Geek SAK
-
What Syph & Metro do to their tools are mods, imo at least. If one charges upwards of $300 for a swapping of tools I doubt that would be considered simple half and hour task. They have the task-specific tools to do them conversions, so yeah I would say for someone that only possesses limited knowledge and tools could <u>not</u> replace tools with such ease, and for them to be fully functional too.
This work you cannot just buy from a retailer and slap into your SAK without some knowledge & tools, least I would think. Not sure I would even feel comfortable attempting any knife mod without working with spare junkers before attempting something beneficial or suitable for bragging rights.
In comparison to the handmade custom scales that I derived from blocks of wood into Plus scales; working with old plastic scales, drawings, pictures, and a lot of help from the forum to make something that I otherwise had no idea what it looked like - still don't see it as a mod. That was more of customizing or accessorizing, and even put a Vic emblem in them. Hour wise, yeah, over a week and lots of work. Even altered them again, ground a thumb groove making it easier to open the corkscrew.
Could have bought the scales far cheaper than what it cost to make them, but I wanted a certain wood that no one else would make from. Scales can be plain, carved, or contain scale tools that are available perty much anywhere if not looking for a specific type of material. Those can be obtained without much effort, if not looking for a specific material.
Now if the scales popped out and became a camera tripod, turning the SAK into an assault crossbow, would fling string beans across the room to wake up a snoring pooch, would concentrate the suns rays into a portable solar furnace, or would form some otherwise specific duty then I could see that as a mod.
If you dress your lady friend or wife up in lingerie, a pretty dress, latex or leather, get her hair dyed red, that is accessorizing. Get her upgraded with a new set of hooters, a firm butt, and could make her purr - THAT is definitely a mod. :D

-
So how do we go seeing that this has "through the scales" exposed rivets and a hidden 4th pin. Also the scales are bonded to the side liners and the encapsulating resin flows round the sides and covers the edges of the liners... are we modding yet?
these are not a pair of clip on, clip off scales. To get them of you need a drill.
I have done knives with snap on scales in wood, bone and plastic. But most of my custom scales jobs are now done on knives that are broken down and rebuilt with new pins peened through the scales as exposed rivets. Often I use old knives with poor snap due to worn pivots. The new pins fixes that.
I guess you could say is more correctly customizing than modding. But it is the same as the difference between putting stick on pinstripes on a car and a full respray in candy red over gold base with 14 coats of clear. Almost any Joe can make a reasonable job of the former but you need a little more skill for the latter.
I don't mean to sound bitchy but I don't think the line is as clear as "mods involve changing tools"
-
Another grey area one...

technically it's just an Explorer, but the scales and side liners have been replaced with hand made ribbed aluminium side plates like an alox SAK.
mod or not mod?
-
@PTRSAK said:
I don't mean to sound bitchy but I don't think the line is as clear as "mods involve changing tools"That's it! English is not my first language, so it's difficult to express myself. But the statement above is what I wanted to say. :)
It's absolutely off topic now. But if there was a scale forum, we definitely would have difficulties to distinguish between "modding" and "customizing" and "scale change", since those words are sets which are overlapping. (I'm a computer scientist, thus half mathematician)
-
Well technically a mod is modifying something, or some part of something, usually in a way the original manufacture doesn't do (or doesn't want you to do). If you voided the warranty its for sure a mod! :D
-
Clip on scales I would think would not be customizing - as with everything I posted here was my in opinion. That is what is great here, many opinions, feedback, varied opinions - so as long one doesn't get their feathers ruffled. :D Where you had altered the knife structurally to attach them, then I would be consider it a mod. In contrast, the Australian Silky Oak scales I made I do not consider a mod as they can be removed without affecting the performance of the knife parts.
Removable scales that do not involve structurally modifying the knife, i.e. pin replacement, I would not consider a mod. Not unless the scales were structurally altered to perform something different than what common scales would. As if one put a miniature GPS unit into a scale, added a light or laser, then that is a scale mod for sure.
Guess I will coincide that the word mod is in the eye of the beholder & creator as to what they consider a mod.
Past that will try and not offer any further comments on other people's work.

