Website or Book?
-
Over the past week I drew up an outline for the chapters in the book and started working on sample chapter. Stay tuned...
-
I vote for a book but would be happy either way.
-
keep us updated. I'd buy a book.
-
And I am sure if you need photos of anything not yet in your collection , I am sure someone will be able to provide some .... I have a few soldiers I can snap :)
-
A model of publishing that I really like and may be applicable:
-
Give us a peak at the first chapter?
-
A book is more alluring for me, though a website or an e-book have their advantages. Either way I think it would be great if you took the time to write all that stuff down for the world to know and I certainly look forward to seeing the fruits of this venture. I think a printed book might take a little longer due to research and chapter planning but it's definately worth it IMHO :ahhh

-
Thought I'd post an update on the book. It is now books, not book. Originally my idea was to write about both simultaneously. I figured that yes, there are some minor difference in tool changes of the years (e.g. 84mm knives get 2.0mm blades at least 10 yrs before 91mm ones do), but the vast majority of the changes happened simultaneously and could be documented as such.
Well, as I started organizing my research I've found there are a lot more differences than I originally thought. Trying to write about both product lines in the same chapter ends up being confusing, and if I break them out into their own separate sets of chapters, it essentially becomes two books. So that's what I've decided to do - write an 84mm and a 91mm book following the same basic format. I also realized while compiling a list of all known models of knives that there's a hell of a job ahead of me. I documented 48 different 84mm models and 125 different 91mm models, including all special run models that I know of.
Good news from Ibach - Victorinox has given me permission to use their trademarks in the book, which is a pretty big relief. I'm not sure what the laws are regarding using a company's trademarks in a written work (with pictures) - can you do it without permission under fair use? No clue, but unsurprisingly Victorinox is being very helpful and supportive of this effort so it's not something I have to worry about. They really are a great company.
Finally - I'd like some opinions. In outlining the section on the different knife models I decided that for ease of reference I want to have a unique name for each different model of knife. The plan is to list all "aliases" under the name (e.g. The Artisan, aka Craftsman), but each model should get it's own "reference" name. The problem is Victorinox has recycled a lot of names and many knives don't have unique names. Three in particular I'm thinking of are the Angler, Craftsman, and Handyman. These are all names that refer to current production knives. However, pre-1987, these names were used on different models.
My plan is to use any name currently in use to refer to the model currently in production. So, if I refer to a "Handyman", that means the current incarnation of that model (Ranger w/ pliers), and not the older version (Ranger w/ fish scaler). So what to call the older version?
- Handyman Classic
- Handyman Original
- Something else
Any thoughts are appreciated. Thanks!
-
You might try:
Handyman (1)
Handyman (2)
Handyman (3)with the oldest first. If a new version shows up it's easy to add a number.
Sounds like progress is being made. Looking forward to the final product(s).
-
A.very good choice i think not trying to mix 84mm and 91mm.
-
@jazzbass said:
My plan is to use any name currently in use to refer to the model currently in production. So, if I refer to a "Handyman", that means the current incarnation of that model (Ranger w/ pliers), and not the older version (Ranger w/ fish scaler). So what to call the older version?- Handyman Classic
- Handyman Original
- Something else
Any thoughts are appreciated. Thanks!
Considering these 'books' might be published in 2013/2014, I do agree it's best to use what most public known or Victorinox is using for the current models. But make very clear references where the same name will occur at the end of that section, so people could trace the history of the 'name'.
Few other humble suggestions for avoiding repeated-name confusion:
-
Categories everything under different era
If possible, make the separation of these eras meaningful.(every 20 years, expansion of plant, change of style, world events, CEO changes, etc) So people will know if a name occured in that era, and also easy to make association between the era and the product. The good thing is, if there is a new revised book/info, it is easy to pickup where it is left off(for you or for future writer). -
2 Categories: Current production vs Ceased production
Again, these two categories, will be time-proof. But the tricky part is, if the books were to be revised in the future, some currently produced products might become 'ceased production' and reading old/new book together could be confusing to reader(especially if name is re-used). -
Method of elimination + Other fun reading material
This really has to do with how to organize the book and the goal of writing it. If it is to aim potential collectors to quickly identify something, then I do strongly recommend to categorize around the physical appearance of the tool(scale, tool shape/size/design, blade, shape, material, trademark, etc) and their history of development.
