benchmark for sharpness? How sharp is too sharp?
-
What is your benchmark for being sharp enough? Can a knife be too sharp?
For most of my life, if my edge would grab hair or slice hair off my arm, I was happy. I typically left a relatively "toothy" edge on my blades. I found that those micro serrations really helped to slice through rope, meat, tomatoes, whatever.
More recently, my benchmark has become hair splitting sharp. When a hair dragged lightly across the blade splits the hair, I stop. This is fantastic for push cutting almost anything... but I find that for slicing, the blade has a tendency to slide across some things rather than biting in. Ripe tomatoes are a great example.
There's a certain sense of accomplishment in knowing that I got my knife that sharp. That mirror edge looks wonderful. I'm just not sure it's the most useful edge for my working knives.
What say you, fellow SAK-a-holics? How sharp is too sharp?
Sam
-
I am not a knife expert, and I too am working on my sharpening skill. But I think the answer will be dependent on a lot of factors, and might not be a standard one.
Depending on the use of the knife, its design/geometry/steel or factory spec, the angle for sharpening will be different and probably the cutting ability will be different. Nowadays, without knowing the depth of sharpening art, I pretty much still stick to the factory spec since I believe most of them probably know how their products should work better than me. :)
How sharp is sharp? Personally, I think arm-hair-shaving sharp for my SAK is decent and already pretty good for general use.

-
A knife or tool I carry gets the Lansky treatment, but only with grits 2 and 4 out of the five. I found that any extra grits being used just increase the sharpening time, but the cutting doesn't improve (at least I can't tell the difference). Afterwards I strop them briefly on the back of an old leather belt.
Kitchen knives I just pull occasionally through the "fine" side of an Edgemaker Pro that lives in the kitchen drawer. Those edges seem perfect for general food prep, but I dislike the fact that the stick sharpeners always leave a 1/4" or so of only partially sharpened blade near the tang. Picky, I know, but that's how I feel. Not that I am ever going to use that 1/4"....
-
I don't try for any form of precision sharpness, just to get the knife usable safely without having to use force. I also leave a toothy edge as I find this more useful. Many knife oriented people may consider my knives not sharp enough .... but they're not the ones using it ;)
-
There are several benchmarks regarding hair splitting. But those depend on the hairs itself and are mostly used for determining the sharpness of razor knifes.
If you can shave your arm hairs with your SAK i think it's for most people sharp enough. For myself: If I can hold a piece of paper in one hand and can slice little stripes of that paper with my SAK it's enough for me.
-
Dry shave arm hairs with no tugging is my minimum standard. Lansky crock stick sharpener. Stropping gets the blade even sharper. No such thing as "too sharp". :-\
-
Since the Lansky crock stick sharpener is mentioned, I do recommend to anyone interested to look into the Spyderco Triangle Sharpmaker(also get the ultrafine stones), that is probably one of the best sharpening investment I have made. Very easy to use/touchup, and even get to shaving sharp.
A more portable version is the Lansky turnbox, which could also compliment the sharpmaker quite well.
Of course, a wicked edge is probably the best I could recommend, but with that great tool, comes more practice and more reward.
-
@50ft-trad said:
I don't try for any form of precision sharpness, just to get the knife usable safely without having to use force. I also leave a toothy edge as I find this more useful. Many knife oriented people may consider my knives not sharp enough .... but they're not the ones using it ;)That explains why you are such a fan of carrying scissors around :P
:D
-
@50ft-trad said:
I don't try for any form of precision sharpness, just to get the knife usable safely without having to use force. I also leave a toothy edge as I find this more useful. Many knife oriented people may consider my knives not sharp enough .... but they're not the ones using it ;)
That explains why you are such a fan of carrying scissors around :P
:D
There's nothing wrong with carrying a nice pair of Vic scissors

-
I knife that can easily shave arm hair and cut paper is what I consider sharp enough for normal use.
The main thing is to be able to easily cut stuff that you want to cut, if you can do that then you have a knife that is sharp enough. -
What do you think about the Victorinox Pocket Sharpener? Does anyone around here use one of those? Is it durable? Does it give a good edge? Is it able to sharpen the small blades entirely, or does it leave a small part of the blade unsharpened?
-
@50ft-trad said:
I don't try for any form of precision sharpness, just to get the knife usable safely without having to use force. I also leave a toothy edge as I find this more useful. Many knife oriented people may consider my knives not sharp enough .... but they're not the ones using it ;)
That explains why you are such a fan of carrying scissors around :P
:D
Just spotted this
:D :DFor a long time I was knife only, literally just a single or double bladed traditional pocket knife. When I decided to try carrying a SAK regularly I specifically went for a Tourist because I thought scissors weren't necessary. Once I had tried carrying scissors for a while though, I didn't want to go back. Scissors just make things so much easier, and that's what it's all about, right?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login