Enlightenment
-
'Its not really a problem-it just means your reaching enlightenmeny' -Al,the 50ft-trad.
There's a few points of enlightenment I've reached...my optimal SAK is a SuperTinker,or the Wenger equivalent.(of course I'm fixated with the million dollar Wenger which packs a meaty five layers
)I'm not keen on Tacti-cool folding knives. I'm not in a job that requires tactical qualities,and the looks in knife-o-phobic Britain are a liability.
I'm in the process of getting rid of my OHO folders...they're just a bit of a bad idea.As much as I like the convenience at work,in too many other situations they're too much of a temptation.Theres a couple I'll keep,like my SRM 710,but they're for particular jobs,rather than EDC.
I've also really come to the conclusion that,as a general rule,there's a Goldielocks zone of value in knives,of about £20-£40.Most SAKs fall within this price zone,most Opinels,most Moras too!These knives are quality,durable and reliable.I have a few folders that lie outside the Goldielocks zone,but they came through trades rather than cash purchase.
As to fixed blades,I have two big scary ones,and although there's one or two Condors I fancy,I think that Moras must be truly hard to beat!
As to MTs,with the exception of the Victorinox tools,I don't think there's one on the market that inspires confidence the way the first generation Leathermen did.This week sees my modded PST go in to work.I think I'll be leaving an MT with rolled edges in my locker in case of jobs that require serious plier pressure,but I have a strong notion that the KST is going to become a serious fixture in my EDC.
These are my main conclusions after a three year journey in knives and multitools.
What are your conclusions,enlightenments and epiphanies?
-
Very few companies really do proper hardening, and you'll always find out when it's too late. It's a lot of brittle steel out there, carbide problems, remains of austenite, etc, etc. I care more and more about trust in the hardening process rather than the exact steel as time goes by.
Probably nothing beats a Mora on price/performance, but it's possible to beat it on performance.
You'll always end up EDCing a Victorinox, no matter how many knives you own.
And this is just a general complaint: I prefer fixed blades, but laws and public opinion of knives are no fun.
-
I find myself now admiring Vic, Wenger and SpyderCo and Case. Although, I don't have nearly as many Spydies and Case's as I'd like, my Vic and Wenger collection is getting there.
My EDC includes a Pioneer, Climber and Rambler. Between the 3 of those, I find I can accomplish most tasks, and if I'm heading out for a job that's more in the unknown, I take the SwissChamp for extra backup.
No matter what the brand of knife however, I look for and demand the highest quality. I have no forgiveness for manufacturing defects, especially in the bulk output that LM has. This is not meant to pick on LM but they are a good example company of one to avoid.
-
I went through this john,I've come too a conclusion that the og wave is my all time favorite and where i started my mt journey back in 98,but sak's and mt's i couldn't live without are the tinker for lightweight urban edc,swisschamp as my main edc,modded kick for my lightweight uk legal mt,surge for heavy work ,pst for just being a classic,and old and new gaks for outdoor work,keychain wise s4 for keychain or alox cak with toothpick and tweezers,p4 for maxpedition organizer,and micra too pair with the pst,well that's me,but the wave is my first love and the champ is my main edc ,i can blame taxidad for that and not you for a change john

-
Good on you mate, I think we all reach that conclusion eventually :)
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
-
a bit like you John, I've tried and tested more shiny stuff than Normal folk would consider healthy.
Since my arrival here at MTO I've stepped up a few gears, buying much more in the last year than I have in many previous years
also someone who will remain anonymous (Kirk ;)) has tempted me with loads of stuff I didn't even have an interest in until I found this den of iniquity 
BUT I still keep going back to my 'old faithful', even though I now love my wave, and the 'Vic Spirit' someone ( ::)) convinced me I couldn't live without, I have trouble leaving home without my battle scared 'swisschamp' , she has ALWAYS served me so well, and although lacking in the 'plier' department, has such a good selection of tools I rarely find I have nothing to work with, and IS kinda UK friendly :D (but if I were searched by PC Plod I'd rather not be carrying "any" knife ::))
so in summary I too have been on a long journey back to where I started
but here's to the on going quest

-
@Steinar said:
...
You'll always end up EDCing a Victorinox, no matter how many knives you own.
...Very wise words here.

