Scissor based keychain MTs
-
I always wanted an S4, but the Micra seems quite liked too. I think we should get em both Ben
and stay true to our calling, more Multitools! -
@WhichDawg said:
I always wanted an S4, but the Micra seems quite liked too. I think we should get em both Ben
and stay true to our calling, more Multitools!And a Crosscut and a load of others as well yeah? :D
-
first we'll start with the favs, then we'll work our way through the list!
-
@WhichDawg said:
first we'll start with the favs, then we'll work our way through the list!But that's my problem, what are the favs? ;)
-
Hi,
My vote is for the S4.
Cheers - Joe
-
Here are some comparison pics of the Micra, the Squirt S4, and the SOG CrossCut:

At first glance they all appear pretty much equal. Little folding scissors with a selection of blades and such. All three are about the same size.

The Micra and (to a lesser extent) the SOG close up into stainless steel boxes. The Squirt's blades are outside opening for easy access, but that leaves the innards exposed to dirt and crud when it's carried in the pocket. User preference.



Scissors en'guard, the cutting edges on the SOG CrossCut are significantly longer than the Leathermans. This combined with compound leverage would make a person think the CrossCut would be hands down the best. But.....

Notice how wide the CrossCut is up near the scissor pivot? Those wide gear teeth become a real liability when trying to make long cuts in heavy material. Once your cut begins to extend beyond the length of the scissor jaws, those gears "hang up" on the material being cut. (see below)

The Squirt S4 is better:

While in my opinion the Micra with its extremely narrow pivot area is by far the best:

Two more tests I conducted:
On a 30-page mail order catalog, the Micra and the Squirt cut all the way across no problem. Holding the tool stationary and squeezing the handles, both models snipped through all the way to the scissor tips. The CrossCut didn't fair so well. It started the cut okay, but then out near the tips the scissor jaws spread apart and the cut failed.On a plastic clam pack of medium thickness, the Micra's narrow pivot area allowed it to snip and cut wherever I wanted. From one side to the other no problems. The Squirt did "okay" but was not as smooth as the Micra part way across the clam pack where it had some contour for the product to fit inside. Again the CrossCut had the most difficult time. The wide pivot area and gear teeth meant that the cut portion of the clam pack had to be spread wide apart in order to allow the cutting to continue. And the jaw-spreading issue negated any advantage the compound leverage may have given the tool on the heavy plastic.
Now keep in mind these scissor tools are used to cut a lot more than paper and plastic. On cord or small rope the results might be different. Or even on single sheets of paper the Micra's narrow pivot advantage won't matter as much.
But on heavy paper or cardboard or plastic I'd opt for the Micra. :)
-
J-sews
That was a useful post. Thank you!
-
I EDC-ed a Micra till about 2 weeks back, when i switched to a CrossCut.
J-sews is spot on. Though it looks stronger because of the compound leverage, the Micra scissors is more effective when cutting paper. The spring on the Micra is also better, so the scissors open up more effectively, which makes a big difference as to how fast you can cut.
There is one thing that the Crosscut trumped the Micra. When cutting something tiny, like snipping off a bit of peeling, dead skin on my fingers, the SOG's tip was actually better than my Micra's. Even though J-sews found that when cutting through a thick sheet, the Micra cut all the way to the tip while the CrossCut didn't, when using ONLY the the tip of the scissors, I found the CrossCut better.
-
Bob your post belongs in the review section :)
-
Thanks for the pics Bob! :) They were very helpful. ;)
-
Yeah Bob, really helpful! ty sir

-
I would recommend the Micra i have the micra and the crosscut but if you want something different there is the shrade tough chip i have never handled it before though.
-
I know a few folks here like the Tough Chip ST2, but to be honest, I really don't think anyone should look at them. I've had one for a couple of years now, and I never use it, carry it etc.
Def
-
I know a few folks here like the Tough Chip ST2, but to be honest, I really don't think anyone should look at them.
Why not? Just because you don't like it doesn't mean anyone shouldn't even look at it. IMHO the(older) Tough Chip completely outclassed the SOG and LM scissor based tools. Yeah they were bigger but in my experiences they were also much stronger and cut better. Like the SURGE!!!!
Except that's just bigger, not better. :D :D
Of course none of these scissor tools is IMHO, leaps and bounds better than the scissors on a full size SAK. I have complete confidence in the scissors on my Fieldmaster. They may be slightly better but I'd rather have the full size blade and still good scissors than great scissors and an almost useless blade.
-
I think they are too big and bulky to be suitable for a keychain (and mine even has a sheath!), the implements on them aren't really all that great, and anyone who might still want one, might end up getting one from the "new" Schrade, and I certainly wouldn't suggest anyone pays actual money for something from Taylor Cutlery.
Def
-
@Defender said:
I think they are too big and bulky to be suitable for a keychain (and mine even has a sheath!), the implements on them aren't really all that great, and anyone who might still want one, might end up getting one from the "new" Schrade, and I certainly wouldn't suggest anyone pays actual money for something from Taylor Cutlery.Def
I feel a rant coming on :o :D
-
Nope, just mentioning a few good reasons not to get a Tough Chip! :D
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



