Normal folders
-
His best arguement was a video from YouTube that he found, of two guys destroying a cheap airsoft gun with Strider knives, is was mostly just them taking turns stabbing it.
He told me I could never do that with a Victorinox, because it would fold in on me.
So I had to find a new wasteful activity. ;) :o
-
At least you could take apart the airsoft gun with a swisschamp and then put it back together.
-
Thought I'd revive this thread, as I've still not altered my opinions, but a lot of prominant members have been carrying single bladed folders of late, so I guess there's leg's in this discusion yet :)
-
I have been carrying a folder for quite a while now. I find a OH blade to be very handy, so I carry either a Boker Subcom or a Spyderco Pride. The Spyderco gets caried a lot more than the Boker as it is a legal EDC.
I always carry one with a SAK and MT though and would never chose it if for some reason I could only carry 1 item. I just find it a handy addition to my EDC's.
-
With the exception of carrying my Spyderco occasionally I haven't carried a regular folder for years. My SAK's and MT's have been able to handle everything I've needed them too. Crime is pretty low in my area so I don't worry about needing a "fighting knife".
-
I'm pretty well the same- the Skeletool isn't much larger than many tactical folders, and does much more. I use screwdrivers, scissors, cap lifters and so on more often than the blade, so a folder with a blade and nothing else isn't much use to me.
Def
-
It is hard to see why you'd carry a folding knife solo, paired witha Sak or MT I can can see the point, but I'd say the Wave/Charge Oht/120mm Wenger's to name a few have rendered the tactical folder obsolete :)
-
A <u>dedicated</u> <u>one hand</u> <u>locking</u> folder with a <u>clip</u> is a darn good thing to have at hand. I always carry one, plus a SAK or multitool, and I find they get out of the pocket into action about the same number of times, for different purposes. Reaching into a pocket (with one hand) and opening a blade with a fingernail (the other hand) just to open a letter of a bag of chips is too much time consuming. I find the one hand capability very important, not for SD but for speed, ease and safety. Besides, the blade on a dedicated folder is usually a lot stronger than on most SAKs/MTs. Even a modest Delica or Mini-Grip will outperform the blade on a Charge or OHT in every aspect (ergonomics also play a role here).
My priority in EDC goes like:
0. Watch and wedding ring (only objects I sleep and shower with)- Knife
- Light
- SAK/MT
Of course, I always carry at least one of each... plus (most of the time) glasses, pen, cell phone, keys, wallet and some clothes and shoes...
-
@crocodilo said:
My priority in EDC goes like:
0. Watch and wedding ring (only objects I sleep and shower with)- Knife
- Light
- SAK/MT
My priority is
- Cane
- Wallet
- SAK or multi-tool(lately my new Fieldmaster)
- Cell phone
- Lighter
- My keys(if I'm driving, which is rare)
I didn't count my wedding ring because I never take it off so I don't consider it EDC.
-
I'm 30% mall ninja, so I'm required to carry both (two spydercos, a sak, and a multi).
-
I used to carry those "Tactical Folders", but now I carry SAK/multis due to the fact that I'm at an age I don't forsee me being involved in any forms of bloodsoaked mayhem

-
I'm going to have to agree with Micky and Def, I find myself carrying my regular folders less and less now.
I really like the versatility of my OHT and other SAKs. Why carry just a single folding blade?A dedicated folder does not out perform my OHT for EDC.
A dedicated folder may have speed and more strength, but I'd rather have a fixed blade for that.I've gone to the dark side with Micky and Defender! :ahhh
-
I'm not sure why are you guys calling them "tactical knives". Just because they have one hand opening doesn't make them tactical, they are still just simple pocket knives. Heck my EDC, spyderco centofante 3, is advertised as a gentleman's knife.
-
MT all the way!!!
-
I like normal folders, especially one-hand open/close models. The wide variety of steels, blade types and handle shapes/materials has always been an attraction for me. Weight is another issue, the lightest full-size multi cannot be clipped to a shirt pocket comfortably but I can carry some quite large folders this way without any weight issues. Couple this with the fact that I am left-handed and there has yet to be a multitool that is truly accommodating of this quirk, normal folders will probably remain a staple of my pocket forever.
