Swisstool X and Spirit comparison pics.
-
@max6166 said:
What a fantastic post! Thanks for all the work!
I have been dying to see a point-by-point comparison like that. Really informative.
I have a few questions:
-
Do the files have the same surface on both sides?
-
I think both files are combo metal saws, correct? If so, does the Spirit's more aggressive teeth make it a better metal saw?
-
The Philips on the ST-X is at quite an angle which I think would prevent it from reaching many recessed screws. The Spirit's shank has much less of an angle, but it still has one. Can the Spirit reach recessed screws, like those found in electronics, or does the shank's angle prevent that?
No problem. ;) I'm surprised there wasn't one on here already.
Here are my take on your questions;
-
The files do have a slight variation on each side, but it is only a very slight difference - no where near as obvious as the differences on a Leatherman file. The one on the Spirit is more aggressive than the one on the Swisstool X which I feel is an improvement as I never really found an application for the one on the X.
-
The metal saw has the same teeth on both, but the Spirits is slightly thicker. TBH I am yet to use either as a metal saw, so I can't really comment on their effectiveness.
-
I personally have not had any problems with the phillips reaching anything, but I do see the shape of the Spirits to be an improvement.
-
-
I've only used the metal saw on the Swisstool X but it made short work of a metal pipe when i put a blind up. The only negetive is now the teeth are noticibly deformed and i'm unsure how effective they will be next time.
The philips on the spirit is slightly better, as when you half open up the body so it is extra long the entire thing is very thin and there is very little angle, whereas the st-x is still quite chunky and the philips head is angled towards one side.
I was going to put up a photo of the spirit-s and st-x blades next to each other but my phone has decided it's no longer speaking to my computer....
-
Very interesting to note that not one single blade or driver is commonly shared between the two models.
Does the Spirit S have the same plain edge blade as the Swisstool?

I would image the one on the Spirit would be shorter.
Here you go, sorry about the quality of photo but my phone isn't the best quality camera in the world!
<a href="http://img405.imageshack.us/my.php?image=stjc1.jpg" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://img405.imageshack.us/img405/5589/stjc1.th.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
Very interesting to note that not one single blade or driver is commonly shared between the two models.
Does the Spirit S have the same plain edge blade as the Swisstool?

I would image the one on the Spirit would be shorter.
Here you go, sorry about the quality of photo but my phone isn't the best quality camera in the world!
<a href="http://img405.imageshack.us/my.php?image=stjc1.jpg" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://img405.imageshack.us/img405/5589/stjc1.th.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
I didn't realise they were shaped differently as well.
Thanks for the pic!

-
In addition to all of the above, the X comes with a crate opener. This tool is not offered on the Spirit;
Isn't the bottle opener/combi tool bulked up so it can be used for prying?
What I was saying, was that there is no dedicated crate opener like there is on the X.
The large screwdriver doubles as the "crate opener" on the Spirit. That is why it is much thicker than that of the X. It is not a dedicated tool, as you mention.
-
Yeah, that's what I was saying- Terry!

-
Nice pics Ben
I have been
that if I get a larger MT
that I might look into gettin a Swisstool X I like all the features
plus I need to see whats all out there, all my reg MTs are Leatherman right now so I need to think outside my little box some I guess :D Plus Dunc is so adament about everyone gettin one
so next big tool STX prob be Chrstmas though :( :D -
A Swisstool X would make a hell of a Christmas pressie mate :)
-
I'm a bit late arriving in this thread ::) Great work Ben :D You've saved me a job , I was intending to get round to doing a comparison but I doubt it would have been as good as yours . nice one ;)
Just my two pennies ...
I prefer the Spirits phillips
The file is perfect for removing hard skin from your feet :o
Dunc
-
Hello ben, thanks again for pointing me here. I have been eyeing the spirit for a long time, does it have the same toughtness as a swisstool x?
-
@duckman1975 said:
Hello ben, thanks again for pointing me here. I have been eyeing the spirit for a long time, does it have the same toughtness as a swisstool x?I believe it does, yes. Infact, quite a few of the Spirits tools are actually thicker than those on the Swisstool and also, the flat heads look larger and more durable as well.
You do lose a little length off the tools on the Spirit though.
-
Glad to know that, like the spirit design. Which one do you use the most the x or the spirit? like my surge but sometimes its just to darn heavy to carry around, sorry lm123.
-
@duckman1975 said:
Glad to know that, like the spirit design. Which one do you use the most the x or the spirit? like my surge but sometimes its just to darn heavy to carry around, sorry lm123.TBH, I have only had the Spirit a couple of days, but since it arrived, it has been the MT I have carried. ;)
-
For others considering the SwissTool and the Spirit, I think the scissors should be the primary concern. If you don't mind the added size and weight, go with the SwissTool. If you can, get both and see which suits you more. You can always put the other in the car or give it away as a gift.
-
This is quite the necrothread, sir.
-
Still the best comparison on the Web, so I thought it best to post here despite the threads age. Good information is still good information.
-
Agree, it was a nice read, no matter how old it is. And some newer members get to see it for the first time too.
I have a Swisstool X on the way at the moment so it was nice to see it again. :D
-
I want to buy my first Swisstool X. Should I pay full price for a brand new version or get a 2nd hand with old style plier head for a bit less? Which version is better if I only want to choose one?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login