Classic SD as edc?
-
The manager gets my vote for small SAK joy.


-
I also find the Classic to be just a little bit to .... er, little.
Today I have been carrying an Executive as I find that the 74mm size fits my hand better.
You could also look at the Ambassador which is the same tools as the Classic, just bigger blade and scissors.
-
The Classic is a great EDC, covering any and all roles traditionally held by a small pen knife. It is unobtrusive, replaceable, high quality, and serves many functions. It's not often my only knife, but, working a desk job, where most of my knife-needs are wants, I have yet to feel under-knifed when it is.
-
@PTRSAK said:
I also find the Classic to be just a little bit to .... er, little.Today I have been carrying an Executive as I find that the 74mm size fits my hand better.
You could also look at the Ambassador which is the same tools as the Classic, just bigger blade and scissors.
+1
As a result of talking about how much I prefer the Executive, I took it off my keychain tonight and will be carrying it in place of my Micra sometimes to show it some love :D It needs some love as I haven't carried it in a long time and it was my very first SAK. -
I love them all, but prefer the Manager in this genre. The Classic SD is great. But for me the Manager's addition of a small 3D phillips, cap lifter, pen, etc. is worth the minimal increase in girth. I don't miss the loss of the toothpick, which for me is the least useful of any tool this side of a corkscrew. As for the Executive, for me it has no real benefit over the Manager though you do get a longer blade and bigger scissor which is noteworthy. They are all great though, and far better than a pocket full of nothing.
<a href="http://s1144.photobucket.com/user/BirchHardwood/media/3565865d-2823-416a-ade2-33a41b5586d8.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1144.photobucket.com/albums/o487/BirchHardwood/3565865d-2823-416a-ade2-33a41b5586d8.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Powernoodle's ubiquitous, gratuitous and too-often-posted Manager pic. -
@powernoodle said:
I love them all, but prefer the Manager in this genre. The Classic SD is great. But for me the Manager's addition of a small 3D phillips, cap lifter, pen, etc. is worth the minimal increase in girth. I don't miss the loss of the toothpick, which for me is the least useful of any tool this side of a corkscrew. As for the Executive, for me it has no real benefit over the Manager though you do get a longer blade and bigger scissor which is noteworthy. They are all great though, and far better than a pocket full of nothing.Those are the main reasons I prefer the Executive, but the Manager is one I would possibly get sometime.
-
@powernoodle said:
I love them all, but prefer the Manager in this genre. The Classic SD is great. But for me the Manager's addition of a small 3D phillips, cap lifter, pen, etc. is worth the minimal increase in girth. I don't miss the loss of the toothpick, which for me is the least useful of any tool this side of a corkscrew. As for the Executive, for me it has no real benefit over the Manager though you do get a longer blade and bigger scissor which is noteworthy. They are all great though, and far better than a pocket full of nothing.<a href="http://s1144.photobucket.com/user/BirchHardwood/media/3565865d-2823-416a-ade2-33a41b5586d8.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1144.photobucket.com/albums/o487/BirchHardwood/3565865d-2823-416a-ade2-33a41b5586d8.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Powernoodle's ubiquitous, gratuitous and too-often-posted Manager pic.The manager is a great little tool. I carry one on my keaychain. The combined bottleopener and small phillips is perfect for tiny screws and opening beer bootles without pulling out the Pioneer in a public place. Also the pen has saved the day on many occations.
-
I'm not completely dissing the 58mm format, I have dozens of them including a few custom jobs.
I do like my Alox Rambler and the Monster58 was a fun build. I'm slowly working my was through a pile of the "But wait, there's more..." classics I have acquired in eBay purchases and giving them horn, micarta or exotic wood scales.
They are so much nicer when you knock them up a notch, BAM!

-
Nothing wrong with a Classic as an EDC, but as others have said I find the blade just a little too small for some jobs. The Ambassador solves this by being that bit bigger, though you do lose the screwdriver tip. Also watch out for the fact that some have a keyring and some do not, important if you were planning to carry it on your keyring.
-
I'm loving my Executive, enough that I love it just as much as the Cadet already.
I adore the Cadet. Light, feels nice in the hand, and I like having a bottle opener handy as well as a decent-sized screwdriver. The Executive gives me pretty nice scissors, that glorious file, and I'm expecting to find some uses for the orange peeler as well.
I'd say if you have neither a Cadet nor an Executive, find either, they're both on point as an EDC SAK.
-
I ended up buying a Recruit a few weeks ago and have been using that as my edc. It has worked out very well and I already have the Cellidor scales scratched up (sign of a good broken in SAK).
-
One of the most useful tools in this genre (IMO) is the mini phillips on the Manager. I use that sucker all of the time to remove battery doors on toys and other small electronic devices. Other implements will do the trick, like the file tip on the Executive, but the real deal on the Manager seems to work best.
-
@powernoodle said:
One of the most useful tools in this genre (IMO) is the mini phillips on the Manager. I use that sucker all of the time to remove battery doors on toys and other small electronic devices. Other implements will do the trick, like the file tip on the Executive, but the real deal on the Manager seems to work best.+1

-
Too small for me , but if I had to carry a 58mm , it would be a Rambler .
Chris
-
@powernoodle said:
I don't miss the loss of the toothpick, which for me is the least useful of any tool this side of a corkscrew.It's worth noting that they do at least give you the choice - they toothpick comes in the box so if you really want a toothpick and have no use for the tweezers you can swap.
I keep the toothpick in my earphone pouch for a bit of post-use cleaning.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login