What popular tools have you decided are NOT for you ...?
-
Leatherman Juice seems to have quite a following, I'm not one of them. I'd rather have a Charge or a Skeletool if it has to be lighter duty. I only tried the S2 for EDC and it did not fit the bill.
-
Good topic!
I'm a huge fan of Leathermans however, I have found that I really don't like Juices. The pliers get loose in the pivot too easily, the flat drivers are simply torturous. After some use, they become difficult to deploy and the can opener is next to useless.

Wingman/Sidekick: They could have been great with minimal extra effort.

OHT: I just don't get it.
On to Victorinox:
If I didn't work with oil, diesel, grease or hydraulic fluid all the time, the Spirit would be a good tool. My wife loves hers. The handles get so damned slick, it becomes a major problem holding onto the tool.111 mm Vics with backside Phillips. This thread explains why

SAK's with the little tiny flashlight. WTF?
CRKT: The Zilla and Zilla Jr. Actually the Zilla Jr is a nice little tool IF it used standard 1/4 inch bits.
The fullsized Zilla is just big and not all that functional.SOG: I hated my PowerLocks from the get go. The tool covers are a PITA. The tools aside from the pliers are flimsy and bend too easily. And that damned little spring on the 1/4 bit driver. I love the concept but not the spring.
Spyderco: Spyderench/Byrdrench. Looks cool, but nothing on it works well.

As far as one piece tools, the Shard never did it for me. Just too limited.
That's about it.
For now. :D
-
Great idea for a topic Al

There have been a lot of good points made for most of the MTs, SAKs and even a few knives. I really have an issue with most of the Gerber products. My first real MT was a Mr. Pinchy in the early 90s when they were released. Mine only lasted two weeks IIRC before falling apart on the job
I've had a few of there knives and have just not been impressed with their quality. I own the Big Game Cleaning Kit by them and really haven't had too many complaints with it since buying it more than ten years ago and I use it regularly during most of the year during the major hunting seasons. I don't really talk much about it on here because I don't frequent the Gerber forums.I don't own any SOG MTs, probably because of the lack of interest in them. I had no interest in the LM Juice line until I got a S2 at the end of last year and now own that one, a Kf4 and a Pro. I mostly have the Heavy Duty LMs and that's what I needed when I was in the military. Now that I'm retired, I don't really need the heavys, I just like them because of the feel they bring and that's what I'm use to. I also came to the table of MT.O only owning two SAKs, a Swiss Champ and what I thought was a Climber but now realize is a Huntsman (stupid hiding saw
) and I haven't really 'caught' the SAK bug, yet :D . I've since gotten a Vic Classic, Vic MiniChamp and the Wenger BO10 LE 7th Anny. That's not too bad compared to most that I've seen here buying SAKs (not a bad thing by any means folks, keep buying if you can do that). With that being said, I really don't have a great desire to own too many more. I found the one piece game isn't really for me either thanks to the Tofty Tool Pass Around (which was awesome btw!¡!) that some of us did in the first part of the year. I like the tools and all but find myself grabbing for the full sized or heavy duty stuff more often. As far as edges on blades, I really don't like the combo edged blade at all. I had to have one in Iraq when I tried to cut out curtains in a Mercedes with a plain edged blade that didn't work because of the thick textile type fabric (I keep a razor edge on all my blades). That was the CRKT Crawford Kasper my son now owns. It wasn't a bad knife but it wasn't what I prefer in a knife blade. For me, it's either all serrated or all plain edge, they both have a purpose just not a CE for me thanks. It's the same for me in the MT realm of blades..........no CE blades (Flair!¡!)
I have no desire for the LM Anniversary/ Limited Edition tools ether.I buy MTs/ SAKs to use, not to look at. I own nine retired tools and have them all in some sort of use. Other LMs that I have no need for are the Skeletool series, Wingman/ Sidekick, Style Series, Hail and Rime.Enough of my rambling......................... NEXT!¡!
-
Well, my experience is limited to Leatherman and Victorinox primarily, and one Wenger (EvoGrip16). Of the ones I've owned, the only one I can say was any disappointment was the LM Freestyle. It was an impulse buy, and it was ok, but nothing that impressed me. The blade was decent, but I didn't end up liking the shape of the pliers, or the ergonomics of the handles. This would also apply to the Skeletool since it's basically the same thing only with a bit driver and carabiner. I don't think I'd be a big fan of the LM OHT either as it just looks big and awkward to me, despite the fact it's supposed to be more convenient with all the OHO tools.
I don't think I'd be a fan of any SAK thicker than my Ranger Plus either. There was a time when I would have thought that was too thick, but I don't think I'd want anything thicker.
I have no experience with Gerber or SOG, but I probably never will either