I've found my ideal carry quite some time ago, a Spirit X and a SAK de jour. Can't even remember when I carried a single bladed folder. Well OK, I carried an ALOX Solo today, but that's a gray area, right? ;)
-
@kirk13 said:
'Its not really a problem-it just means your reaching enlightenmeny' -Al,the 50ft-trad.There's a few points of enlightenment I've reached...
.... What are your conclusions,enlightenments and epiphanies?
Knew you'd come round to my way of thinking, Kirky Boy ;) :D :D
OK - here's a few of my ***many ***conclusions thus far:
[list type=decimal]
-
Multitool manufacturers on the whole have no interest whatsoever about making good tools - they are purely interested in making profit. This can be done with innovation, gimmicks, clever marketting and/or engineering cost savings into the products, either directly through materials, or indirectly through process routes. Leatherman's finest product for example is it's PR engine, firing up a brand loyalty like no other through patriotism and other psychological means. Gerber on the other hand cycles through products time after time, constantly changing what it has on offer and seeking out that gimmick or novelty which is going to capture the imagination of the mjarket, no matter how briefly. CRKT seem to work similarly too. The exception to the rule is Victorinox who first and foremost want their product to be of superior quality. Their designs might not suit all users at all times, but they have a thirst for quality above all other manufacturers - everyone else is just after your money
-
Due to financial pressures, the best tools out there right now are the ones that have been running for years or have been discontinued. Customers are driving the sale prices of tools through the floor, and manufacturers have no option but to make compromises in quality in order to achieve sales and stay in business. Their workforces are all seeking more money as their families face rising costs at home, litigation drives up insurance costs and legal fees, taxation, rent, rates, and power are all increasing - and all the time the customer is wanting to pay less and less. The only way forward is to "cheapen" the tools. If we don't like the way modern releases compare to tools of old - we only have ourselves to blame
-
Value (price vs function/quality) is more important than price and/or function/quality alone
-
Gerber tools are perfectly fine! They are not necessarily the best tools available, but on the whole offer exceptionally good value for money. A Leatherman Crunch has a level of engineering that will make it more resistance to abuse than a Gerber Grappler, and there is more chance of it lasting the 25 year warrantied term without failure - however - a Gerber Grappler offers more diversity in capability with longer drivers, longer knife, longer file, fully one hand opening etc etc - but it will probably break in a shorter period of time than the Crunch - BUT it will also cost you less money. Similar parallels can be drawn with Skeletool vs Octane, Kick vs MP400, Balance vs Juice. Gerbers are engineered to an acceptable level and offer great value - Leatherman are often over engineered and cost considerable more .... assuming the quality of the tool is up to par (something they are starting to struggle on more and more - see note 1). You pay your money and take your chouice (See Note 3 - for me personally, Gerber has the upper hand over Leatherman recently)
-
Backspring corkscrew is WAY better than backspring Phillips
-
Kick, Fuse, MP400 andPaladin PT-510 make for GREAT knifeless mods
-
Ease of sharpening beats edge retention. Keep your brittle easily chipped supersteels which need hours with expensive tackle to sharpen, and give me a well treated piece of 420 stainless anyday
-
There are some excellent tools getting less attention than they deserve. Gerber Balance, Fit, & Octane, IDL Tools T5 and T7, Swiss+Tech Micro-Plus 8in1 and Screwzall (fantastic companion tools for SAKs). Discoed models not getting the love they deserve include MP700, SOG Toolclip, Buck X-Tract Fin & Essential
-
I very very rarely need a saw
-
Wenger ergonomic Ranger scales are NOT ergonomic
-
Victorinox's locking 111mm knives are horrible
-
Wenger's locking 85mm are horrible
-
Byrd Tern and Wings Slipit are better than more expensive Spydie knives
-
Def's old kayak is pink
-
Alox is overrated
-
A tool combo is better than having one bigger tool with all the same features
-
Tacticool knives, pack, pouches and camo gear is uber sad and equivalent to stuffing a pair of socks down the front of your man hammock to boost your ego
-
UK legal pocket clipped OHO knives are excellent! Nothing wrong with a tradfitional slippie, but a quick access OHO (for general utility) has proved most helpful many many times
-
I kind of rattle on a bit too much, especially when I've been knocking a few back like tonight
-
I've forgotten what I was going to say next ...
-
Oh yes, everything I have written in my conclusions above is fluid - in as much as it may have all changed perspective in 6 months ... and that's perfectly fine. Not only does everyone have a different bias and need spectrum, but things change. One day the best tool for you might be a Charge AL, the next it might be a Wenger Traveller and IDL T7
-
-
:D
Excellent read.

