How much blade do you NEED?
-
Simple question. How much length and sturdiness do you really NEED?
I hear a good deal of 'the blade on X is too small', and I just keep wondering what it is people are doing that requires more cutting capability.
I had a SOG Crosscut for 15 years, and find the blade on that size tool is fine for virtually all of my cutting needs. Grated, I'm not out on a ranch or dock.
I find the blade on the 58mm SAK, while long enough, just seems too fragile. Not that I've ever had one break on me. They just don't inspire confidence.
Any SAK I've had, 84, 85, 91mm... all have more than enough cutting capability for me. And as for blade steel, I prefer 'easy to sharpen' over 'holds an edge'.
How 'bout you?
-
MOST of my 'cutting' needs comprise of string, plastic , carboard and the occasional 'zip-tie' therefore any blade will do.
IF i was to think i might need a proper knife , i would carry a propper knife. the same as any other tool ie. screwdriver/pliers
pocket tools (multi's/SAK's) are just for those just incase moments for me
that said i do like a big sharp blade .... just because ...not because i NEED one, it's a primal thing like poking a fire with a stick
- just like to add, i normally EDC a swisschamp (2 blades~ small + very small) covers me for most things. would be nice to have the larger blade OHO
-
I guess the large blade on the Pocket Pal covers what I can say I actually need. Any smaller, and it requires extra care to open a bag of coffee or something like that. As for sturdiness, I guess the Pocket Pal covers what I really need, once again, though I often prefer a heavier and stiffer design.
Blade steel? Anything which doesn't chip or break, while still holding an edge. :)
(The right steel for the right knife, in other words. For an EDC, DIN 1.4110, 12C27, Chipper, C75 and so on are fine steels in my opinion, so "easy to sharpen" over "holds an edge" here as well. I would probably say "doesn't chip" instead of "easy to sharpen", though.)
-
My 91mm Sak will fit some of my needs. Its is a smaller blade so i use it for smaller cutting task. My Sog Vulcan does the jobs where the vic blade is to small or not strong enough. also i tend to favor holds on edge over easy to sharpen to a point.
-
A blade around 8cm, like in the Opinel #8, Leatherman Surge or Victorinox Pioneer/ Harvester, is optimum. I don't care much for the steel, as long as it is , flexible and metal color (no BO). I never broke a blade and I had Swisschamps for a decade without sharpening.
For opening envelopes and packages any blade in my Minichamp will do. -
For everyday use I dont need a big blade. My Byrd Robin with a 48mm edge is more than good enough for most tasks.
When out in tbe woods or camping, I prefer a bigger blade, but you can get a lot done with just a classic mora sized blade. -
2.5in please :D I work and live around Chicago so to be a legal carry it needs to be 2.5in. Not 2.6in like most Leathermans includeing the Juice line, 91mm SAKs, Swisstools and SOGs. ugg.....
-
A Skeletool is big and sturdy enough for my needs. I think the Wave's blade size and shape is my favourite of all the things I own but I wouldn't want any bigger - my Core's is too long I think. My Spirit's just doesn't inspire as much confidence TBH. I really appreciate the lock after an incident with my Kick and a cable tie.
A 91mm SAK blade is plenty for non-locking use and I really like them for a lot of purposes. I agree with the point about the 58mm SAK, the Squirt's seems much more solid.
Obviously my kitchen knives are a completely different kettle of fish.
Being a bit narrow minded I can't see what you'd need a bigger knife for. Food prep has its own set of tools and if I wanted to attack a tree I'd use a proper saw and axe/hatchet.
As for steel, I'm happy enough with my Wave's. I've used it to cut some mild steel and whilst that did take a chunk out of the edge it got me out of a muddle and didn't take too long to put right.
-
I like to have at least 2.5"-3" , that said , on my EDC SAK the pen blade is the most used .
A 58mm would probably be OK , but the handle is too dinky for my big mits , kinda like why I don't dig single AAA lites .
Chris
-
i think alot of the blade size also has alot to do with hand sizes, shape of the blade etc. A 58mm sak can open a letter just as good as my 3.5 inch blade, but i have big hands which makes it hard to hold the little bugger. Some people carry a bigger blade when they can by with a small blade, but like to have a bigger blade when something big come up. And lets face, Its not so much about what you NEED as much as what you WANT. If I am going to spend good money on something, I am going to get what I want.
-
I don't want anything bigger than a 65mm Wenger on my keys, but most of the time I don't want anything less than an 84mm SAK or equivalent as my main blade. A lot of what I do in just opening a package or cutting string type jobs, and I've sharpened a pencil several times with a little keyring knife ... but they're no good for slicing an apple, or knocking down a cardboard box.
84mm Golfer or Tourist, or an 85mm Wenger is as small as I like to go without feeling "without"
-
My most used knife at work is my TattooSteve Alox,the Boxer.It only has a Vic pruner blade,so bout an inch and a half?
Thinking of doing a SAK mod dumping the big blade,as I so seldom use it!
As TaxiDad said,if I need a 'proper' knife,I'll bring a proper knife :D
-
Oh,and Lynn,we're still waiting for your rant about tactical folders

-
-
Why you no likey tac folders?

lol -
I find that my 91mm SAK blade is suited for most tasks, if I need a locking blade I always have a full size leatherman on me. I use the LM for "dirty" work and the SAK I try to keep clean so I can slice apples and stuff with it.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using crapatalk two point oh.
-
@50ft-trad said:
I've sharpened a pencil several times with a little keyring knife ... but they're no good for slicing an apple, or knocking down a cardboard box.I comprehensively destroyed a decent cardboard box with my Manager last night to create kindling for a fire, so I beg to differ on that point :)
-
That's A Knife - Crocodile Dundee (4/8) Movie CLIP (1986) HD
someone had to do it
-
A 91mm sak blade covers most jobs or my opie #6 more slicer jobs,if i need sharp its usually a opie as im crap at sharpening knives but oddly can get opies razor sharp,also can get sak sharp enough but struggle with LM's
:D UK laws don't help though so smaller is safer here :-\
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