-
To be honest, I haven't found a complete dud yet. While I usually carry a SAK, currently a four layer mod (an Explorer Plus with a saw and fine screwdriver instead of the scissors and hook) and a LM PS4 on my keys, with a Crunch coming along if I'm carrying a bag or expect I'll have to fix something, I still find time and occasion to use others I've picked up along the way. While the Juice series has some drawbacks I still quite like my KF4 and take it on hikes. My SOG PPP, while it does have some less than stellar inside tools, is lightweight and has powerful pliers, so it gets thrown in a pocket or bag on certain occasions. Even my LM Mini-tool fills a niche for me. Perhaps the closest I've come to acquiring a tool that didn't work out was the Charge TTI. That stubby phillips let me down in the past, the pliers head isn't my cup of tea, no awl, it has a clunky feel to me. It's a great tool for many reasons but it just never clicked with me. It now belongs to my wife who keeps it in her toolkit and takes it on jobs.
-
@enki_ck said:
<u>Charges, any of them</u>. added bulk of the scale slabs, no extra benefit of them. It makes the tool thick and the pocketclip can't ride as low as it does on the Wave anymore. The cap crimpers really don't belong on an EDC multi. I wish they offered the same options they do Charges in the Wave format. Wave with a S30v blade, Wave ALX with a 154cm blade and double bit drivers, Wave AL, ...I too would love a wave with a 154cm blade, I mean who would't want a pocket tool that packs a sword-blade in such a tiny frame :D
Wenger, never really liked their design
I think **Vic **would do well to bring something new to the table. I mean there is nothing wrong with a proven design but there should always be some "evolution". Victorinox doesn't list weight for good reason the 111mm line is heavy as leadshoes. -
Victorinox minichamp. It has many things I do not need on a tool of that size (or even a bigger one)
SOGs in general, after last years problem with the Powerduo (though it is now used regularly since I keep it in a car's glove compartment)
Gerber steady, great idea with several issues.
LM newer squirts (e.g. PS4) and Waves. I just do not "click" with them
Swisstools - they are just too prety for me to use.
Ganzo, again I never really "clicked" with them and have many other options.
-
@stealth007s said:
I really don't like the combo edged blade at all. I had to have one in Iraq when I tried to cut out curtains in a Mercedes with a plain edged blade that didn't work because of the thick textile type fabric (I keep a razor edge on all my blades). That was the CRKT Crawford Kasper my son now owns. It wasn't a bad knife but it wasn't what I prefer in a knife blade. For me, it's either all serrated or all plain edge, they both have a purpose just not a CE for me thanks. It's the same for me in the MT realm of blades..........no CE blades (Flair!¡!)
Another flair to that! Too often I found CE edge with the serration close to the handle, exactly where I might start cutting and everything got caught! If there is a choice between PE or SE or CE, I did go just straight for just the plain edge. Serrated edge is ok, if it is an additional blade to a PE blade. The only CE that I could merely tolerate the the 111mm Victorinox German Army Knife, where the serration is at the tip of the blade, and the plain edge close to the handle.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
On to Victorinox:
If I didn't work with oil, diesel, grease or hydraulic fluid all the time, the Spirit would be a good tool. My wife loves hers. The handles get so damned slick, it becomes a major problem holding onto the tool.Personally, I do like the Swisstool Spirit a lot, and I find the Black oxide version offers a lot more handle grip than the stainless steel version. If you do like Spirit, may wanna give that a try.
-
Gerber. Loved the MP400, until it rusted after a light rain shower.
Leatherman. Hate floppy handles.
Sog. Like the pliers, hated the internal tools.
-
All Gerbers. I hate the "fancy" factor enough for never trying one.
All "tactical" camo/ black oxide, tanto etc blades (dedicated or multitools). I already worry if police ever finds what I EDC, how would I explain that military look?
All tools with titanium and gold and exotic materials. Stainless steel is all I need.
All SAKs and Multitools with the bare essentials. I can do without one tool (ie the scissors on my Spirit, since I already have scissors somewhere else on me) but what to do with a SAK/Multi with no file/ saw/ scissors/ philips/ awl etc? I use these tools. Since most times I have a full feature SAK with me, I can go with a single blade knife with more edge real estate.
All Wengers, except the 120-130mm line. The 85mmn are smaller than the 91mm Vics and that was a handicap for them (compare the Philips for example).
All non Swiss "SAKs". Why buy a Chinese disaster when SAKs are so cheap? Moreover, why buy a Spanish or German "SAK" when the Swiss are better and even cheaper (and easier to find). -
@Mr. Whippy said:
On to Victorinox:
If I didn't work with oil, diesel, grease or hydraulic fluid all the time, the Spirit would be a good tool. My wife loves hers. The handles get so damned slick, it becomes a major problem holding onto the tool.Personally, I do like the Swisstool Spirit a lot, and I find the Black oxide version offers a lot more handle grip than the stainless steel version. If you do like Spirit, may wanna give that a try.
The BO Spirit indeed offers more grip than the stainless one, and another thing about the BO version, it looks more like a tool ... I mean, the first Spirit I bought, I was affraid to use because it just looked so nice. Now that I have a couple of them, I have one I carry every day and which sees a lot of use, and it has some scars to prove it, which also has its charms. But for some strange reason, it's easier to use a brand new BO than it is to use a brand new stainless version in my opinion.
Now, on topic, I wanted to say the Rebar, as some of you may know, I had some issues with my first Rebar, and the one I got in return was also a dud, so I decided I would never buy another Rebar ... but I found myself staring at one at a local outdoorshop just this weekend, I have some store credit from that shop and all the sudden, the Rebar came to mind ... So I'm not yet sure if I want to add the Rebar to this "special" list.
The ones I am sure about (that I'll never buy) are the Wingman/Sidekick, they just don't feel ... right (can't explain why, just don't like them). The OHT is another one I can add to the list, I would like one just to have one in my collection, but I already know I would never carry it (and since my funds are very low these last months, I can no longer buy tools which I know I'll never use, like my MUT a few years ago ...).
Same goes for most of the Gerbers, I have one (an old multiplier) and I think one is enough ...
Leatherman Juice/Squirt are also not for me, I always carry a plier based tool (Spirit/ST300/Wave) combined with a Sak, so I feel there's no reason for me to get a Juice or Squirt.
And last but not least, I don't think I'll ever buy a 84-93 mm SAK without scissors (one of the main reasons why I carry a SAK along with a tool like the ST300, or maybe ... the Rebar ... I can see where this is going to ... ::)).
Just my 2 cents ;).
-
So far the only ones I've had and didn't really get along with were a Juice CS4, and an S2.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk 4
-
Some excellent responses
and I agree with much of what's been said (though I cropped out the ones I'd differ on in the quotes below)@enki_ck said:
<u>Wingman/Sidekick</u> - really? Even the initial "might get one to try out eventually" feeling was squashed with the ad campaign LM had for these and poisoned them for me. Whenever I hear/read any of these two names one of these images jumps in my head and I say NO. :P

