Leatherman OHT
-
Lol. I know what you mean!
-
I want to see one in the flesh before parting with any cash .
Chris
-
i just got one. Although I think black oxide looks cool (at least until it gets handled) I decided on coyote because I don't like the idea of my hands getting dirty from using the black oxide Leathermans, which I learned about thanks to this forum.
Turns out, although the scales aren't black oxide, the sides and all the tool surfaces ARE. So sure enough my hands were filthy after playing around with it which then soiled the coyote scales too. Luckily I was able to clean the scales and wipe down all the surfaces such that now it hardly sheds at all.
Can't they make some automated process do this for us before boxing it up?
-
I'm sure they could, but as LM ships well over a million tools/year. At 5 minutes extra per tool, that's a lot of money...
Def
-
Considering some of the individual polishing steps on some Leathermans takes 14 hours to complete and is done mostly robotically, 5 extra minutes doesn't seem like a lot, to me, versus the fewer customer complaints and returns from people who were unaware that the tools' black coating comes off on their hands.
-
I'd say if you aren't aware that BO can come off on your hands then you probably aren't someone who needs it.
Just sayin...
-
I'm of the mind the majority of their sales are to civilians, not the military, and their color selections are based on fashion/whims, not needs.
edit to add: There are 15 pages of reviews on Amazon for the Black Oxide Wave, and on just the first page of those appears these individual comments:
"as another person has mentioned, the finish on this tool is less than ideal. It comes off on your hands and anything you touch for the first week or two of use"
"However, herein lies its particularly annoying flaw. Right out of the box, the finishing coat on this tool left black smudges and marks all over my hands, especially where lubricant was applied. Now, overlooking the sissy/feminine jokes sure to come, that's just not okay with me, especially if those smudges transfer to whatever I'm working on"
"When you get your Leatherman Wave w/ Black Oxide finish ...you will get "Black Hands"..I mean the finish will rub off on to your hands."
"And the black color makes it look cool as well."
[THAT'S why people buy it!- mzil]"Someone mentioned that the black finish comes off ... and, yes, it does. I had the same problem with my TDI K-bar but once wiped down with a towel it's fine."
"The only slightly annoying thing about this tool is that it needs a good rubbing down when you first get it. The black oxide finish is kinda powdery when you first get it out of the box and rubs black stains into everything it touches."
-
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me. The people that complain about the BO finish leaving smudges on their skin might look upon their MT's as fashion statements not tools.
-
For me, the black stain in your hands is just part of the excitement. 8)
-
@MeadMaker said:
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me.Since their ability to leave black marks on your hands dimminishes over time/use, (but you don't see this smudging as a negative, if I understand correctly), does it upset you because when they reach the worn state of no longer shedding, since you feel they have lost some of their rust prevention coating?
-
@MeadMaker said:
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me. The people that complain about the BO finish leaving smudges on their skin might look upon their MT's as fashion statements not tools.Not sure i agree with that. I'm a building technician and use my MT every day, the idea that it would case me to leave black fingerprints all over a 5 star hotel would likely get me fired. :D
-
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me. The people that complain about the BO finish leaving smudges on their skin might look upon their MT's as fashion statements not tools.
Not sure i agree with that. I'm a building technician and use my MT every day, the idea that it would case me to leave black fingerprints all over a 5 star hotel would likely get me fired. :D
But if you take a new, or for matter an old, tool into a 5 star hotel don't you make sure it is clean so that it does not get you fired? I was once part of a project that included installing white carpet throughout a house. Believe me, I learned the value of keeping my tools and shoes clean on that job.
I recently bought a new 4" adjustable wrench to use as part of my bicycle EDC. It there was some oil on the head that was excess lubricant from the adjusting screw. I didn't complain about it, I just cleaned it off. Its a tool. Tools are often dirty or oily. If it had been a belt buckle, tie clasp or watch band that had stained my clothes I would probably have felt differently.
-
BO looks better if you wipe a new tool down with some light oil anyhow.. well in my opinion.. and in the process it removes some of the easy to wipe off BO.
-
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me. The people that complain about the BO finish leaving smudges on their skin might look upon their MT's as fashion statements not tools.
Not sure i agree with that. I'm a building technician and use my MT every day, the idea that it would case me to leave black fingerprints all over a 5 star hotel would likely get me fired. :D
But if you take a new, or for matter an old, tool into a 5 star hotel don't you make sure it is clean so that it does not get you fired? I was once part of a project that included installing white carpet throughout a house. Believe me, I learned the value of keeping my tools and shoes clean on that job.
I recently bought a new 4" adjustable wrench to use as part of my bicycle EDC. It there was some oil on the head that was excess lubricant from the adjusting screw. I didn't complain about it, I just cleaned it off. Its a tool. Tools are often dirty or oily. If it had been a belt buckle, tie clasp or watch band that had stained my clothes I would probably have felt differently.
Quite right. However you and I know that a new BO finish is going to need cleaning before you use it, not everyone might know that. :) I do agree though that you'd have to be fairly foolish not to work it out for yourself before it became an issue. ;)
The only real difference I can see between oil and BO residue on a new tool is that one is an essential part of the operation/rust prevention on a tool, the other is simply a by product of a process and really doesn't need to be there.

