Is the Multitool.org icon wrong?
-
Odd that you should say something about more common tools. There are more versions of the MP 600 than any other tool on the market.
Right or wrong though this logo has been established over many years and I don't see it changing anytime soon. I hate it when companies change their logo.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Odd that you should say something about more common tools. There are more versions of the MP 600 than any other tool on the market.Right or wrong though this logo has been established over many years and I don't see it changing anytime soon.** I hate it when companies change their logo.**
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
I hate change !!! and i hate it more the older i get

-
I didn't ask it to change, just noticed the Multitool's geometry. Also, I didn't know that Gerbers are so common on the other side of the Atlantic. On the other hand I am very new here (although moderately old on the face of the earth) so I can understand how much accustomed the older members are to this graphic. Symbols doesn't have to be naturalistic. Usually they are stylized. Islamic flags are totally wrong in an astronomical way as there is no way a star could be visible in front of moon disc (crescent lighting doesn't mean the rest of the moon isn't there) but it would be ridiculous to change their symbolism now (not to mention a potential world war).
I like changes but only bloodless ones. -
I dont think how the tool is open or closed is noticed by many, I sure didnt.
Its too late now but if I was around back in the early days the reason I would have suggested for change is that it looks like an i. Before I was a regular here I tried to look up this site a few times and I was sure it was iMultoool.org At a quick glance at a logo thats what it looks like. Too late now and not a huge deal, just something I remember from when I first found this site.
-
I was just about to say that some poor bugger thought it was iMultitool.org for a while there! I'm glad you chimed in because I couldn't recall who it was that had said that!
I think, if I recall correctly we tried to make the multitool look like the typical plier based tool, but without making it look like a specific plier based tool. We didn't want it to look like any specific tool so that folks wouldn't think we were biased towards anything is, this wasn't going to be a fan boy site where everything was compared unfavorably to a Spirit or PST.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
Looks like a generic tool to me.... and why is this in the feedback forum?!
-
No problem. We should perhaps move it to General so more folks see it.
Def
Sent from my Motorola Atrix digital multitool.
-
done
-
I have to say, I thought much the same as kkokkolis, that the tool looked... if not 'wrong', at least 'weird'.
I think this is because in my mind, the Leatherman PST is the symbolic plier-based MT.
I don't have a problem with the logo, it's just one of those things that crossed my mind at some point.
-
the 'tool' looks 'Wrong' ??? yet the bodyless yellow head holding the holding the five foot tall multi doesn't look 'odd' ?

-
As an icon, I'd say it's not wrong at all ... it's clearly a representation of a pliers based multitool. What more do we need? Does it need to be accurate to a specific model - no, and in my mind the site owner wisely opted for impartiality in that respect. Good thing for me really - if it wasn't for Grant's desire to have an open discussion taking all tools on their own merit instead of the narrowmindedness that plagues other parts of the net, my scepticism towards certain commercial entities and their commercial methodologies would probably have gotten my butt hauled out of here long ago :D :D
Is it the perfect icon? Well it does look a little pinchy, so maybe not one I'd carry, but so long as it has scissors and an awl I'm sure it'll be fine

-
Wisely? I'm sure my wisdom is open to a very unflattering debate! I think we were just lucky in the early days and now we're pointing back at what went accidentally right and saying "see? We knew what we were doing!"
Wink wink nudge nudge.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
Don't get me wrong mate, I didn't mean it as a universal statement :P
You were bound to get one right eventually :D :D
-
Do enough things and eventually one won't be completely wrong.... :D
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
Some additional info... At smaller sizes it's much harder to tell the details of the tool icons. When I started doing/redoing some of the MTo graphics the logo was already established, and Grant didn't want to change it much, so I maintained it as much as possible but cleaned/modified it slightly... before it was more like this on the MTo wiki:
vs my cleaned up version here without a solid shadow as it's on a dark background, and therefore a bit redundant:

I also thought it was a good idea to integrate the tool part of the logo as icons where ever possible... hence the read status icons:

and some of the member badges:

They all use the tool graphic that is part of the original logo, all I've done in most cases is change some colours, the outer border width and add some bevelling to make it look 3D.
-
....and I like it...

-
You will notice as well that while the position of the handles may look very similar to the Gerber MP600, the logo icon very clearly has two rivets at the head end, showing that it is in fact a butterfly opener, not a sliding head, thereby differentiating us from being too "Gerber-esque" as well. All in all I think we achieved what we were going for by making it indicative of all multitools without being too close to any of them.
Def
-
here is a blown up version of the logo tool:

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login