What makes a great multitool?
-
Welcome to the forum
well the perfect mt
not as easy question as you might think as everyone's different as mentioned,personaly for me I've tried many mt's over years and started back in 98 with a original wave.really liked it as easy to use and cool looking :D i sent it in under warranty and it was changed the the newer wave,i liked many of its improvements but it was heavier and wider,I've tried lots of leathermans, sogs,a few gerbers,a few sak's and many others but my favourites are as follows,for the maintainence the surgs as like a tank and do usefully,my modded bladeless kick as a lightweight pocket carry,the original wave for packback carry ,still a classic,and last but no least the victorinox swisschamp as a real handy urban edc that pretty much does it allfor me a mt /sak needs cover most jobs but for me no just one mt can achieve this,so you end up with a few

-
I think, for most people weight and size is a huge concern.
WHile a LM Wavee or Swisstool Spirit approach perfection in Engineering Design and quality, they are still way to big for an average person to carry on an EDC-basis.
As we all now the truth in "the best tool is the tool you have with you", the first and foremost target is to have a compact and lightweight tool. It should be suitable for pocket- or even keychain carry.The next point on the list is usefulness. Most people won't carry a tool wich they don't need. Need is a bt difficult to define - a tool which is often needed might be around in the average houshold - and thus not needed on a multitool (like a spoon).
A tool wich is very unique but seldomly used won't get the same attention as an often used one (like an awl or can.opener).To me, it seems there are a few tools a typical multi tool should always have:
A blade (you kinda expect it and it comes in handy often)
Scissors (they are often needed and not easily replaced by other tools)
Screwdrivers flat and phillips/pozidirv (they are often needed and rarely quick at hand in an average household)Therefore, a simple victorinox will do most of the jobs, while beeing small and pocket friendly.
The crux with more capable tools is always, that they are bulky, too. Pliers rarely seem to be a good idea in an every-mans multitool as they are bulky and even though they are unique in their application, you don't need them that often.
I think, that the leatherman style gets it just about right. All the tools work pretty well (the blade is damn short though) and it gets a lot of jobs done. It's pretty compact, too (even tough i dont get the extra-layer just for the tweezers).
I think, the holy grail lies in a MT combo with a really small MT on your keychain, and a tool which only has the heavy-duty-stuff in your backpack.ANother point to consider, is that a MT is only useful if its readily at hand. There are many tasks, where a plier might be handy, but if it takes you longer to deploy your crunchs' pliers then the next guy to get you some usual pliers out of his toolbox, the MT might not be the first choice.
MTs should be easy AND FAST to use - so the least possible deploying work should be needed. I like the skeletool and its OHO blade and fixed bit-driver in that regard. -
A Leatherman Surge.
sent from Ducttapetech's mobile device
-
For me its the one that serves you best and can withstand all that you put it through, the only way to find out is lots of testing and spending. Oh and it HAS to be made in switzerland 8) :sak:
-
Hi, and welcome to the forum :D I think others here have pretty much answered your questions, and like they've said, it all comes down to personal preference. I can't claim that there is any one "best" multitool, but I have a few that I consider to be right up there for what I like. I have my "big 3" which are the Charge TTi, Spirit and Rebar. Lately I've been thinking I prefer the Rebar and Spirit, but the TTi is still an excellent choice with it's one hand opening blades and outside tools like saw and file. The Rebar and Spirit both have a great selection of tools and are fairly slim and nice to carry without feeling too bulky/heavy in my opinion.
My typical EDC lineup consists of a combo of one of the above MTs, a SAK and the Leatherman Crater c33 (to have a dedicated OHO blade). I don't need the Crater while carrying the Charge though. Basically, at the least I want a MT and SAK combo, which makes me feel prepared and covers anything I encounter. However, if I must be honest in what I actually need/use on most typical days, a SAK tends to be sufficient, and the MT basically just ends up sitting in my back pocket and only used occasionally for the pliers or locking tools. Of course my needs are different as I work in an office setting, which many wouldn't consider a MT as a necessity, but rather a SAK. I've found I have little real use for a full size MT, but I do like to have one on me as one never knows when it may prove handy. As many of us say, it's better to carry these things and not need them, than to need them and not have them handy

-
@xt60043f said:
Swisstool spirit X./thread
Actually ... looking now at the OP's site that he is doing the research for, I would probably agree with this choice. The Spirit X has beaten other tools in polls before here when "the unanswerable question" has been asked. Also, whilst it may not be the ideal tool for all users and all situations (no one tool is), the Swiss quality of manufacture, pocketable size, ergonomics and fantastic tool array would probably put this tool as being the best tool for the majority of day to day users.