With good pictures of everything, we could quickly deduct when(or when not) the tool is made. Of course, some section could be donated to write about maybe the top ten most popular/long-lasting models, and detail their history/story of use/evolution for the fun read.
These 'books' idea is so exciting, and just thrilled to see someone to be so dedicated to pass down the knowledge in some form. On the premise to not lose money, I for one will vote against the ebook before the book, simply because it will lessen the desire for people to purchase the book. It is might not be fair for someone to work hard to put these together and in the end have to bear all the financial risk by. On the other hand, if a book is published, depending on budget/time/desire, a new revision could always be printed in ebook or new book format in the distant future.
Another thing is to consider a good service to collectors who really need to identify a dated piece on the internet, it will be super nice to have a website built similar to a SAK selector, so by clicking the features, it will eventually yield some exact results(with pictures?) or some approximate-time-of-production suggestion. Of course, this kind of project could be maintained by a small knowledgeable group of people, so the fire could be passed on in the future.
-
This is great news. I can't wait for the book(s) :D
-
Yes i am sure the books will be very good

-
@comis said:
Few other humble suggestions for avoiding repeated-name confusion:- Categories everything under different era
I have a two level Periodization (eras and periods) that I developed years ago that will be a central part of the books. A couple of the other collectors here have seen it, but I never posted explicitly about it. The chapter on this periodization system I developed is actually the first one I'm working one; maybe I post a draft version of the chapter later this week if anyone is interested.
@comis said:
2) 2 Categories: Current production vs Ceased productionThis doesn't work very well because many knives can be out of production but later remade (e.g. The Yeoman, currently revived by SwissBianco).
As for everything else, well I have a pretty detailed outline of the book already worked up and I'm going to start working from there. I'll put it this way - I want to make the book that I, as a fairly serious collector, always wished had existed.
-
Few other humble suggestions for avoiding repeated-name confusion:
- Categories everything under different era
I have a two level Periodization (eras and periods) that I developed years ago that will be a central part of the books. A couple of the other collectors here have seen it, but I never posted explicitly about it. The chapter on this periodization system I developed is actually the first one I'm working one; maybe I post a draft version of the chapter later this week if anyone is interested.
@comis said:
2) 2 Categories: Current production vs Ceased productionThis doesn't work very well because many knives can be out of production but later remade (e.g. The Yeoman, currently revived by SwissBianco).
As for everything else, well I have a pretty detailed outline of the book already worked up and I'm going to start working from there. I'll put it this way - I want to make the book that I, as a fairly serious collector, always wished had existed.
@jazzbass said:
...
As for everything else, well I have a pretty detailed outline of the book already worked up and I'm going to start working from there. I'll put it this way - I want to make the book that I, as a fairly serious collector, always wished had existed.Can't hardly wait! :D
I am fairly new to the whole SAK collecting game, and I do often think about what are the good ways to appraise/collect/document/track/store the SAKs that interest me or those I have collected. It'd be great if the book could shed some light to new collectors/SAKs lovers, what are different ways to organize this whole thing.
-
@jazzbass said:
I want to make the book that I, as a fairly serious collector, always wished had existed.
That's the spirit. I encourage you to take your time and envision the most functional and comprehensive way to tackle your topic. I'm sure you are aware of many issues that need to be addressed. (In the past I used to make translations for a living. Sometimes I found out that what I had written down was good but could be made even better through text structure. Likewise I think you could use some meticulous planning ;))As for the recurring model names, I think I would go for something like (random dates as I'm not sure):
1970-1985 Handyman (Ranger w/ fish scaler). That way you keep the model's name, era and variations all in one place and make it easy to keep track of the timeline. That's just me though. Anyway, I think that writting these books is very good for you first of all and also for the rest of us SAK enthusiasts. Good luck to you -coming from a bloody perfectionist
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
