SAK vs. Leatherman
-
If you're after a basic SAK for camping, 2 models spring to mind. If you want a saw, go for the huntsman. If not, go for the climber :). I realise these are a bit bigger than you mentioned but you need decent tools when you're camping.
-
I agree as most smaller sak-multi's won't be much help camping,possibly a vic farmer or a vic huntsman,both cover most tasks including sawing,personally I would get something like a leatherman p4/ps4 or micra or vic tinker for urban edc and a huntsman or leatherman wave for camping,or a gak
. Welcome to mto 
-
I have a slightly heathen confession to add here... I bought a LM Supertool 200 a few years ago. The joint in the pliers went loose after a week basically in my pocket! Since then I've not been a huge fan of Leathermans.
Victorinox SAKs on the other hand are beautiful quality. Mmm... a Swisstool... I ca hear the bank crying from here :D.
-
Hi LL,welcome to MTo.
The guys are pretty much right.Because SAKs are relatively cheap,you can have mission specific knives.For urban use,a SuperTinker,or a DeluxTinker or a Explorer are close to perfect.For the outdoors,couldn't fault the guys,Farmer or Huntsman :tool:
-
Just 58 mm, many functions and for mostly urban use?
Somehow, the MiniChamp springs to mind here... -
Since you already have a Manager, i.e. a Rambler with pen (BTW, it's missing what, tweezers or toothpick :D
? ) the Minichamp is your other main option IMO too. For an urban EDC I think it's hard to beat the Vic 91mm Climber/Mountaineer models. Lately, I found out that apart from the Deluxe Tinker there's also the Deluxe Climber -the latter is discontinued though. Those are a lil' thick but could be worth considering. My two cents... (And welcome. I think here you'll find many good answers and a lot more good questions
) -
I carry a climber but it's not my fantasy SAK. I didn't think that existed 'til I saw the deluxe climber
. I then found out it would be easier to buy a packet of chicken's teeth
. -
Just get a swisschamp and all bases are covered

-
There are so many options really. No one has mentioned the Executive yet, which is the right size for what you mentioned. However, it doesn't have 10 tools/functions (although it comes close). The other options mentioned so far are not bad either, as long as you don't mind the longer and thicker models.
-
I agree with the chaps here:SAKs are cheaper than Leatherman tools and you can even get 2 SAKs for the price of a Leatherman.
For camping, I would suggest the Swiss Soldier 08. It has a locking blade, a saw and the openers. On the backside, there is an awl and a phillips screwdriver. Be aware that it is 111 millimeters in length and lacks the tweezes and toothpick.If you want a regular-size(91 mm) SAK for camping only, go for Climber.
For urban use, I suggest either Climber or Compact. Both have a good pair of scissors.The question here is if you want a pen or a small blade. If you want a pen, the Compact is your choice. If the small blade, then go with Climber.
Bare in mind that Climber has 3 tool layers while Compact has 2. If you do not want scissors, Spartan or Tinker.(Depends on if you want a corkscrew or a backside phillips).If you want something in between, get the Huntsman as others said.
By the way, welcome to MTO.

-
I carry my Climber almost everyday, but I also usually carry some sort of MT. I find a PST is a great compliment to the Climber.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
-
just get the best 1st and get a victorinox spirit.
I know its not exactly what you said you're looking for but you'll still thank me later. =)also get some victorinox alox tools...again...you'll thank me later. lol
-
Decided on a victorinox Signature and LT PS4
-
You will end up with multiple SAK's , another good smallish one to think about is the "Tinker Small ".
Chris
-
Whilst my collection of SAK's is greater than my Leatherman, I have to say that the leatherman 'Micra' is usually on my keyring.
This does not mean to say that Leatherman is better, but IMHO the micra makes an excellent keychain model, I used to have a variety of SAK's on my keyring, but the scales always ended scratched, as the micra is stainless steel. It is the right size and has ten functional tools
Spring-action Scissors
Nail File
Nail Cleaner
Tweezers
420HC Knife
Extra-small Screwdriver
Medium Screwdriver
Flat/Phillips Screwdriver
Ruler (4.7 in / 12.0 cm)
Bottle OpenerAt the end of the day, it is an individual choice, although I chose the micra for my key ring, the best multitool out there [for me] is the swisstool.
Viva SAK's

-
Although I am more of a SAK person, I love my Micra too. If you do not want a pen and light, go for Micra. If you do, a Victorinox Middnite Manager is your best bet.
-
I think some variation of a Spirit is hard to beat
-
For urban EDC, I have these:
Climber
Sportsman
CadetDepending on your needs, you might consider any of these or a Compact. Try making a list of situations where you thought "Man, I could really use a SAK right now!" That will give you the list of tools. Go to Vic's site and use the SAK selector to find which one has them!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
