Battle of the X-es, Vic Swisstool vrs Spirit
-
Nice comparison. After using the Spirit X for a few years now with different things I just don't need the bigger Swisstool.
However for the life of me I can't tell which side of the file is finer -
If you'd have posted this a year ago it would have saved me a LOT of money and time

-
@styx said:
Nice comparison. After using the Spirit X for a few years now with different things I just don't need the bigger Swisstool.
However for the life of me I can't tell which side of the file is finerThe side towards the handle is definitely finer on mine.
@Taxi Dad said:
If you'd have posted this a year ago it would have saved me a LOT of money and time
And where's the fun in that. :P The spirit of MTO is GET THEM ALL. >:D
So which one would you have chosen? :D
-
Great comparison.
I like both tools well and agree on those few differences you mention. I have "<u>used</u>" my SwissTool but the Spirit stays in its pouch untouched since photography time. -
Nice comparison. After using the Spirit X for a few years now with different things I just don't need the bigger Swisstool.
However for the life of me I can't tell which side of the file is finerThe side towards the handle is definitely finer on mine.
@Taxi Dad said:
If you'd have posted this a year ago it would have saved me a LOT of money and time
And where's the fun in that. :P The spirit of MTO is GET THEM ALL. >:D
So which one would you have chosen? :D
I couldn't get on with the Swisstool ::) i've been around the block and tried a few since then, just got a 'Spirit' and I love it :D where's the sense :ahhh (swiss tool was 'lacking' scissors mind
) -
The SwissTool nylon pouch with the snap carries nice and low, still vertical only though.
-
I just came here for the pun in the title. :D
-
Good review , I prefer the Spirit X for EDC too .
Chris
-
Another great detailed comparison between the SwissTool and Spirit! It's fun to see the small design changes that went into the Spirit, to improve weight and accomodate the different shape without losing strength. I weighed a SwissTool, Spirit S, and Wave the other week just out of curiosity, and was surprised to find that the Spirit only weighs 75% of what the SwissTool does. Not only that, but the Wave weighs about right between the two, at ~240g. For my EDC, you can't get much closer to perfection than a Spirit S on the belt and a Compact in the pocket.
-
Very Nice comparison. I don't know about the scores I just know the Spirit is the International Champion.

-
I really prefer the SwissTool for the better scissors and blade.
Both are unnoticeable on my belt. -
I only have the Spirit (butterblade), but I've considered the Swisstool before. I don't think there's much point to getting one at this point in my MT life, unless it was simply for a new toy ;) I've always been curious about the Swisstool since I got the Spirit though. It does seem like there were improvements made to some of the tools for Spirit though. I like the bottle opener/prybar as well, and it's surprising how much beefier it is than the Swisstool's two separate tools, or that they didn't just do the same thing for the Swisstool and free up a possible spot for something else. Oh well. The Spirit is an excellent example of Swiss engineering, and I'm sure the big brother is the same

-
What surprised me was that the Swisstool had so much thinner saw and file. The difference is very visible in this picture, the far right tools on both. As I said I consider that a plus for the saw but a minus for the file on the Swisstool.

-
Wow, that is a considerable difference indeed. One would think the larger Swisstool would have the beefier tools. It's actually not all that much thicker than the Spirit is it? I would probably say that the Spirit may be the better MT overall between the two of them. However, I've never handled/used a Swisstool, so who's to say I may or may not think otherwise if I were to do so

-
@Monrogue said:
Wow, that is a considerable difference indeed. One would think the larger Swisstool would have the beefier tools. It's actually not all that much thicker than the Spirit is it? I would probably say that the Spirit may be the better MT overall between the two of them. However,** I've never handled/used a Swisstool**, so who's to say I may or may not think otherwise if I were to do so
fetch your wallet my good man, you need to go shopping ::)
-
Nice comparison Nikola
Another nice feature on the Swisstool along with the rule is the square. This helped my father and I assemble a greenhouse at my parents' home a couple of years back.The Spirit X has got to be my favourite pocket tool of all of them, and the Swisstool CS Plus (X model with extras) is my favourite for bag carry. There are times and situations where a different tool may be more appropriate (should you need a serrated blade, or OHO, or non-locking or whatever), but for general purpose carry and not knowing what the day might have in store, these two tools are magnificent
-
Battle of he X-es! Love it. This is like trying to chose between an awesome MT and an awesome MT! I think any MT aquire'r need boths. I like both, and use them.
-
@Taxi Dad said:
Wow, that is a considerable difference indeed. One would think the larger Swisstool would have the beefier tools. It's actually not all that much thicker than the Spirit is it? I would probably say that the Spirit may be the better MT overall between the two of them. However,** I've never handled/used a Swisstool**, so who's to say I may or may not think otherwise if I were to do so

fetch your wallet my good man, you need to go shopping ::)
Yeah, my wallet's not too happy with me after getting two mods ;) I think my Spirit (butterblade) will have to suffice...for now >:D
-
I only have a SwissTool myself, a new BO regular with two blades (including the new style for the serrated one). I do not miss the scissors and I prefer the second blade. I like it and I am now waiting my second, in plain silver. The Spirits seem to be more refined but I prefer the larger siblings - at least for now, until I get to handle a Spirit.

-
For me , the Spirit does 98% of what I want a Multi for , with less weight , bulk , and with better ergonomics . I've owned both a Swisstools , and Spirits - all I have at present is one Spirit X .
Chris
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