If the OP is forced to choose just one tool to do an article on, the Spirit should probably be it - though with honourable mentions to Leatherman Wave/Charge series for the one hand opening tools and diamond file, Gerber's MP400 & 600 for the flicky pliers, and SOG's compound leverage to give a more rounded view of the tools on offer for those guys who need something a little different.
Thoughts anyone?
Oh ... and of course, a mention of the assistance you had from the wonderful crowd of people at multitool.org wouldn't go amiss either
;) :D :D :D -
The one tool to rule them all: "Credit Card"

For me its a folder: The blade is the one tool that has the most awesome utility to weight ratio :D
-
And lo this guy speaketh the truth:
(/post/756566)
-
The one with the best combination of **Included tools ** (number of decent, useful tools included; useful as specified by each person and need/situation ) and Portability (based on the fact that if you do not have it on or near you when you need it then it is not useful, portability again as specified by each person and situation, what he likes or is able to carry, whether he is in a car, in the house or in a swimming costume) for the current situation/need.
So a LM Micra, squirt, Victorinox manager may be fine if you are currently sitting in an office but not so good if you need to repair a car or a bike.
Have a look in the Review section too. -
Welcome to MT.O! :D
Everyone here are enthusiastic about their tools, and as you could see, already there are tons of variations and good read. So I will try to keep it simpler for the OP:
What qualities do you think make for a great multi-tool?
See below, question #4 answers this question #1 ;)
What tools have you used, and what do you currently use?
There are tools that I use and many are just for collection purpose. I mainly have used Victorinox and Leatherman tools in the past. Currently, I am carrying a Victorinox Spirit with me.
Where do you use them--ie, in the car, in the kitchen, in a tool box?
Mostly around house and work for easy fixing. If the task require many hours of work/repair, I probably will go get my toolbox.
What's most important: Materials, construction, ergonomics, or functions?
All of them.
I think nowadays we have enough choices on MT that we could afford to be picky. But if I really need to pick, "honesty".
I appreciate those companies who are honest about their products, a reasonable price tag for a good tool while maximizing those four qualities for their customers.Do you think there is a clear best multitool on the market right now?
I can't say I know enough to call it a 'clear winner', but I edc(every day carry) a Victorinox Spirit. And relevant to its price tag, build quality/material/ergonomics/functions are all satisfying to me.
I have a feeling this is going to be a loooong thread, but it's a fun read. >:D
-
What qualities do you think make for a great multi-tool?
I can't add anything to what everyone else has said.
What tools have you used, and what do you currently use?
I have used: Leatherman Kick, Wave, Rebar, Juice CS4, Skeletool, Squirt, Core; Gerber Dime; Victorinox Spartan, Tinker Small, Manager, Swisstool Spirit X; Woolworths crappy PST copy; Silverline fake Crunch; SOG Pocket Power Plier. I no longer have the Kick or Rebar (swapped the plier head out and gave it to my dad) and I think I've lost the PPP.
Currently attached to my keyring is a Vic Manager and on my belt is a modified Leatherman Wave - that's what I usually carry for work. For lighter work carry I sometimes take the Spirit in a pocket. Outside of work will depend on where I'm going, how many sheeple will be around and how knife tolerant the sheeple are likely to be. For lighter use it'll be the Tinker Small, through the Juice, Spirit and sometimes the Wave. If I want something light but with a half decent and reasonably tough knife then it might be the Skeletool.
Really, I rarely use the Squirt, and would never use the Dime in preference to the Squirt.
Where do you use them--ie, in the car, in the kitchen, in a tool box?
My biggest use is at work - carrying an MT is I suppose a bit lazy. There are many scenarios where I might have to go and look at a job that needs doing, find I need a tool to progress a bit further, go and get said tool, use it and then find I need another that it wasn't obvious I'd need earlier. Rinse and repeat a few times and I've spent more time walking around finding tools that I have doing the job and I've accumulated a large pile of tools. So why didn't I just take them to start with? Because they're heavy, I'd probably have taken the wrong ones and I probably wasn't anywhere near any tools when the need to do the job arose.
