Executive blade pic request
-
Could someone with a Vic Executive, a 58mm SAK, and a 84mm SAK possibly post a photo showing the blades
of these knifes side by side? The first thing I'm wondering is if the small Executive blade is the same size as the main blade on the 58mm line. Next, I'm wondering how the length of the larger blade on an Executive compares to the main blade on a 84mm.I appreciate any assistance, folks.

-
The Executive is a great SAK, you should get one
:D I know, not the reply you're looking for ;) I'm holding my baby at the moment, so I can't post pics (although I don't have the 84mm to compare). -
The small 74 blade is smaller than the 58 blade, and the large 74 blade is vastly inferior to the 84 blade.
From Sakwiki ;)
If you think of the 84's as a slightly smaller 91, and think of the 74's as a slightly bigger 58's. The difference in performance and ability between the 74s and 84s is much bigger than the 10mm frame size might imply
-
Thanks, 50ft-trad.

Is the stock of the 74 thicker than the 58s, or the same?
-
@50ft-trad said:
the large 74 blade is vastly inferior to the 84 blade.What do you mean by vastly inferior?
The 74mm blade is obviously narrower than the 84mm but that can be a very positive characteristic when making curved cuts in stiff material like cardboad. Is the primary bevel of the 84 significantly less than that of the 74? If not, then slicing ability should be similar? Obviously the 74 is shorter than the 84 but not by a vast difference, especially when compared to the jump from 58 to 74.

-
@theonew said:
The 74mm blade is obviously narrower than the 84mm but that can be a very positive characteristic when making curved cuts in stiff material like cardboad.Agreed! I've found the main blade on my Exec to be the perfect blade for doing detailed carving; I used it extensively for the SAK pumpkin carving contest last fall! Was able to do some wonderful fine cutting with it. It's also far superior to the 58 mm blades for things like cutting tape, opening letters and boxes, and so on. If the Exec didn't have the small blade, I wouldn't even notice!
-
@50ft-trad said:
the large 74 blade is vastly inferior to the 84 blade.
What do you mean by vastly inferior?
The 74mm blade is obviously narrower than the 84mm but that can be a very positive characteristic when making curved cuts in stiff material like cardboad. Is the primary bevel of the 84 significantly less than that of the 74? If not, then slicing ability should be similar? Obviously the 74 is shorter than the 84 but not by a vast difference, especially when compared to the jump from 58 to 74.

To me it just feels weak, and I've never really had much confidence in it. Maybe just a perception thing

-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
the large 74 blade is vastly inferior to the 84 blade.
What do you mean by vastly inferior?
The 74mm blade is obviously narrower than the 84mm but that can be a very positive characteristic when making curved cuts in stiff material like cardboad. Is the primary bevel of the 84 significantly less than that of the 74? If not, then slicing ability should be similar? Obviously the 74 is shorter than the 84 but not by a vast difference, especially when compared to the jump from 58 to 74.

To me it just feels weak, and I've never really had much confidence in it. Maybe just a perception thing

Oh come on Al... you don't need me to remind you of the appropriate tool for the task meme...

The main blade on the Exec isn't nearly as dinky as the main blade of a 58, and it has its uses; just don't use it for a job it's not well suited for.

-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
the large 74 blade is vastly inferior to the 84 blade.
What do you mean by vastly inferior?
The 74mm blade is obviously narrower than the 84mm but that can be a very positive characteristic when making curved cuts in stiff material like cardboad. Is the primary bevel of the 84 significantly less than that of the 74? If not, then slicing ability should be similar? Obviously the 74 is shorter than the 84 but not by a vast difference, especially when compared to the jump from 58 to 74.

To me it just feels weak, and I've never really had much confidence in it. Maybe just a perception thing

Oh come on Al... you don't need me to remind you of the appropriate tool for the task meme...

The main blade on the Exec isn't nearly as dinky as the main blade of a 58, and it has its uses; just don't use it for a job it's not well suited for.

100% agree with you Paul, and therein lies the problem ....
The 58mm and Wenger 65mm are great for a keyring as back up blades for light work. The 84/85mm knives are great EDC blades which will do pretty much the bulk of what I'm liable to encounter away from work etc. The 74mm blade is kind of lost between the two. A bit too slender and delicate for what I want as a primary blade, but too big for a back up too.
I'm looking at my Director as I type this post. It's sat on my desk at home for quite a while as a lightweight desk knife. I could sharpen a pencil with it, or open mail, or assassinate a piece of fresh fruit ... absolutely I could ... but I feel much happier doing that with a sturdier blade. I am unlikely to break it by taking it past it's working limits ... but I'd rather have an 84mm and feel I can work without having to compromise and ease off a bit.
Love the Pocket Tool Chest, and love the 84s and 85s .... the 74's just seem ... you know what, if it wasn't a lobster pattern and was built more like a small framed Recruit or Cadet, I'd be a lot happier with it
EDIT: I think what I'm trying to say is the blade feels too long for it's width/rigidity. It oesn't feel flimsy - but kind of feels like it should do ...
... we're back to perception again :-\Lynn - see if you can borrow one for a bit ;)
-
@50ft-trad said:
EDIT: I think what I'm trying to say is the blade feels too long for it's width/rigidity. It oesn't feel flimsy - but kind of feels like it should do ...
... we're back to perception again :-\Yeah, I understand what you mean about that... And I agree; the 74 mm frame is a bit of an oddball because now that I think about it, it's small for a single sided design, but a bit large for the two sided design...
And, I admit, too, that the main blade is a bit small for anything other than envelopes, tape, etc. But, I like it for those tasks better than the 58mm blade, or even the 65mm blade on my Evo 88. I guess I'm just a little ham-handed, but the 58mm frame just feels too small to me and I've never liked it. The 65 is small as I'm comfortable with, and honestly, the main reason I carry my Evo 88 is for the cap lifter, the drivers, and the pointy-pokey bits, not the blade.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login