Scissor test
-
I think I may have a bone to pick with Nutnfancy. I'd rather hear feedback from several owners, over one of his tests alone. Nothing wrong with his tests, but the final word should be reserved to those with with the most experience.
-
I'm not sure where Nutnfancy came into this...

In the original post, I linked to a video by TheLateBoyscout, who does some decent reviews. I watch his, Nutnfancy, Cutlerylover... really whoever puts out a review on tools. Everyone has points to make, and perspectives to bring. I don't agree with all of them, but surprisingly, I often agree with a lot of them.
I find the cult of TNP more than a little annoying. And I find people emulating his style in video making to be SUPER annoying, particularly when you hear a 12-year-old saying 'Just keeping it REAL'.
I don't expect anyone to take THESE findings as anything more than additional data points. All I can say with this is that this is MY experience with the tools I've had in-hand. These are not based on someone else's opinion. I've even tried to remove my OWN opinion, as far as I could. It's a little odd to me how a tool is remembered compared to how it fares when tested side-by-side with another tool.
I started this as a way to answer something for myself: Is there a pair of scissors out there that's better than the SOG Crosscut (that I knew I'd need to replace due to 15 years of hard use). Scissors are the tool I need the most, use the most, and care about the most. Now, it's a matter of figuring what compromises I want to make to have good scissors with the best combination of additional tools possible in the lowest weight possible. Man, I LOVE MTs! Is it sick that I find this stuff fun? :D
-
Like any 12 year old know what "real" is ::)
I had an S2 which I really didn't like the scissors on. Now I have an XE6 on the way, I'm really hoping I can learn to love them :)
-
Damn good set of tests ! Thanks Lynn
-
This is a very informative thread. Thanks for keeping it real Lynn. :D
-
Great thread! Someone lend Lynn LeFey a Gerber Flik please!

-
Here's a link to Cupboard's 'Great British MTO cable tie scissor test'.

</topic/47299
-
Bit of a contrast between a balanced and broad ranging test with a decent scoring system to a few blokes in a field with a pile of MTs and cable ties :D
Good shout linking the two and thank you!
-
While it's kind of you to say, I'd actually consider multiple people performing the same test a setup with much less personal bias. And your scoring system was the same as mine. AND I'd mentioned earlier that I'd overlooked the ip-tie test, which is another real-world test for MT scissors.
You blokes did great. Except I didn't get any beer, so...

-
I've had a couple Juices, and the scissors were the same. Middle-bottom of the pack. I mean, I WISHED they were good, because the S2 form factor is awesome.
-
What's wrong with your scissors?
-
I'm not sure how to say this without sounding snarky, but if you'd read this entire thread, admittedly a long one, you'd know.
For fast reference, here's where I posted my test results for the juice.
</post/608364>In short, they're about as good as a HEAVILY USED pair of scissors on a 58mm vic classic... if you're RIGHT handed. Which I'm not. If you're left handed, they're only good for the easiest materials I tested (paper, PETE plastic bottle, and non-corrugated cardboard), and are either bad or completely fail every other material I tested.
Here's the last post in this thread where I posted all of the test numbers in order. While I marked it as 'used', I later got another Juice to test, which WASN'T used, and got the same results.
http://forum.multitool.org/index.php?action=post;topic=36798.75;last_msg=776751If it happens twice I have to assume the scissors are just bad across the line, and I'm not hearing anything from other folks refuting that.
If all you use them for is light cutting, they may work fine for you, but the tests I did involve some pretty serious cutting tasks, which the Juice scissors simply aren't up to, and as a particular strike against them for ME, is that they're worse for lefties. In fact, nothing but cheap knock-offs (And SOG's atrocious excuse for scissors) were worse.
-
Which is why I followed up with links to the posts in question.
I actually don't expect everyone to hang on every RIVETING word I type. I mean, sure, it'd be NICE, but ...

-
Juice scissors are a hell of a lot better than Wingman scissors!
-
I don't have a problem with that, I just have problems with them pushing whatever I'm cutting all the way out of the jaws.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login