Carrying an MT means that in my initial run to scout out what tools I'm likely to need to solve a problem, I can fix 95% of things without having to make multiple trips all around the site to find the correct tool for the job. Despite saving me lots of time and therefore my boss lots of money, he still laughs at me for having one. For me, the one big feature my Wave is missing is a multimeter ;)
If I knew I was starting a big job then I'd usually go an get the right tools. If I'm building a control panel, then I have my wire strippers, small screwdrivers, crimpers etc in my workshop. If I knew I was dismantling an engine then I'd go and fetch a socket set. If I didn't know or needed something for a quick fix, then I'd use an MT. I don't really see the point of putting an MT in a tool box - you should really be keeping the individual tools there. You might keep one in a kitchen drawer though. Before someone walked off with it I did keep my Woolworths PST clone in my tool box as a bit of a beater and loan tool.
FWIW, I store my Core in my car for car related emergencies but for routine car stuff then I'd just park it in the farm workshop which has a whole workshop full of proper tools.
What's most important: Materials, construction, ergonomics, or functions?
Everything to a certain minimum level. As has been said, I don't need my blade to be an absolutely top notch wonder steel so long as it hold a decent enough edge. At the end of the day I've cut through and shaved thin mild steel with my Wave's blade (to get me out of a muddle - I was miles from anywhere, had left my hole punches at home and was trying to fit something in to a panel with a hole saw that was slightly too small. The Wave's blade made "slightly too small" in to "just fits"). In some scenarios it can be better to have fewer functions - see the Skeletool - however for primary work carry for me, my Wave is more useful.
I said I'd modified it, in my case that means I changed the plier head for the Rebar's (thanks to Metro for all his pictures!) to get a set of tougher and more abuse resistant wire cutters, I removed the never used saw to give me somewhere to store an extra long Phillips screwdriver bit and I swapped the scissors for a long thin flat driver from a Fuse that I made thinner to fit nicely in to electrical terminal blocks - something that I regularly encounter. So I guess the most important thing is not the number of functions, it's the right functions. You may now be wondering why I didn't just stick with a Rebar which has the small flat driver and a Phillips with decent reach - well I tried but I just hated not having the OHO blade from the Wave. When you've got your hands full or are in a hurry (me, most of the time) it's a big deal.
Do you think there is a clear best multitool on the market right now?
No, but the shortlist I'd come up with would be the Rebar, Spirit X and Wave/Charge. If I was buying a gift for some of my colleagues on the farm I'd get them a Rebar. If I was buying a gift for one of my friends that, whilst they may be extremely practical and give an MT heavy use it wouldn't quite be farm level abuse, then it would probably be the Spirit. I don't know who I'd buy the Wave for, but it's what I've based my main MT on!
-
Thank you for such great answers!
-
For me it's quality and implement density , Spirit and Swisstool for the win !
Chris
-
Dunno about what makes a **great **multitool, but I do know what is the **best **multitool...
drum roll
The one that you have with you when needed ;)
-
What qualities do you think make for a great multi-tool?
Fit, finish, durability, functional utility, and functional density
What tools have you used, and what do you currently use?
I use mostly Victorinox and Leatherman, but have also tried others, including Bear & Son, IDL, and Swisstech.
Where do you use them--ie, in the car, in the kitchen, in a tool box?
In addition to what I carry on my person, I have them stashed in various locations around the house and in my vehicles. If I have to break out the toolbox or make a trip to the toolbox, I will be getting the proper dedicated tools.
What's most important: Materials, construction, ergonomics, or functions?
This is like asking which leg of a table is the most important. They are all important.
Do you think there is a clear best multitool on the market right now?
This is like asking what the best clothing is. The answer is that it depends on the individual, the situation, the location, planned activities, etc. However, with regard to fit, finish, and quality of craftsmanship, I consider the Victorinox Swisstool and Spirit the standard by which all others are judged.
-
@bmot said:
Oooh, the question of questions. I'll first tell you the chance you'll get one simple answer is, well, zero. Lots of opinions here on this, but it'll all be honest opinions after trying out a lot of things, not much real 'fanboys' of brands around here.I'll try to give my own personal answers here. I'm not that long into MT's, but I found some things.