-
...
You'll always end up EDCing a Victorinox, no matter how many knives you own.
...Very wise words here.

+2. While I often carry other knives as well (Spydercos have been favorites of late), having only knife blades in my pockets without any other tools just seems silly at this point. Once you go SAK, you never go back.
-
I have your back on almost everything except #13 and #14 Al. I have yet to like a Byrd version as much as the Spyderco version, and I hate the Byrd's Eye opening hole. I also like 111mm and 85mm knives, but I can understand why others may not.
I have a few revelations of my own but they'll have to wait until I have a bit more time to share them.
Def
-
A most excellent and well thought out ramble there Al. :)
-
My enlightenment came when I decided what worked for me, and went and had it built. The same has applied for flashlights, multi tools and many other things in life. What's right for me won't be what's right for someone else. Customized tools make life better.
It doesn't have to be expensive to be good. It's not always going to be good even if it's expensive.
Brand loyalty is for chumps (except in the case of tomato ketchup). Always have the right tool for the right job, regardless of brand.
-
seems like at some point the right combo or fit eventually happens. "test" driving MTs and SAKs is part of the process and fluidity is so true when it comes to finding that "perfect" fit.
i very much enjoyed reading this thread. i have yet to find my right fit and am having a great time being fluid with trying new things. i like to have a SAK on me at all times as they just got it right and keep doing it right as far as ive seen, functionality in a compact package.
-
Thanks fellers