Now, I see quite clearly the disparity in utility between the typical folder and the typical SAK/Multi. I would be quite cheesed off should I become stranded on a desert island with just my folder, although I suppose I could carve a PST out of a coconut or something if I got really desperate.
For most people I know a good SAK/MT would serve them much better than a regular pocket knife. They just don't carry them, I think weight and lack of sexiness are the main issues in my little circle of associates. I shall continue to ring the multi bell to all I meet but I continue to note a lack of success.
-
I think it depends on what activity you are engaged in. While Multi Tools do lots of things well they are not always the best tool for the job. When I'm doing landscape work I'm much more likely to have a pair of pruners or a fixed blade on my belt rather than a MT. I agree that for EDC a good MT is a great solution when you don't know what the day will bring.
-
I'm a multitool man all the way, but I do sometimes find myself wanting a budget folder or fixed blade that I can (ab)use. Otherwise, I've never come across something to cut where I've wished I had a good folder. The blade on my Wave is fast enough and easy enough for me.
-
Oh I guess I forgot to add that 6 out of 7 days you will find a Benchmade clipped to my pocket. Sure there is a MT on my person as well but for sheer cutting stuff it's hard to beat a good one hand folder.
-
All multi-tools are a compromise, they do no job as good as a dedicated tool would. Even more so if you spent the same money for each of those separate tools. For the price though you can have a lot of reasonable tools in a package.
All folders are not tactical even if the manufacturer call them that to help sell them or the press state they are to sell their copy. Most even if used by the militry are just used as a civilian would and not tactical not unless you use the term 'to tactically open a letter'. :P They are a useful tool, many made with blade shapes made of steels not available in multi-tools and never will be. Size and cost stops it. The UK Spyderco I EDC is used every day, because the blade although ?short? enough to be UK legal is made of S30V steel and is (thanks to the hole for one hand opening) deep with a flat grind so is as useful in the kitchen as it is in the field. Because it is of such a simple design it is very easy to keep clean. It is used for every thing I have to cut, except at mealtime (it is often then in the washing up) where I use a normal knife and fork (a spoon sometimes :) ). The CRKT Edgie is as useful with, because of the way the single grind is auto sharpened a micro serrated edge that is great for slicing tomato's and other soft skinned fruits and meat (it only has a 440c blade though and I worry about cleaning it because of the slim sharpener in the handle).
The way the Spiderco was designed gives it another advantage in a country that frowns on locking blades there is a finger coil at the blade/handle hinge that makes just holding the knife to cut something a blocking (not locking) mechanism to stop the blade folding in on your fingers.
The knife on my multi is only used if I am already using the tool for something else.Dave
-
@micky d said:
Hi guys,Do any of the member's here feel the same way I do about conventional folders?
I mean I look at a nice spyderco or benchmade or even a boker ect ect, and I think that's a very nice knife but how will it open a tin of bean's, or tighten that screw in the bathroom that keep's working it's way loose Or a host of other jobs that a multi or sak would take in there stride? ???
It's got to the point where I haven't bought a normal folding knife for about 3 YEARS :o
So am I the only one who's been permanatly tainted by multi's and sak's, or is there room in your heart's for both?
cheers :)
Several years back I got my first pocket-clipped, one-hand-opening folder.
Lowes had the Gerber AR 3.0 marked down to half-price and even threw in a free Gerber pocket diamond sharpener along with the knife. At the time I didn't think I needed another knife, but it was too good a deal to pass up.
I carried and used that Gerber AR3.0 for a while. I got spoiled by the convenience of always being able grab the knife without having to dig down in my pocket, and being able to cut things quickly and easily with just ONE HAND.
Ever since then, I don't like being without some sort of one-hand-opening knife clipped to my pocket.
I really couldn't care less if it's 'tactical' or has a 'super steel' blade. I'm about as happy carrying my $8 Kobalt folding razor knife as a $75 Benchmade or Spyderco.
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login