**- What qualities make a great MT?
**Well, that's a good one. I think a multitool has a few things that are important. For me, a multitool has to be there when I'm in need of tools, but can't of won't carry a toolbox with me. I want one to be with me everywhere, so I can take care of things I couldn't without any tools. So, therefor, portability is an important part for me.
Besides that, I want it to carry the tools that I need, preferably easy to get to, too. I think I'll call that user-friendliness. It means that you can easily get to the things you need, and it doesn't hold you back. Of course, if you paste many tools into one, some user-friendliness gets sacrificed. The length of your saw, of size of your file is gonna get smaller.
Last is the fact that I want my tools to work without needing too much maintenance. It's a tool, and of course, it'll need some TLC from time to time, but it should not be needed to oil and clean your MT every week, so to say. I want it to be ready when I need it, but like it's not there when I don't. This is a weak spot for (certainly newer) Leatherman tools, which tend to rust easily. Not something I like to see on a tool.
**- What tools have you used and currently use?
**I started carrying MT's a few years ago, with a Leatherman Wave. I loved it, used it a lot, then I lost it. In search for a replacement, I found this place, and well, everything was lost, so to say ::)
Momentarily, I have three or for tools in use that I carry and use a lot: The Leatherman Rebar for just normal "Every day" carry (EDC). Very capable tool, real workhorse, I like it a lot.
For those jobs that require a little bit more, I have a Swisstool. Real shiny, a size bigger than the Rebar, and thus stronger. The Swisstools and Swisstool Spirits are well known for how beautiful they are, and for surviving anything you throw at them.
For days I like a lighter carry, or prefer to have nothing on my belt, I have a Leatherman Skeletool. Clips to the pocket with a handy pocketclip, has just pliers, a one handed opening knifeblade and a screwdrivers, very lightweight and compact, nice to pocketcarry.
For really lightweight carry (think swimshorts or with a suit) I have a Victorinox Tinker Small Swiss army knife.
I have more, but those don't use them as much as these three. Of course, I do a lot of pairing up, mainly with Swiss Army Knives (SAK).
Pff... I should really go to sleep now, I'll continue this later ;)
Oh, yes still had to finish this

**Where do you use them? **
I carry my tools almost everywhere, but using really just depends, wherever necessary. I use my tools when I'm doing some jobs. I don't have one in the car, mainly because I always have a tool on me, and because I simply don't know enough about cars to be able to fix anything, anyway. I could do some things, but mostly, a multitool doesn't work in a car so well, anyway.
But, my MT's get used most on those odd jobs that one can encounter during the day, like fastening a loose screw, quick fixes, or cutting stuff.What's the most important: Materials, construction, ergo, or functions?
Like it's been said by many others before me, all of these are important, but I want to add one more thing: portability. I said this in the first part already, but it's somehow quite logical. If it's not portable enough, then you won't carry it, so it won't be on you when you need the tool, rendering the tool useless. Like what has been said before: the best tool is the one you have with you.
Do you think there is a clear best multitool on the market right now?
I don´t, as for everyone, opinions differ so much, that there´s not a single best multitool for everyone around. Some want heavy duty multi´s they carry on a belt, some won´t carry anything more heavy than a Leatherman Micra.
Besides that, I think there are two or three, that, for a "regular" (non-MT-nut) user, there are a few "bests"For fit and finish, and the very good tool-density, the Swisstool Spirit is one of the best. I like it better than the original Swisstool, mainly because of the (seems for me) better thought out tools.
For the OHO blades, and smart bit screwdrivers, I like the Leatherman Wave/Charge series. There's a reason they're probably the most popular tools around ;)
Also, I don't own any, personally, but I really like the looks of the SOG Powerlock. Very capable tools, maybe not as refined as others, but good for hard work, even more so with the 2.0 model, which has the gearcovers for when using the inner tools.I didn't mention Gerber, I know. I've tried some of their tools, and though they are very capable, I personally don't like them as much as other tools. I've never had one break on me, or not perform well, but I somehow just don't like the feel of them, and some choices they made, like the plastic lock covers, and things like that.
Well, I hope this was helpful, and I want to repeat: the best tool around, is the one you have with you when you need it

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