@Grant Lamontagne said:
I have your back on almost everything except #13 and #14 Al.:D
#13 was heavily based on #3 & #7. The Byrd knives I have are excellent value, and in a well treated budget steel that isn't going to chip or need a week off work to sharpen :P Personally I've never had an issue with the Byrds eye OHO, but fair point if you find it a problem. My dislike of locking blades which need you to put your fingers/thumb in the path of the blade to release it is another major barrier for me with Spyderco. I do have an original black UKPK which is a very nice knife, but find the Byrd Tern which is very similar (see HERE) is much nicer to use even discounting the steel issues.
In fairness, the slide release Vic 111mm is less of an issue as at least you do not cross the path of the blade, and even right handed the lock can easily be released with your right index finger. I did still nearly stab myself in the foot with a Vic Skipper though, when I went to close the blade but didn't have the lock release just right. I pushed the knife out of my hand and it hit the floor with the point of the blade right where my foot would have been had I not moved it so quick. The OHO isn't brilliant for "righties" either.
I have handled an 85mm locker, and found the lock very noticable in the grip (plus other issues as above with siting of lock and blade path). I'm eagerly waiting to see how Vic consolidates their 84mm line with the Wenger 85mm, and whether the locks are abandoned or continued across the range. Personally I'd love them to ditch the locks but keep the full range of 85mm tools. Other than Kirky's "fluke" knife, it is currently not possible to buy a new Wenger 85mm with both a Phillips and a non-locking blade in the UK
@Aloha007 said:
seems like at some point the right combo or fit eventually happens. "test" driving MTs and SAKs is part of the process and fluidity is so true when it comes to finding that "perfect" fit.i very much enjoyed reading this thread. i have yet to find my right fit and am having a great time being fluid with trying new things. i like to have a SAK on me at all times as they just got it right and keep doing it right as far as ive seen, functionality in a compact package.
Yup! That's what I had to do in order to reach my conclusions. Buy lots of tools and try them all at different times, in different conditions and circumstance, and in different pairings/combinations. Good fun, but very expensive :ahhh :ahhh :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Yup! That's what I had to do in order to reach my conclusions. Buy lots of tools and try them all at different times, in different conditions and circumstance, and in different pairings/combinations. Good fun, but very expensive :ahhh :ahhh :DI'm still in the process of doing just this.
A few points I'd add.
1)The 111mm OHO is, in MY opinion, one of the best Lefty OHOs in existence. I can both open and close it with one hand, and I have never felt like my thumb was in danger.
-
There likely is no perfect tool, even for a given individual. There may be something near a perfect tool (or tool combination) for a certain type of work. If your work changes, your tool loadout may be vastly different. Therefore, it's probably best just to have a WHOLE BUNCH of tools to chose from. :D
-
There's nothing wrong with someone loving their $10 multitool. If it meets their needs, then it's the right tool for them.
-
It's not useful if it's not on your person, or readily at hand.
4A) Therefore, it's generally best to get smallest/lightest toolset to fit your needs. -
The blade on a 58mm SAK has never failed to perform any task I've set it to.
5A) I still prefer the more sturdy feeling 84mm small blade as a minimum. This might be a matter of how something SEEMS than how it is, but that doesn't matter to me. -
I am currently in a love/hate relationship with the Leatherman Juice line. Why must you tease me with such a nearly perfect form factor then fail in many small details?
-
After extensive research, I have come to the conclusion that, all things considered, the SOG Crosscut is still the most ACTUALLY useful tool for me. In reality, I need a toothpick way more than I need a phillips driver, making the Crosscut edge out the Micra.
8 ) I have determined that, for me, the Vic Spirit X has thus far been the best full size MT I've found, and I now carry it on a daily basis.
8A) Since starting to carry it, I have not needed it, not even once. My Crosscut has handled everything.-
I can't understand a reason to get a 91mm SAK with plier layer when for virtually the same weight, you could get the Leatherman Style PS, which are much better pliers.
-
I am not a blade-steel connoisseur. I am not going to waste time becoming an expert blade sharpener. Give me steel that I can sharpen easily. Vic and Leatherman (lower end) got this just right, IMO.
-
I STILL don't like semi-serrated blades.
Yeah... that's about it for now.
-
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
9) I can't understand a reason to get a 91mm SAK with plier layer when for virtually the same weight, you could get the Leatherman Style PS, which are much better pliers.But the Style PS is missing some important tools found on all 91mm SAKs with pliers, e.g. a knife blade for starters...
-
Which is why you COUPLE it with a 91mm SAK that doesn't have plier layer.
-
That's a whole lot of (mostly) clever thoughts

I have to agree with the OP somewhat - there is a Goldielocks zone, and most SAKs sit firmly in it. Best value tools out there really. Also a big fan of Moras for the money

As for OHO knives, I really do love the Spydie UKPK. I think it's excellent, and I have three to attest to my love of them! I didn't however pay new retail prices for them, which are a little over the top, especially over here where they are gratuitously inflated. I am however, more than happy to pay for them used, and have found them to be my go to knife despite delving in to other types.
As for slippies, I occasionally fall in love with something custom, maybe up to around £100-150 in price. This is a rare occurrence and in general I can resist. I don't see them as work horses though, more like pocket jewellery.
MT's? Anything goes! US prices on LM tools are fairly reasonable for what you get I think, but the Vic Spirit beats them all for quality in my mind. I love being able to play modding with tools like the Fuse though, and they can be picked up for very little too, which perhaps makes them more viable over all.
I also have a long term love affair with the KF4 which may be my favourite pocket MT ever.
Alox... like it very much, yes the prices are a bit silly for some now, but it's a lovely combo of trinket and tool, which pleases me quite a lot :D
That's all for now... I need to go and fondle some stuff and choose my EDC for the day

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login