage.
Taskmate still has the non-locking T-style Phillips, but I've never really had a T-style Phillips fold up and damage my fingers while in use.
Anyways, the S557 does look like a really capable SAK and I want to try out its Wenger Universal Wrench!
.
-
yes, the phillips on the swiss toll is amazing. I beleive it is the inline you refer to?
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login