Good night :)
@Syph007 said:
Well technically a mod is modifying something, or some part of something,** usually in a way the original manufacture doesn't do (or doesn't want you to do). If you voided the warranty its for sure a mod**! :D+1

-
Love the Geek SAK!
-
What I want to know is,
is the RAM upgradeable?:D
-
Think I have a small box of old memory chips, but those chips are stacked rather close together. Even have some SIMM memory cards (yikes!) laying around here too.
PTRSAK, clever used of the 4th hidden hole. Did not dawn on me, at first glance, yours was hidden. You have the talent, good sir. Maybe a new knife shop is in the works for a side business. :D Are there many modders in the Australian continent? Could be a hidden asset.
-
@Syph007 said:
If you voided the warranty its for sure a mod! :Dok... It seems we do have a simple. "black and white" definition of what is a mod.
and I wasn't complaining about anyone's comments... I was participating in the discussion. I even went to the trouble of saying that I wasn't being bitchy.
I respect anybody who willingly voids their warranty on anything by deliberately tinkering with it. I've been doing that all my life.

-
@PTRSAK said:
I respect anybody who willingly voids their warranty on anything by deliberately tinkering with it. I've been doing that all my life.
EXACTLY. Never assume the one who manufactures the product is the best able to make it the way you want it. They make it under money/market constraints, but when you tear it apart and build it anew, you can do whatever you want, even if its isnt financially viable on a large scale.
-
What's a forum without discussions? Yes, dead! ;)
I'm proud of voiding warranty of some knifes. Especially those with adding wood scales using epoxy. Want to see that service technican repairing a broken spring on such a knife. :-D
-
@HankSolon said:
What's a forum without discussions? Yes, dead! ;)I'm proud of voiding warranty of some knifes. Especially those with adding wood scales using epoxy. Want to see that service technican repairing a broken spring on such a knife. :-D
I'm waiting for the time when someone sends in their Syph torx pivot mod to Victorinox for a repair and Vic decides that they like the torx pivot so much that they start using them. Or they kidnap Syph and have him set up shop in Switzerland :P.
-
This is really interesting me. How did you apply the resin to the scales?
-
What's a forum without discussions? Yes, dead! ;)
I'm proud of voiding warranty of some knifes. Especially those with adding wood scales using epoxy. Want to see that service technican repairing a broken spring on such a knife. :-D
I'm waiting for the time when someone sends in their Syph torx pivot mod to Victorinox for a repair and Vic decides that they like the torx pivot so much that they start using them. Or they kidnap Syph and have him set up shop in Switzerland :P.
Or put a contract out on him...

-
Lets not forget +B first got noticed due to his damascus pioneer mod. Now he is against mods (at least on his forum).
Go figure
-
-
I've never really been sure about +B. IMHO, he's basically a modder with Victorinox endorsement. He can make whatever he wants as long as the design is approved by Victorinox so that the warranty can be enforced. Therein lies the rub for him I believe. If he's to stay in Vic's good graces, he couldn't officially support or endorse mods that involve modifying factory parts or combine parts from different knife frames (i.e., pliers/scissors on 93mm alox).
For him to go on any record and support such mods would likely put his status with Victorinox in jeopardy. In other words, knife builds that would not/could not be warrantied due to not being approved by Victorinox. For all we know, he might have a secret stash of Syph/tattoosteve/Bushido mods that he plays with every now and again.
-
Are you going to make a Geeky Compact model next, Pete? :D Or is that already in the works?
Wonder if scales could be made with exposed CMOS on a board, or even the various forms of solar cells.


Of course with solar cells a savvy developer could devise a scale LED light with a poly-lithium battery, solar cell, mini rectangular LED and switch all on one scale, and a fakey on the other side with maybe glow in the dark coating on the underside of a panel. If it could float above the attachment scale, could give off an eerie glow without distracting from the outer visual scale appearance.
Might be other substrates of a 3D formation that would look nerdy floating in a resin scale/handle. The possibilities are endless. or you could make a miniature aquarium-like scale, where things float around inside. That would be an interesting project, almost like a snow-globe in effect.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login