-
Some of the tools that I carry in my car tool box have a BO coating for rust prevention. When they were new the coating did leave some marks on my hands and the equipment that I was working on. They are tools so it doesn't bother me. The people that complain about the BO finish leaving smudges on their skin might look upon their MT's as fashion statements not tools.
Not sure i agree with that. I'm a building technician and use my MT every day, the idea that it would case me to leave black fingerprints all over a 5 star hotel would likely get me fired. :D
But if you take a new, or for matter an old, tool into a 5 star hotel don't you make sure it is clean so that it does not get you fired? I was once part of a project that included installing white carpet throughout a house. Believe me, I learned the value of keeping my tools and shoes clean on that job.
I recently bought a new 4" adjustable wrench to use as part of my bicycle EDC. It there was some oil on the head that was excess lubricant from the adjusting screw. I didn't complain about it, I just cleaned it off. Its a tool. Tools are often dirty or oily. If it had been a belt buckle, tie clasp or watch band that had stained my clothes I would probably have felt differently.
Quite right. However you and I know that a new BO finish is going to need cleaning before you use it, not everyone might know that. :) I do agree though that you'd have to be fairly foolish not to work it out for yourself before it became an issue. ;)
The only real difference I can see between oil and BO residue on a new tool is that one is an essential part of the operation/rust prevention on a tool, the other is simply a by product of a process and really doesn't need to be there.

We are not far apart on this Gareth, but I see the last part differently. The excessive oil could have been cleaned off of the adjustable wrench by the manufacturer, but they chose not to. No big deal. The story is the same with the BO residue.
-
@mzil said:
I'm of the mind the majority of their sales are to civilians, not the military, and their color selections are based on fashion/whims, not needs.edit to add: There are 15 pages of reviews on Amazon for the Black Oxide Wave, and on just the first page of those appears these individual comments:
"as another person has mentioned, the finish on this tool is less than ideal. It comes off on your hands and anything you touch for the first week or two of use"
"However, herein lies its particularly annoying flaw. Right out of the box, the finishing coat on this tool left black smudges and marks all over my hands, especially where lubricant was applied. Now, overlooking the sissy/feminine jokes sure to come, that's just not okay with me, especially if those smudges transfer to whatever I'm working on"
"When you get your Leatherman Wave w/ Black Oxide finish ...you will get "Black Hands"..I mean the finish will rub off on to your hands."
"And the black color makes it look cool as well."
[THAT'S why people buy it!- mzil]"Someone mentioned that the black finish comes off ... and, yes, it does. I had the same problem with my TDI K-bar but once wiped down with a towel it's fine."
"The only slightly annoying thing about this tool is that it needs a good rubbing down when you first get it. The black oxide finish is kinda powdery when you first get it out of the box and rubs black stains into everything it touches."
Those comments do nothing but prove my point. Black oxide is a function, not a "color". It's not paint, it's not cerakote, it's not powdercoating. It is a form of controlled oxidation(rust) that is chemically induced. Since it is oxidation in itself, there is waste residue.
And it looks cool.

True, most everyone who buys a BO tool likes the way they look, but an educated buyer won't whine about the coating coming off because they actually understand what it is they are buying. Therefor, if you have to complain about BO coming off, you probably aren't the type of person who needs it.
-
-
@Mercury said:
True, most everyone who buys a BO tool likes the way they look, but an educated buyer won't whine about the coating coming off because they actually understand what it is they are buying. Therefor, if you have to complain about BO coming off, you probably aren't the type of person who needs it.I'm not sure I'm quite understanding your meaning in this last sentence. What exactly is this type of people who need it? The military?
-
Well that's a given, but you are right in that Leatherman's sales are primarily civilian, and the uses for a BO tool in the civilian world are mainly limited to wet environments where rust would be an issue. If you know about rusty tools, and have done your research about how to inhibit said rust, you would likely discover a great deal about Black oxide considering it's widespread use in manufacturing knives and tools. That would make you an educated buyer, one who understands what BO is. If you are buying it for the "color" alone, do a bit of research about the thing you think is cool. But then again there are a lot of folks out there who don't know a thing about half the stuff they own.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