<u>Freestyle</u> - Why? The original Freestyle concept made sense, this one, not so much. The Juice line already fills this slot and has the drivers too in the same size format, but a lighter package, with more tools, and yet, better pliers.
<u>MUT/OHT</u> not my cup of

<u>SOG:</u> Pliers rock, everything else, :-\ One of the most used tool on a multi for me are the screwdrivers, and the phillips on the SOG does not inspire confidence.
<u>Powerassist</u> - why would one need an assisted knife on a multitool?
<u>EOD models</u> -
<u>SAKs with backlayered phillips drivers.</u> If it's not ALOX, then it should have a corkscrew! :P I only own one SAK with a back layered phillips and that one came in a lot with other proper SAKs. ;)
<u>Victorinox:</u>
<u>108mm GAK</u> - the saw, the torture
<u>111mm OH models</u> -
they do nothing for me. Especially the Dual Pro/Hunter models with TWO OHO blades.<u>Wenger:</u>
<u>EVO anything</u> - Why, Wenger, why? So much added bulk, not ergonomic at all, never could understand it.
Totally agree on all these (cropped list)

@kirk13 said:
Of the tools I Havnt tried... LM OHT...it's ugly and its mother dressed it funny. Just don't get why LM had to build a Gerber
.
Absolutely :D Not to mention the stubby blades and blatantly WRONG tag line .... how are they even managing to carry that one off?LM Skeletool; the blade is OK, but everything else just didn't work for me. Not a fan of the fiddly LM bits and the ergonomics of the pliers was just horrible for me.
Forgot about the Skeli!
Just found it lacked utility. Every time I carried it,I needed something it didnt have

I fully agree. I always needed something that the skeletool was missing: can opener, file, scissors are my biggies. I like the blade and the cap lifter, but that is basically all the Skeletool has to offer. I hate the pliers. The bit driver requires the entore tool to be opened - I don't like that either.
Well said chaps

@sawman said:
What about <u>one-piece key ring tools</u>? IMO, many of those are awkward on the verge of being un-useable...Good call! As I said in another thread recently ...
@50ft-trad said:
... The ergonomics are horrible, and if you carry it in your pocket you're liable to puncture/rip the pocket - or worse, part of your body. To use any of the drivers (integral or as an add on), you need a large amount of clearance around the tool, and if the screws are recessed at all you're out of luck before you start. Frequently these tools are made out of a material that is wholly inapropriate for the tool style (ti or alu, or cast materials). To get the most out of it, you can't use it on it's own, you actually need a tin or bag of additional accessories - and if you have got a tin or bag with the extras in, there are far better ways of using those accesories than with this.@Mr. Whippy said:
Good topic!I'm a huge fan of Leathermans however, I have found that I really don't like Juices. The pliers get loose in the pivot too easily, the flat drivers are simply torturous. After some use, they become difficult to deploy and the can opener is next to useless.

OHT: I just don't get it.
CRKT: The Zilla and Zilla Jr. Actually the Zilla Jr is a nice little tool IF it used standard 1/4 inch bits.
The fullsized Zilla is just big and not all that functional.SOG: I hated my PowerLocks from the get go. The tool covers are a PITA. The tools aside from the pliers are flimsy and bend too easily. And that damned little spring on the 1/4 bit driver. I love the concept but not the spring.
Can't argue with any of this cropped list, except I don't like the Zilla Jnr either. As for the Spydie stuff I can't comment, though I actually think the "Spyderguppie" as named by Bob is not a bad little tool :D
Vic 111mm with backspring is the doomed culmination of two failed concepts in my mind :P
@dks said:
Victorinox minichamp. It has many things I do not need on a tool of that size (or even a bigger one)Gerber steady, great idea with several issues.
Totally agree on the Mnichamp, and totally *forgot *about the Steady

@Top-Gear-24 said:
And last but not least, I don't think I'll ever buy a 84-93 mm SAK without scissors
-
Anything Atwood - I don't get it, but maybe I don't appreciate the artistic merit???
Anything in titanium - I can't afford them so maybe my budget is keeping me from seeing the great aspect of anything made with titanium???
-
Al, what about the ones you don't agree on? :D I expected at least a couple of
-s for a few of them. :D -
@enki_ck said:
Al, what about the ones you don't agree on? :D I expected at least a couple of
-s for a few of them. :DI expected a
for some of mine too :D and I have been surprised at a few people's answers, but I'm not going to challenge them over it. If a tool doesn't work for you, it's irrelevant how popular it is. That's the whole point of the thread :PI think some folks can be a little quick to prejudge a tool if they haven't held/used one :-, though sometimes I can be the same so I can't really
for that either :DOh ... and another couple that come to mind ...
SOG Paratool - keeps the half arsed implements, loses the excellent compound leverage, and adds pliers that fold over ... :-\
Leathermac Crunch - the blade, the file, the fact you have to assemble the tool to use it ... NO!!!
-
I like the Skeletool. It's one of the few tools with a permanent place in my bicycle's seat bag. It's really super handy having reasonably big pliers in such a small form factor without giving up the multi-driver. Also, the wire cutters can handle spokes. Really.
On the other hand. I've handled a Surge, and I could never carry one, even in my satchel. The thing is a brick with pliers in.
-
@Jothra said:
I like the Skeletool. It's one of the few tools with a permanent place in my bicycle's seat bag. It's really super handy having reasonably big pliers in such a small form factor without giving up the multi-driver. Also, the wire cutters can handle spokes. Really.On the other hand. I've handled a Surge, and I could never carry one, even in my satchel. The thing is a brick with pliers in.
I completely agree with this. The Skeletool is perfect for backpacking, climbing, cycling, etc where you want a full sized pliers, multiple drivers and minimal weight. I also agree that the Surge is just too big. I like the large flat driver, but that's about it. Everything else can be done with a Charge or Wave with significant weight/size savings.
-
Wave, Surge and the like- I feel like I'm about to slice my thumbprint off with the way the blades are setup. I've carried just about every combination of hole/stud/disk/et al and lock combination you can find for a one handed opener and those are the only ones I've never felt comfortable with.
Oddly enough, I like the one on the Skeletool.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login